Page 1 of 3

biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 17:04
by cakes
For me boxing is a very lot to do with how hard ya can bang, and who else could bang harder than the one and only prince naseem hamed :TU: any others ????????

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 17:08
by Dioufy
Is that you, Nas?

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 17:09
by palooka
I was watching a youtube montage thingy of Nonito Donaire yesterday and that man is frightening.

(Julian Jackson and Terry Norris were by far the most powerful and fastest hitters I've seen; I'm still not sure how they didn't kill someone).

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 17:09
by palooka
Dioufy wrote:Is that you, Nas?
Is that you John? :)

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 17:11
by Dioufy
simon fox wrote:
Dioufy wrote:Is that you, Nas?
Is that you John? :)
:box:

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 17:13
by palooka
:D

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 17:20
by cakes
Dioufy wrote:Is that you, Nas?
I wish :bow:

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 19:29
by Jeff Thomas
Biggest hitters i've seen from these shores were Wayne Alexander and Nas- they had weird power. They were pioneers in terms of results - always chinning people who hadn't been stopped etc...

World level, I think Jackson is the obvious choice but Felix Trinidad carried his power up well too.

Norris was a funny choice Simon- yep a big puncher but surely more noted for his skills. Top fighter though

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 21:03
by lefty
Randall bailey is a guy who springs to mind

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 23:30
by fasteddie
i dont think anyone carried a punch through the division's like thomas "hitman" hearns

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 24 Feb 2011, 23:40
by fasteddie
The Dark Destroyer wrote:
fasteddie wrote:i dont think anyone carried a punch through the division's like thomas "hitman" hearns
Manny Pacquaio has a case, he's carried his power through several divisions. Knocking Hatton/Cotto and Margarito about the way he has still shocks me.
yer true,when i think of punches tho i think of the old days i never think of the here and now,i think in todays boxing there is only manny who knocks people out in devastating fashion :box:

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 04:32
by CiganoBoxer
I read in a boxing mag once that Emanuel Stewart said that Naseem Hamed was one of the hardest punchers he ever held the mits for :bag:

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 04:55
by lefty
The Dark Destroyer wrote:
fasteddie wrote:i dont think anyone carried a punch through the division's like thomas "hitman" hearns
Manny Pacquaio has a case, he's carried his power through several divisions. Knocking Hatton/Cotto and Margarito about the way he has still shocks me.
I dont think that manny is really a one punch ko artist though,i know he knocked hatton out brutally but his he tends to knock people out with an accumalation of shots and a high volume,dont get me wrong though he's still a big puncher.

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 04:58
by pyenest77
An absolute no contest IMO. Julian Jackson the hardest puncher I have ever seen.

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 05:04
by Josh1111
What about the later Edwin Valero? That man was an absolute beast

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 05:11
by lefty
Josh1111 wrote:What about the later Edwin Valero? That man was an absolute beast
x 2 ....also david lemiuex the canadian middleweight prospect has alot of power

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 05:27
by bigjack
pyenest77 wrote:An absolute no contest IMO. Julian Jackson the hardest puncher I have ever seen.

Without a doubt,the amount of opponents that he put down for the full count was amazing,many of them unconcious :box:

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 06:14
by Happy Slapper
David Haye has to be the biggest puncher and probably biggest pound for pound puncher in boxing today.

Naz had incredible power in his day.

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 07:30
by MightyWarrior
Happy Slapper wrote:David Haye has to be the biggest puncher and probably biggest pound for pound puncher in boxing today.
Nah, just take a look at who he's been knocking out ( Audley ? Ruiz ?? China chin Macca ? ) and I think that disqualifies him straight off.

Safe to say the two biggest punchers P4P today come out of the Philippines. And for my money, Donaire looks an even bigger puncher than Manny.

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 07:37
by orbtastic
Jackson & McClellan the obvious ones.

I guess if you wanted to do a division by division, off the top of my head:


Heavyweight - Shavers. Foreman, Baer
Cruiserweight - Bell, Qawi
Light Heavy - Moore, Foster, Fitzsimmons, MSM
Super middle - Benn, Park
Middle - McClellan, Ketchell, maybe Graziano
Light Middle - Jackson, Hearns, Norris has a decent shout, Mugabi
Welter - Cuevas, Langford (could rate him anywhere), Robinson
Light Welter - Tsyzu, Bailey
Lightweight - Joe Gans, Duran, Rosario, Ramirez
Super Feather - Arguello, Freitas
Feather - Saddler, Hamed, Danny Lopez, Esparragoza, Moreno
Super Bantam - Gomez, Junior Jones
Bantam - Olivares, Zarate, Zamora
Super fly - Galaxy, Donaire
Fly - Wilde (I dislike rating him so highly but you can't argue with his record on paper), Vic D
Light fly - Carbajal, Sajatoraong (sp), gonzalez
Straw - Finito Lopez

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 08:11
by cakes
Can't believe no one has mentioned Tyson :evil:

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 08:17
by Datsue
orbtastic wrote:Jackson & McClellan the obvious ones.

I guess if you wanted to do a division by division, off the top of my head:


Heavyweight - Shavers. Foreman, Baer
Cruiserweight - Bell, Qawi
Light Heavy - Moore, Foster, Fitzsimmons, MSM
Super middle - Benn, Park
Middle - McClellan, Ketchell, maybe Graziano
Light Middle - Jackson, Hearns, Norris has a decent shout, Mugabi
Welter - Cuevas, Langford (could rate him anywhere), Robinson
Light Welter - Tsyzu, Bailey
Lightweight - Joe Gans, Duran, Rosario, Ramirez
Super Feather - Arguello, Freitas
Feather - Saddler, Hamed, Danny Lopez, Esparragoza, Moreno
Super Bantam - Gomez, Junior Jones
Bantam - Olivares, Zarate, Zamora
Super fly - Galaxy, Donaire
Fly - Wilde (I dislike rating him so highly but you can't argue with his record on paper), Vic D
Light fly - Carbajal, Sajatoraong (sp), gonzalez
Straw - Finito Lopez
Fantastic list.

Of today's fighters, you've got to mention Donaire after last weekend, I'm still having nightmares about that left hook & I'll bet Fernando still doesn't know what day it is.

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 08:44
by Ash-Weston
cakes wrote:Can't believe no one has mentioned Tyson :evil:
Cant believe no one has mentioned Katsidis :evil:

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 09:18
by orbtastic
Ash-Weston wrote:
cakes wrote:Can't believe no one has mentioned Tyson :evil:
Cant believe no one has mentioned Katsidis :evil:
Katsidis has raw power but he's too unpolished enough at the top level and consequently loses. A little like Shavers but at least big Earnie got some good wins at the top level and had genuine one-hit power. Even at b & c level Katsidis is not scoring one punch KOs, he's either going pts or TKO.

Re: biggest puncher in their division ?????

Posted: 25 Feb 2011, 09:20
by Scottrf
Yeah, nice list orb. Joe Louis was the only one who immediately came to mind as an omission.