BoxRec

This fight was talked about but never happened. Who wins this match up.

I predict Gatti's willingness to trade would be his downfall. Tszyu ko 6.

Gatti would get brutalized for as long as it lasted. He simply wasn't that caliber of fighter.

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Gatti would get brutalized for as long as it lasted. He simply wasn't that caliber of fighter.

100%
Gatti was wonderful to watch but against that level of opponent he would not be able to rely on toughness to see the final bell, let alone find a way to win. Stopped in or around the 8th, IMO, and down several times.

Gatti/Phillips would've been good; I'd have favored Cool, though.

Manslaughter 101

Counter-puncher wrote:Manslaughter 101

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Gatti would get brutalized for as long as it lasted. He simply wasn't that caliber of fighter.

Agreed, and Gatti is pretty much my favorite fighter of all time, but I'm aware of his faults, and indeed he wouldn't have been able to compete with Tszyu.

Horrible styles mix for arturro.
Interestingly enough, I think mickey ward would have had a better chance against tszyu, but that's another story.

Anyone else think Tszyu is a little underatted these days?

thunderfromdownunder wrote:Horrible styles mix for arturro.
Interestingly enough, I think mickey ward would have had a better chance against tszyu, but that's another story.

Tszyu would've Gonzalez'd Ward.

thunderfromdownunder wrote:Anyone else think Tszyu is a little underatted these days?

By whom? He just made the HOF last year in his first year of eligibility, right?

Rover wrote:

thunderfromdownunder wrote:Anyone else think Tszyu is a little underatted these days?

By whom? He just made the HOF last year in his first year of eligibility, right?

I think he deserves to be more widely remembered, but hey.

Who's forgotten him? He had his last fight in 05.

Tszyu TKO3 for me. He wouldn't have outclassed him quite as comprehensively as Floyd, but Tszyu had dynamite in his right hand and he was very accurate. Gatti could only take so many before the ref or his corner would have to step in.

Counter-puncher wrote:Manslaughter 101

True dat.

Gatti's face would be hamburger by round 4. He is made for Kostya who would just measure him for booming right hands round after round.

orbtastic wrote:

Counter-puncher wrote:Manslaughter 101

True dat.

Gatti's face would be hamburger by round 4. He is made for Kostya who would just measure him for booming right hands round after round.

If it made it to Round 4.

Rover wrote:

thunderfromdownunder wrote:Horrible styles mix for arturro.
Interestingly enough, I think mickey ward would have had a better chance against tszyu, but that's another story.

Tszyu would've Gonzalez'd Ward.

The two guys that beat Tszyu were tough pressure fighters, ward fits into that category. Not saying he would have, but I think it would be interesting

Ward's no Hatton or Phillips. Not even close.

BarryWashington wrote:yeah tszyu would run through gatti and easily outclass ward. i still think a younger kostya (on neutral territory) would run through hatton. think that fight was one of those "at the right place, right time" moments

How did territory impact it? It didn't go to the cards, so no hometown decision.

Rover wrote:

BarryWashington wrote:yeah tszyu would run through gatti and easily outclass ward. i still think a younger kostya (on neutral territory) would run through hatton. think that fight was one of those "at the right place, right time" moments

How did territory impact it? It didn't go to the cards, so no hometown decision.

The crowd certainly gave Hatton a boost, plus the ref ruled a Tszyu punch low that was on the belt and knocked Hatton down, then didn't deduct points from Hatton after his obvious low blow (although I acknowledge that had the neither of these would have changed the result). I agree that prime-for-prime, Tszyu beats Hatton.

You stated that you acknowledge neither of those things (and one low blow shouldn't warrant a deduction--though I agree that was a KD--very close call, though) would've changed the outcome.
So Tszyu wouldn't have quit in Vegas?

Tszyu has one loss Hatton never beat him that was a modern day mugging and an insult to boxing

NICARAGUAN NIGHTMARE wrote:Tszyu has one loss Hatton never beat him that was a modern day mugging and an insult to boxing

Nonsense.
Hatton's holding didn't make Tszyu quit.
"He held me to death!"

Rover wrote:

NICARAGUAN NIGHTMARE wrote:Tszyu has one loss Hatton never beat him that was a modern day mugging and an insult to boxing

Nonsense.
Hatton's holding didn't make Tszyu quit.
"He held me to death!"

blatantly unfair reffing will break any fighters spirit