BoxRec

How would this have gone at super middle?

I'd go with Collins.Collins W12

Collins!! Would of smotherd froch with ease. Very dangerous late on froch, he can really dig in & pull it out the fire when needed

Froch would and should be favourite.

Froch. Collins didn't mix in anywhere near the company Carl has (washed up fighters aside). Plus Carl was a natural super middle.

Collins was slow and lacked the pop and athleticism of Froch. Mind you, Collins was stubborn enough to last 12 rounds. 117-112 Froch, if not wider if he really concentrated on his boxing.

Ezzard wrote:Froch would and should be favourite.

Agreed.

I think at 36 Froch is slowing down. His starts are getting increasingly pedestrian. With the loss of speed and the fact he is more hittable, a fight with Collins actually becomes more even. Edge to Froch, but it's a harder fight now.

Would be a helluva rough and tough contest. But Collins wins it.

A real hard battle I'd still favour froch by a close decision

Any fight u care to think of u can see froch being beaten.Collins fought in a tougher era but despite his and British middleweight historians revisionism during 89-93 Collins was an also run at mw never truly in the league of McCallum,toney,jones jnr,Jackson,mclellan ,Hopkins or even b level guys like kalambay.

Than he beats a shot benn twice and a still useful but past it Eubanks by hair line decisions.

Froch has beaten or found a way to beat far better fighters in Kessler,Taylor,groves,and Abraham and diesel. Froch at his best beats Collins in a very good fight but manages to over power him