Page 1 of 2
Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 07:24
by Anzi
He talks all the way through the fight about rubbish, the Lomachenko v Salido fight was an interesting fight, but Mrchant and his partner ruined it, they even stopped scoring it and gave up after a few rounds and Merchant talks so slowly, you end up virtually falling asleep, whilst waiting for the punch line, he has been like that for years, plus he put's down the fighters all the time, Mayweather was right about him, they should get rid of him, he has too much ego for his own good, he even called Salido an "old goat " during the fight, there was only one old goat at that fight and it was not Salido.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 07:32
by TopGun
Prefer him over Jim Watt! No contest.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 07:41
by Bard of Boxrec
I thought Larry had long retired?
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 09:11
by ScottDetonator
The commentary for the US Saturday night card was terrible. Two old farts spring to mind. From salivating over the 'Corona' girls to breaking the scoring down to every single minute of the fight and constantly telling us how they scored it(every other sentence), not to mention they are biased most of the time.
Did the US get the same commentary that we did on BN? They sound more like the B-team to me. I'm also not a fan of women commentating, in this case Christina P, several times she mentioned what the fighters were wearing in a fashion sense. Bad mix and overall boring.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 09:18
by JimStone
Merchant and his mate only do the international feed. They work for Top Rank. The Yanks don't get that commentary.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 09:22
by Old bones Ian
Never been a fan of Merchant, he does know his stuff but his delivery grinds with me.
And don't get me started on Teddy 'I'm never wrong' Atlas
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 10:07
by Anzi
Aden wrote:Merchant and his mate only do the international feed. They work for Top Rank. The Yanks don't get that commentary.
Bad for us good for them.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 10:12
by forcefraser
Merchant is barerly alive these days. As for the "Colonel" or whatever they call him, he is terrible.
He had Vera up after 6 rounds against Chavez Jr. I watched the fight and struggled to give Vera anything. I though jr looked excellent in the fight.
Chavez beat him silly in one round and the Colonel said "I`d give that rounde to Vera"
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 10:48
by Anzi
forcefraser wrote:Merchant is barerly alive these days. As for the "Colonel" or whatever they call him, he is terrible.
He had Vera up after 6 rounds against Chavez Jr. I watched the fight and struggled to give Vera anything. I though jr looked excellent in the fight.
Chavez beat him silly in one round and the Colonel said "I`d give that rounde to Vera"
Lol, I know, they had trouble scoring the rounds for the lomachenko fight, so they gave up, never heard that before, they chatted all through the fight about anything.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 11:24
by davie
I always wondered why he spoke so slowly, thought it was just his age, but then i watched some fights from the early 80s, that he was commentating on and he even had a really slow drawl then
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 11:27
by forcefraser
It`s a terrible line up that they have. Merchant has done his time, he should be put out to graze.
I want more of the two who called the Taylor v Froch fight. Those guys were epic.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 11:47
by banjo
Yanks are always shit commentators, then again the British ones have been going that way for sometime now. Nobody can give an informed view anymore, they all either talk drivel, overemphasise or the most recent one - shout.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 13:21
by Anzi
banjo wrote:Yanks are always poo commentators, then again the British ones have been going that way for sometime now. Nobody can give an informed view anymore, they all either talk drivel, overemphasise or the most recent one - shout.
What you on about the yanks are the best, usually ? Channel 5 are very good. English & American combined.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 14:46
by whiskey
forcefraser wrote:It`s a terrible line up that they have. Merchant has done his time, he should be put out to graze.
I want more of the two who called the Taylor v Froch fight. Those guys were epic.
Wasnt it steve farhood and al bernstein ?
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 14:48
by lefty
G0mez wrote:forcefraser wrote:It`s a terrible line up that they have. Merchant has done his time, he should be put out to graze.
I want more of the two who called the Taylor v Froch fight. Those guys were epic.
Wasnt it steve farhood and al bernstein ?
I think Gus Johnson was a part of that broadcast.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 15:28
by gilgamesh
Personally I love Larry Merchant, and I find him amusing. I don't get to hear him as much these days because he doesn't work for HBO anymore, but I like hearing him when I do.
I've always heard a lot of people hate on Merchant. I'll never feel that way about him.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 15:33
by lefty
gilgamesh wrote:Personally I love Larry Merchant, and I find him amusing. I don't get to hear him as much these days because he doesn't work for HBO anymore, but I like hearing him when I do.
I've always heard a lot of people hate on Merchant. I'll never feel that way about him.
I think he's shite as a commentator but like you he I find him quite endearing. I feel the same way about the Sheridan aswell as it goes. I have a feeling that both of them are somewhat hammered whilst commenting aswell

Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 15:38
by handsofstone
I dont get too uptight about any commentators really but Merchant sure as hell,s a slow talker

Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 16:23
by Anzi
gilgamesh wrote:Personally I love Larry Merchant, and I find him amusing. I don't get to hear him as much these days because he doesn't work for HBO anymore, but I like hearing him when I do.
I've always heard a lot of people hate on Merchant. I'll never feel that way about him.
One thing about boxing is that their is always a difference of opinion, not matter what.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 17:59
by Bard of Boxrec
I kind of like Larry but not sure why. One guy I feel gets a lot of hate is Gus Johnson but I think he is good and can't understand the bile. Bernstein is good. I can't really think of any commentators I actively dislike apart from one reedy-sounding UK guy I never remember the name of who I think works for FW but thankfully doesn't seem to get much work. Oh, and John Rawling.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 18:09
by Flump
How come Bob Sheridan calls himself 'Colonel' anyway? And Tom Parker for that matter, anyone know?
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 18:44
by gilgamesh
columbo wrote:gilgamesh wrote:Personally I love Larry Merchant, and I find him amusing. I don't get to hear him as much these days because he doesn't work for HBO anymore, but I like hearing him when I do.
I've always heard a lot of people hate on Merchant. I'll never feel that way about him.
I think he's shite as a commentator but like you he I find him quite endearing. I feel the same way about the Sheridan aswell as it goes. I have a feeling that both of them are somewhat hammered whilst commenting aswell

I find him endearing, and I actually like him as a commentator. He might talk more paired up with Sheridan, but the Merchant I knew at HBO didn't have a whole lot to say and he would just chime in on occasion usually with funny comments.
If a fight is boring, he'll say so. If a fight is great, he'll say so. I've always liked that about him.
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 18:57
by Boxing Prospect
I like Larry, he's like a drunk uncle. Sheridan however is as useful as a chocolate teapot...
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 19:05
by jameswilson
IF HE WAS 50 YEARS YOUNGER HE'D KICK ALL YOUR ASSES!
Re: Larry Merchant is a terrible commentator
Posted: 03 Mar 2014, 19:08
by jamesmcdonnell
Boxing Prospect wrote:I like Larry, he's like a drunk uncle. Sheridan however is as useful as a chocolate teapot...
You mean Colonel Bob Sheridan?