Page 1 of 2
Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 11:03
by Lennox
WBA Super-featherweight title.
I am not sure if it is the interim title or full version.
Emmanuel Lopez ranked 126 by the IWBR fighting Carlos Padilla ranked 168.
The WBA have them ranked 3 and 4 by their ratings.
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 11:27
by ReggieDiggs
When they pulled Tim Tomachek(?) out of the crowd to fight Tommy Morrison for a abc belt.
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 12:10
by koolkc107
Depends on how you define "worst"
If by that you mean most disappointing given what was at stake, it is hard to beat 2 that come to my mind.
Whitaker vs Chavez for the lineal welter title
Pacquiao vs Bradley for the WBO title
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 12:36
by Boxing Prospect
Lennox wrote:WBA Super-featherweight title.
I am not sure if it is the interim title or full version.
Emmanuel Lopez ranked 126 by the IWBR fighting Carlos Padilla ranked 168.
The WBA have them ranked 3 and 4 by their ratings.
Ignore the fight, it's a paper title that the WBA created when they forced Uchiyama to be promoted.
For what it's worth look at some of the early IBF title fights, some of Satoshi Shingaki's opponents shouldn't have gotten a title fight.
Also there was a debutant who fought for a title, Arturo Mayan?, who was blasted out in about 60 seconds and never fought again
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 12:48
by Datsue
Any of Herbie Hide's "world" title defences prior to getting bombed by Klitschko?
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 13:07
by Lennox
ReggieDiggs wrote:When they pulled Tim Tomachek(?) out of the crowd to fight Tommy Morrison for a abc belt.
yeah that was pretty bad Tomachek was ranked #213 at the time (by my ratings that you don't like)
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 13:31
by ReggieDiggs
Lennox wrote:ReggieDiggs wrote:When they pulled Tim Tomachek(?) out of the crowd to fight Tommy Morrison for a abc belt.
yeah that was pretty bad Tomachek was ranked #213 at the time (
by my ratings that you don't like)
lol you can't make a post without discussing your rankings can you?
Regardless of the ranking, taking anyone from an audience member to participant in the event is awful form even if the #1 ranked guy had ringside seats.
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 13:46
by Lennox
ReggieDiggs wrote:Lennox wrote:ReggieDiggs wrote:When they pulled Tim Tomachek(?) out of the crowd to fight Tommy Morrison for a abc belt.
yeah that was pretty bad Tomachek was ranked #213 at the time (
by my ratings that you don't like)
lol you can't make a post without discussing your rankings can you?
Regardless of the ranking, taking anyone from an audience member to participant in the event is awful form even if the #1 ranked guy had ringside seats.
Well I thought you would criticise if just left the number. I do make plenty of posts without mentioning them.
That Morrison fight I think what happened was Mike Evans (might not have been him) decided he was not fighting about 20 minutes before, so in fairness TT saved the day, but yeah as a WTF is was pretty grim, prob should just have been non title, but maybe the contracts and payments and ticket sales all had implications.
Arturo Mayan never had a fight before in that WBO straw-weight fight. Theres a lot of info on the website about Lineage and World Title fights.
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 13:59
by handsofstone
Cornelius Bundrage vs Ishe Smith was just awful
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 17:24
by SJM122
Chris Byrd vs DaVarryl Williamson was horrible in terms of action

Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 17:34
by Boxerbeetle
If we're counting some of the more ridiculous 'world titles', Joe Bugner vs Bonecrusher Smith for the WBF title was just a farce from start to finish.
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 17:46
by handsofstone
Not a title fight but the 12 rounder between Junior Witter vs Victor Lupo was so bad it deserves an honourable mention
I swear i thought we'd gone back to the 60 rounders of yesteryear

Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 18:56
by Andrew
Didn't watch either but apparently Wlad v Povetkin was dreadful as was Mickey Bey v Miguel Vasquez
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 18:56
by Andrew
Sure Wlad v ibragimov was a stinker too.
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 19:24
by Boxing Prospect
Naandrew wrote:Sure Wlad v ibragimov was a stinker too.
Eurgh, what an awful bout that was. There was real hope going in as well due to it being a major unification, turned out to be dreadful, Don't think either guy landed a major punch all night with Klitschko spending most of the time batting Ibragimov's lead hand down...absolutely dire.
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 21 Mar 2015, 21:49
by sucracristo
handsofstone wrote:Cornelius Bundrage vs Ishe Smith was just awful
i thought smith-molina was worse
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 22 Mar 2015, 04:42
by Andrew
How the hell could I forget Klitschko v Haye

Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 22 Mar 2015, 05:13
by Syntax Error
A toss up between:-
Johnny Nelson -v- Carlos De Leon
Sugar Ray Leonard -v- Roberto Duran 3
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 22 Mar 2015, 09:53
by Taansend
fergusg wrote:Carlos De Leon's defence of his WBC world cruiserweight title in 1990 against Johnny Nelson was so bad that ITV's Reg Gutteridge (the commentator of this tedious bout) repeatedly had to apologise for the mundane nature of the fight!
It was seriously bad... and I mean real bad!
Watch it if you dare!

I still have nightmares a quarter of a century later.
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 22 Mar 2015, 10:01
by ReggieDiggs
sucracristo wrote:handsofstone wrote:Cornelius Bundrage vs Ishe Smith was just awful
i thought smith-molina was worse
Ishe Smith & Carlos Molina could have threads dedicated to the worst of their usually unwatchable fights.
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 22 Mar 2015, 10:29
by handsofstone
ReggieDiggs wrote:sucracristo wrote:handsofstone wrote:Cornelius Bundrage vs Ishe Smith was just awful
i thought smith-molina was worse
Ishe Smith & Carlos Molina could have threads dedicated to the worst of their usually unwatchable fights.
Who was the last exciting fighter to hold the IBF strap at 154? I'm scratching my head
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 22 Mar 2015, 10:52
by sucracristo
handsofstone wrote:Who was the last exciting fighter to hold the IBF strap at 154? I'm scratching my head
winky was very defensive but still very watchable, vargas before him, and then terry norris in the 90's.
that's pretty much it.
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 22 Mar 2015, 11:03
by ajwesty13
Barker v sturm
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 22 Mar 2015, 11:36
by handsofstone
ajwesty13 wrote:Barker v sturm
Burns-Cook was even worse
Re: Worst title fight ever?
Posted: 22 Mar 2015, 13:20
by palooka
handsofstone wrote:ajwesty13 wrote:Barker v sturm
Burns-Cook was even worse

terrible way for a good fighter in Cook to go out though I imagine the big purse helped.