Page 1 of 3
FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 10:35
by Luckybattles
Cant believe how people are so heavily influenced by the hype. This guy fights an opponent who was on the verge of journeyman status a couple years ago. a blown up lightweight with a lot of heart and a penchant for putting up exciting battles with little in regards for defense. For any great fighter, this would be a showcase fight. a dream come true. Instead we witness one of the most boring fights in recent memory. Or at least one of the most boring fights since FMJ was last in the ring. All the holding, running, and time wasting was repugnant. Don't get me wrong, I would be truly impressed with this performance against GGG or Andre Ward but Maidana? Cant even imagine this guy being in the top 20 All time greats. Now they will want to make 100 million off pacman. Eff this. Are people that stupid to pay for it. I guess so
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:11
by Chepppaaa
like teddy atlas said "sugar leonard would have kod floyds last 5 opponents".. thats the stuff atg do with journeymans and young green fighters like canelo
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:17
by Impractical Poster
I'd say he's one of the best defensive fighters of all time. But his resume doesn't compare to many of the other ATGs. And that matters.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:19
by Baby Face Finster
Well if his paid lackeys keep yelling TBE TBE TBE it must be true right?
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:28
by SaadOffTheDeck
I'd have to go with Jack dempsey.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:32
by handsofstone
Having watched All Access leading up to the Maidana rematch,im now convinced that he's becoming even more of a twat than Broner
If he has so much money why is he still so obsessed with showing it off?
Its like losing your virginity then recording the lass confirming she's slept with you,then going about telling all and sundry your no longer a virgin and showing everyone the recording
Who gives a eff,move on its bored the tits off me
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:32
by handsofstone
Having watched All Access leading up to the Maidana rematch,im now convinced that he's becoming even more of a twat than Broner
If he has so much money why is he still so obsessed with showing it off?
Its like losing your virginity then recording the lass confirming she's slept with you,then going about telling all and sundry your no longer a virgin and showing everyone the recording
Who gives a eff,move on its bored the tits off me
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:33
by crusader
It's dat TMT lifestyle bro. Get wit it.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:36
by Impractical Poster
Looks like he traded out Justin Bieber for Warren Buffett. I'm kinda surprised Buffett allowed himself to be associated with Floyd. Maybe he is ignorant to much of his antics.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:47
by beatdown337
Juan manuel marquez
canelo alvarez
Miguel cotto
shane mosley
ricky hatton
Oscar de la hoya
zab Judah
Arturo gatti
jose luis Castillo 2x
diego corrales
If wins over these guys, (some who will be in the hall of fame) make you overrated. Then we should all aim for such mediocrity.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:50
by Chepppaaa
handsofstone wrote:Having watched All Access leading up to the Maidana rematch,im now convinced that he's becoming even more of a twat than Broner
If he has so much money why is he still so obsessed with showing it off?
Its like losing your virginity then recording the lass confirming she's slept with you,then going about telling all and sundry your no longer a virgin and showing everyone the recording
Who gives a eff,move on its bored the tits off me
the funny part is, is that floyd seems to be a total narcisst.
and everything is one big lie.
the warrior mentality which he is nowhere, proof are his fights.
the self portrait of himself in public, where he says money is only a persona, in real life he is a family man. hahaha....yeah right, a family man, that travels with like 8 women to miami and acts stupid in night clubs throwing money around like he was 25.
its just all one big joke...and floyd and his fans seem the only ones to find it cool, when obviously its more absurd than cool.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:56
by crusader
beatdown337 wrote:Juan manuel marquez
canelo alvarez
Miguel cotto
shane mosley
ricky hatton
Oscar de la hoya
zab Judah
Arturo gatti
jose luis Castillo 2x
diego corrales
If wins over these guys, (some who will be in the hall of fame) make you overrated. Then we should all aim for such mediocrity.
Don't understand the concept I see.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 11:57
by Tony1244
SaadOffTheDeck wrote:I'd have to go with Jack dempsey.
Agreed. Dempsey was a great legend but not a great fighter.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 12:03
by Tony1244
Chepppaaa wrote:like teddy atlas said "sugar leonard would have kod floyds last 5 opponents".. thats the stuff atg do with journeymans and young green fighters like canelo
KOing fighters can certainly be an aspect of greatness, but a fighter can be great if he wins decisively and consistently. Not a fan of Mayweather, just saying...
