BoxRec

Who would win?

Adrien Broner

Agree.But it would be a good fight).

Mayweather would have kept the stumpy plodder at distance with a sharp and consistent jab and just taken him apart from there. Roger was truly at his element at long range and the level of pace that Broner likes to fight at would suit a sharpshooter like Mayweather, who would have all the time to pick his shots and wouldn't be forced to fight at a pace that would unsettle him ( conditioning was as much of a problem for him as his chin was.) Not to mention that Broner lacks the foot speed and ring smarts to close distance, and the power to change the fight in his favour.

Be interesting if Roger catches him clean early on.

I'd take Roger easily. His speed and long range jabbing would win rounds, and his right hand would keep Broner honest. Who has Broner fought near the calibre of Roger? An old Paulie and Ponce arguably beat Broner for pete's sake . . .

Mayweather by early stoppage or clear decision. Depends on this guys chin, I already know his defense is horrific.