Page 1 of 3
Rose v Maciel
Posted: 25 Oct 2013, 17:08
by Old bones Ian
I think this could be a tough night ahead for Rose, the Argentinian looks a good boxer with a decent chin and a punch.
Rose hasn't been that impressive of late, and needs to be on good form tomorrow. I'm going to have a look at the odds for this fight, as it might tempt me to part with some money.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 25 Oct 2013, 17:51
by Andrew
Just checked Skybet .
Marciel 4/7
Rose 11/8
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 25 Oct 2013, 18:30
by n1ebf
which makes the overseas fighter the favourite

.....do we not have a go-to guy for these situations?
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 04:16
by Boxing Prospect
Maciel.is a.very solid and very over looked guy, made Pirog look pretty average and has hurtful power. Was hoping Rose would be the favorite for my own bets.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 04:43
by Adam1991
you will see a different brian rose tonight.. UD or late stoppage for brian
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 04:46
by lefty
Adam1991 wrote:you will see a different brian rose tonight.. UD or late stoppage for brian
Rose has never fought someone the calibre of Maciel. If you're getting stopped by Maxwell that doesnt well for this fight.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 04:50
by Adam1991
unless your all experts on argentinian boxing experts the only time you have seen him fight is against pirog, why dont yas get behind a fellow britain, instead of slagging him off
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 04:55
by lefty
Adam1991 wrote:unless your all experts on argentinian boxing experts the only time you have seen him fight is against pirog, why dont yas get behind a fellow britain, instead of slagging him off
Actually ive watched a few of his fights. On top of that, Pirog far surpasses anything Rose has ever been in with! Yeah he knocked out Harris and Alcine but both were seriously shot and Alcine was a pretty poor champion at his best.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 05:07
by Boxing Prospect
Adam1991 wrote:unless your all experts on argentinian boxing experts the only time you have seen him fight is against pirog, why dont yas get behind a fellow britain, instead of slagging him off
Most of his fights have been on TYC Sports so have been very easy to watch, either live or via video.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 05:10
by JC
Adam1991 wrote:unless your all experts on argentinian boxing experts the only time you have seen him fight is against pirog, why dont yas get behind a fellow britain, instead of slagging him off
They aren't slagging Rose off mate, they're discussing who they think will win. If everyone said they thought the British fighter would win even if they don't believe it what would be the point?
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 05:27
by Old bones Ian
Adam1991 wrote:unless your all experts on argentinian boxing experts the only time you have seen him fight is against pirog, why dont yas get behind a fellow britain, instead of slagging him off
Im not slagging him off, not everytime can i favour a British boxer. I happen to think that Rose will really need to be on form to win tonight. And i hope he does.
Im not a bad judge of boxers and this Argie is a good boxer, im impressed with the way Rose is willing to face a guy who most wouldn't go near.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 05:28
by GlobalBox
Seen a lot of his fights and he can certainly bang particularly to the body, Miguel Diaz is here with him and they really fancy the job, I feel Brian is the better boxer but I am not sure he can keep this guy off him for the entire fight, I would love to see Rose win this but its a big ask, although he has all the home advantages so lets see how Macial travels.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 05:38
by lefty
GlobalBox wrote:Seen a lot of his fights and he can certainly bang particularly to the body, Miguel Diaz is here with him and they really fancy the job, I feel Brian is the better boxer but I am not sure he can keep this guy off him for the entire fight, I would love to see Rose win this but its a big ask, although he has all the home advantages so lets see how Macial travels.
Im not sure Rose has got the pop to keep him off.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 05:45
by GlobalBox
columbo wrote:GlobalBox wrote:Seen a lot of his fights and he can certainly bang particularly to the body, Miguel Diaz is here with him and they really fancy the job, I feel Brian is the better boxer but I am not sure he can keep this guy off him for the entire fight, I would love to see Rose win this but its a big ask, although he has all the home advantages so lets see how Macial travels.
Im not sure Rose has got the pop to keep him off.
Thats the way I see it, if Rose is not caught cold there could be a spell where he is popping and moving but unless Macial gets buzzed by something it may not be enough, I hope it is though.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 06:49
by gmanji
Anyone find odds for a Rose points win? I won £6500 grand when he beat Arron so fancy a large punt if hes 3/1 or more to win
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 16:39
by mcato
I thought Rose lost that fight by 2 rounds. If you watch fights with volume down and not listening to those bias commentators you see it for what it is ...another robbery
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 16:42
by mullenman
mcato wrote:I thought Rose lost that fight by 2 rounds. If you watch fights with volume down and not listening to those bias commentators you see it for what it is ...another robbery
no way did rose win that in my opinion
fighting in the uk is like fighting in the old germany since eddie got involved
no fcuking was did he win that fight
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 16:45
by mcato
mullenman wrote:mcato wrote:I thought Rose lost that fight by 2 rounds. If you watch fights with volume down and not listening to those bias commentators you see it for what it is ...another robbery
no way did rose win that in my opinion
fighting in the uk is like fighting in the old germany since eddie got involved
no fcuking was did he win that fight
I use to hate watching fights in Germany but its getting worse over here. Rose is no way up there!
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 16:46
by Deno1986
I posted in the other thread that I had Maciel by two rounds and I could make a case for a draw but off the top of my head I can't find another swing round to give to Rose. Might watch it again tomorrow. Rose showed some serious balls in that fight to keep fighting back when he was in trouble. 117-111 card is another disgraceful scorecard that are becoming increasingly expected in British boxing.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 16:48
by Fortynineandout
Lots of heart from Brian who dug deep , close fight but to score it 117-111 in his favour is yet again unbelievable & almost becoming the norm . Does the British boxing scene no favours .
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 16:49
by DMA1987
Deno1986 wrote:I posted in the other thread that I had Maciel by two rounds and I could make a case for a draw but off the top of my head I can't find another swing round to give to Rose. Might watch it again tomorrow. Rose showed some serious balls in that fight to keep fighting back when he was in trouble. 117-111 card is another disgraceful scorecard that are becoming increasingly expected in British boxing.
117 - 111 was wrong. It was from the Spanish judge like, bear in mind the UK judge had it much closer. That being said i am not upset about Rose winning, he was worthy IMO.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 16:49
by palooka
Deno1986 wrote:I posted in the other thread that I had Maciel by two rounds and I could make a case for a draw but off the top of my head I can't find another swing round to give to Rose. Might watch it again tomorrow. Rose showed some serious balls in that fight to keep fighting back when he was in trouble. 117-111 card is another disgraceful scorecard that are becoming increasingly expected in British boxing.
1) Rose has some real bottle.
2) That scorecard is ludicrous and Rose's mum wouldn't have scored it that wide.
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 17:00
by Adam1991
who gives a fornicate what you bunch of dickheads say youve been slagging him and slagging him since he got beat by maxwell well guess what were at the top now fighting the elite.. hope youve all enjoyed the journey cause we all have!! Goodnight Godbless
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 17:02
by lefty
Re: Rose v Maciel
Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 17:03
by palooka
Adam1991 wrote:who gives a eff what you bunch of dickheads say youve been slagging him and slagging him since he got beat by maxwell well guess what were at the top now fighting the elite.. hope youve all enjoyed the journey cause we all have!! Goodnight Godbless

have a good night