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 12:04
by SaadOffTheDeck
Leonard rates over Floyd, but it's not a landslide by any stretch of the imagination.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 12:19
by pugilisticprofessor
Chepppaaa wrote:like teddy atlas said "sugar leonard would have kod floyds last 5 opponents".. thats the stuff atg do with journeymans and young green fighters like canelo
Yeah, the 35 year old Leonard that got dropped on his ass and lost a landslide UD to Terry Norris.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 12:23
by beatdown337
crusader wrote:beatdown337 wrote:Juan manuel marquez
canelo alvarez
Miguel cotto
shane mosley
ricky hatton
Oscar de la hoya
zab Judah
Arturo gatti
jose luis Castillo 2x
diego corrales
If wins over these guys, (some who will be in the hall of fame) make you overrated. Then we should all aim for such mediocrity.
Don't understand the concept I see.
How did I misunderstand the concept if the topic is that he is overrated and I responded by posting a list of high quality /hall of fame opponents that he has beaten?
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 12:31
by Broomhall
I am not a personal fan of Mayweathers...but....the guy can box and fight and is certainly one of the greats of the modern game which is undeniably different to the "sport" (or business) of 30 years ago and beyond.
But Mayweather fights in todays business and todays business means having at least 4 world champions in zillions of weight divisions. He has done this incredibly successfully and has used the system cleverly and to his advantage.
You can argue would he have beat this fighter, would he have beat that fighter but the truth is we will never know. all we do know is that he has been the dominant and most talked figure in the game over the last 10 years. Technically one of the best boxers I have ever seen in relation to the opposition he has had.
TV companies do not pay the purses he gets without their being a very good reason.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 12:33
by crusader
beatdown337 wrote:crusader wrote:beatdown337 wrote:Juan manuel marquez
canelo alvarez
Miguel cotto
shane mosley
ricky hatton
Oscar de la hoya
zab Judah
Arturo gatti
jose luis Castillo 2x
diego corrales
If wins over these guys, (some who will be in the hall of fame) make you overrated. Then we should all aim for such mediocrity.
Don't understand the concept I see.
How did I misunderstand the concept if the topic is that he is overrated and I responded by posting a list of high quality /hall of fame opponents that he has beaten?
You can be overrated and have an incredible resume.
Whether someone is overrated depends on whether people have a higher opinion of them than they deserve.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 12:40
by SaadOffTheDeck
Many more people trash him than worship him. As far as the 'diehard' fans and media goes he's underrated by more. Anybody that rates him from 20-50 all time has it right.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 12:43
by reggaereggae
I couldn't agree more with the OP. Money shot is a good fighter, very defensive and gets so protected by Vegas refs. It's basically never a fair fight. Two against one. All of the 80s big four would've beaten him in a neutral environment or maybe even in a biased environment.
As long as Duran was in the mood.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 12:50
by cold187
if a excellent fighter comes in 100 years times are we still gonna compare them to hearns hagler and the "golden era", when none of us were around!!!
if this theory is right then, carl lewis is greater than usain bolt!!!!
never come across a more hated boxer than fmj, even if he beats, pacman will be same hate
if anyone else beat alvarez, maidana, ortiz, mosely, cotto people will be saying how good they are
im not a floyd fan, find his fights boring and tend to sleep, but its true, haters gonna hate!!!!!
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 15:13
by ReggieDiggs
pugilisticprofessor wrote:Chepppaaa wrote:like teddy atlas said "sugar leonard would have kod floyds last 5 opponents".. thats the stuff atg do with journeymans and young green fighters like canelo
Yeah, the 35 year old Leonard that got dropped on his ass and lost a landslide UD to Terry Norris.
Lol I was gonna to bring this up
Teddy & Floyd got more in common than Teddy would like to believe, they both love hearing themselves talk.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 15:15
by IKSRTFO
ReggieDiggs wrote:pugilisticprofessor wrote:Chepppaaa wrote:like teddy atlas said "sugar leonard would have kod floyds last 5 opponents".. thats the stuff atg do with journeymans and young green fighters like canelo
Yeah, the 35 year old Leonard that got dropped on his ass and lost a landslide UD to Terry Norris.
Lol I was gonna to bring this up
Teddy & Floyd got more in common than Teddy would like to believe, they both love hearing themselves talk.
I don't think Floyd would've beaten the Terry Norris that beat Leonard neither.
I didn't hear you guys giving Teddy poo when he was riding Floyd nuts for the last few years. This probably the only time he said anything remotely against Floyd.
Re: FMJ: The most overrated fighter of all time
Posted: 16 Sep 2014, 15:19
by ReggieDiggs
SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Many more people trash him than worship him. As far as the 'diehard' fans and media goes he's underrated by more. Anybody that rates him from 20-50 all time has it right.
This.
I bet Floyd has more fans in the audience wanting to see him lose than anyone since Muhammad Ali.