BoxRec

Sub-Lingual Tablet. wrote:No

ikorolev wrote:F4cking joke Cotto is above Ward, Lara and Thurman ???

Horse wrote:

ikorolev wrote:F4cking joke Cotto is above Ward, Lara and Thurman ???

Ward hasn't done anything impressive since he beat Froch 3.5 years ago. He's lucky to still be on the list.

Thurman's record has only just got to top 30 P4P quality. Lara lost to Alvarez last year and was poor against Smith in his last fight.

Sub-Lingual Tablet. wrote:Stop showing off Horse, it's most unseemly for someone of your vast age.

Horse wrote:

Sub-Lingual Tablet. wrote:Stop showing off Horse, it's most unseemly for someone of your vast age.

ikorolev wrote:So, when it is convenient to you, you look at the record, and when it is not, you look at performance ? Lara schooled Smith with minimal effort, and looked just fine. He also arguably defeated Canelo. Anyway, Lara smashed Trout who defeated Cotto. Lara is clearly the better fighter than Cotto.

Sub-Lingual Tablet. wrote:What's the significance of the Frog I wonder, tell us Horse, tell us?

Sub-Lingual Tablet. wrote:'She seems to be exactly the same as Horse, only pink, and with hair'

Horse wrote:

ikorolev wrote:So, when it is convenient to you, you look at the record, and when it is not, you look at performance ? Lara schooled Smith with minimal effort, and looked just fine. He also arguably defeated Canelo. Anyway, Lara smashed Trout who defeated Cotto. Lara is clearly the better fighter than Cotto.

Lara barely beat Smith. He looked terrible.

ikorolev wrote:119-109 is barely for you ? Maybe you shouldn't bother discussing boxing.

Horse wrote:

ikorolev wrote:119-109 is barely for you ? Maybe you shouldn't bother discussing boxing.

That's not how I saw it.

Lara has a ridiculously negative style even when he's fighting opponents like Smith.

Horse wrote:1. (1.) Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. (4.) Roman Gonzalez
3. (3.) Wladimir Klitschko
4. (2.) Manny Pacquiao
5. (5.) Sergey Kovalev
6. (7.) Gennady Golovkin
7. (8.) Timothy Bradley
8. (6.) Carl Froch
9. (9.) Guillermo Rigondeaux
10. (10.) Terence Crawford

11. (13.) Saul Alvarez
12. (12.) Juan Francisco Estrada
13. (14.) Adonis Stevenson
14. (11.) Juan Manuel Marquez
15. (15.) Shinsuke Yamanaka
16. (16.) Nicholas Walters
17. (17.) Miguel Cotto
18. (18.) Naoya Inoue
19. (22.) Kell Brook
20. (21.) Carl Frampton

21. (19.) Bernard Hopkins
22. (20.) Andre Ward
23. (23.) Lucas Matthysse
24. (24.) Danny Garcia
25. (25.) Erislandy Lara
26. (26.) Mauricio Herrera
27. (27.) Keith Thurman
28. (RE.) Takashi Uchiyama
29. (29.) Donnie Nietes
30. (30.) Marco Huck

Out - (28.) Leo Santa Cruz

KBB wrote:
Please destroy this list and thread Moderators. This is a bad joke.

Bobbyptsd wrote:

KBB wrote:What the actual fvck are you on about? I don't agree with Horse on many points obviously, but at least he's talking about boxing. You are on the 146th page of "Let's call each other names over Flanny Mayquiao" and you think THIS should be deleted?

You have some goddamn nerve, I'll give you that.

I see my favorite retarded Troll is back to following me around and ignoring everything I stated about boxing in my reply to this thread.

I already made my comments about this thread in regards to boxing but somehow you just want to continue following me around and analyzing whatever I say while focusing on the criticism instead of reading what I said:

This is what I stated about boxing/the P4P list, I'll point it out for you to make it easier for you to understand since I know that you are too dumb to comprehend:

I read Canelo was #11 I laughed, dude has beaten far better comp than everyone else on the list barring Floyd. No way does GGG go ahead of Canelo, Bradley who has lost twice to Manny ahead of Canelo, Adonis Stevenson behind Carl Froch

Bobbyptsd wrote:I love Horse's PFP lists! I like to play along at home. I write down the name of top fighters, put them in a hat,put the hat in the dryer, dose acid, forget what I was doing, then write names down as they come to me.

Voila!

ikorolev wrote:That's the problem. You don't see things like others.

Also, the fighter you gave position #1 also has a negative style, but it didn't prevent you from giving him the first spot.

Bobbyptsd wrote:I love Horse's PFP lists! I like to play along at home. I write down the name of top fighters, put them in a hat,put the hat in the dryer, dose acid, forget what I was doing, then write names down as they come to me.

Voila!

Horse wrote:

Bobbyptsd wrote:I love Horse's PFP lists! I like to play along at home. I write down the name of top fighters, put them in a hat,put the hat in the dryer, dose acid, forget what I was doing, then write names down as they come to me.

Voila!

The list is not going to be too far from the consensus, so to suggest it is chaotic and all over the place seems highly inaccurate.

KBB wrote:As soon as I read Canelo was #11 I laughed, dude has beaten far better comp than everyone else on the list barring Floyd.

KBB wrote:I really hate P4P lists because they are highly subjective. No way does GGG go ahead of Canelo, Bradley who has lost twice to Manny ahead of Canelo, Adonis Stevenson behind Carl Froch, lol this list is a pure joke. Lara not higher on the list than Froch or GGG and he's beaten far better comp.

KBB wrote:Please destroy this list and thread Moderators. This is a bad joke.

ikorolev wrote:I am wondering how much time Horse spent on deciding that one of sitting on positions 6 and 7 Froch and Bradley should move up, and the other one should move down when both haven't fought for a while

Horse wrote:

KBB wrote:As soon as I read Canelo was #11 I laughed, dude has beaten far better comp than everyone else on the list barring Floyd.

He had a very close fight with Lara which a lot of people thought he lost, he almost got whitewashed by Mayweather and a lot of people thought he lost to Lara (not me). He's too high if anything.

KBB wrote:I really hate P4P lists because they are highly subjective. No way does GGG go ahead of Canelo, Bradley who has lost twice to Manny ahead of Canelo, Adonis Stevenson behind Carl Froch, lol this list is a pure joke. Lara not higher on the list than Froch or GGG and he's beaten far better comp.

And a lot of people would say the opposite and laugh at you.

KBB wrote:Please destroy this list and thread Moderators. This is a bad joke.

KBB wrote:So what he had a close fight with Lara, Erislandy has beaten a list of A level fighters but he did not clearly distance himself in that fight with Canelo. Do you want to be critical of the others you have ahead of them and the competition that they have faced, beaten or lost to?

We can go there and I will make this list look as foolish as it really does, as far as Mayweather, everyone loses to him so there's no shame in a young Canelo losing to him but he hasn't lost to anyone else; a clear fact that you avoided in this list and your criticism of him.

KBB wrote:Do I care what people say here about me? Obviously no, I still continue to post and you guys like (Bobbyptsd and a few others) still follow me around Trolling and being angry because I do not agree with you.

KBB wrote:Do you want to do a comparison of the fights/fighters against those you have ahead of Canelo and see how the competition stacks up??