BoxRec

CJ Ross gave the 1st to Canelo?! baffling scorecard.

Just 2 sounds different to dave moreti, and using the combined system mayweather won 8 rounds to 4.

Moreti had it too close as well, no way you can give Canelo 4 rounds in that fight.

I agree, just saying.

It strikes me as a good idea that when you have 3 judges scoring a fight , when 2 agree on the score, then that becomes the official score That is if the judges score round 1 9-10, 9-10, 10-9 , then the official score is 9-10.
This means that at least 2 judges would have agreed on the score and that would exclude a judge whose clearly not at the same fight as the others !!!
I wonder how the Burns fight would have ended with this system ?? Perhps 'fights collector ' might know ??

dalcumly wrote:It strikes me as a good idea that when you have 3 judges scoring a fight , when 2 agree on the score, then that becomes the official score That is if the judges score round 1 9-10, 9-10, 10-9 , then the official score is 9-10.
This means that at least 2 judges would have agreed on the score and that would exclude a judge whose clearly not at the same fight as the others !!!
I wonder how the Burns fight would have ended with this system ?? Perhps 'fights collector ' might know ??

yeah this is what I meant by combined scores

WTF was Ross watching? That is plain incompetence or corruption.

Mensa07 wrote:Moreti had it too close as well, no way you can give Canelo 4 rounds in that fight.

They must be sat at the back of the arena

The boxing world needs it. It's not even the rare decision, it's clear as mud decisions that even my mates who hardly EVER watch boxing say, Floyd won nearly every round.

It's as bad as the ball going 10 yards wide in foote and the ref giving a goal, it's ridiculous when no one can agree. There needs to be disciplinary action. The judge who can theophane the win was as ridiculous. The list is endless