BoxRec

Nigel Benn
Steve Collins
Keith Holmes
Juan Carlos Gomez
Carlos De Leon

I think he beats them all, the only one I'd question is Gomez. He may have had the wrong style and too much speed for James.

But if I had to pick, I'd go with Toney in every one of these. Then again, Toney may well be my favorite fighter ever, so I may be clouded.

For me Toney beats all them.