BoxRec

Quarterfinals
Joe Calzaghe vs Nigel Benn
Carl Froch vs James Toney
Steve Collins vs Andre Ward
Roy Jones jr vs Chris Eubank

Who would win?

Calzaghe
Toney
Ward
Jones

Calzaghe
Ward

Calzaghe

Calzaghe W12 Benn
Toney W12 Froch
Ward W12 Collins
Jones W12 Eubank

Calzaghe SD12 Toney
Ward MD12 Jones

Calzaghe SD12 Ward

Joe Calzaghe UD12 Nigel Benn (clear)
James Toney UD12 Carl Froch (close)
Andre Ward UD12 Steve Collins (clear)
Roy Jones jr UD12 Chris Eubank (clear)

Joe Calzaghe UD12 James Toney (close)
Roy Jones Jnr UD12 Andre Ward (close, tough call)

Roy Jones Jnr UD12 Joe Calzaghe (close, primes matchup very different to their real fight)

Wow, I don't see one stoppage in any of these matchups!

Joe Calzaghe vs Nigel Benn - very good fight, calzaghe SD
Carl Froch vs James Toney - Toney UD
Steve Collins vs Andre Ward - ward wide UD
Roy Jones jr vs Chris Eubank - this tournament will go the same way as the middlewieght GP. can't look past RJJ. immense at the peak of his powers. eubank took some stopping though, but well outboxed

----------------------------------------------------------------
calzaghe vs toney - this is a tough one to call but i'm a big calzaghe fan so i'm going to let my heart rule my head and say joe after a few middle round scares
RJJ vs Ward - RJJ to get to a very defensive ward. making andre look bad in the process

------------------------------------------
RJJ vs Calzaghe - unlike the fight between joe and an extremely faded Jones Jr, a prime Jones beats Joe every time. even being a calzaghe fan cant sway me away from Jones by UD. making the gloves are off documentary a slightly different prospect years later