BoxRec

BWH Rankings as of 12 December 2015:

Champion: Tyson Fury
1. Wladimir Klitschko
2. Alexander Povetkin
3. Deontay Wilder
4. Kubrat Pulev
5. Bryant Jennings
6. Carlos Takam
7. Vyacheslav Glazkov
8. Ruslan Chagaev
9. Artur Szpilka
10. Dereck Chisora
11. Bermane Stiverne
12= Malik Scott
12= Erkan Teper
14. Steve Cunningham
15. Anthony Joshua

Topic A - How are the rankings affected by Joseph Parkers' TK03 win over Kali Meehan and TK01 win over Daniel Martz?

My vote: Parker and Martz both remain unranked.

Topic B - How are the rankings affected by Anthony Joshua's KO7 win over Dillian Whyte?

My vote: Joshua remains at #15, Whyte remains unranked.

Topic C - How are the rankings affected by Dereck Chisora's TKO5 win over Peter Erdos and TKO3 win over Jakov Gospic?

My vote: Chisora remains at #10, Erdos and Gospic remain unranked.

Note: This topic is for voting on the rankings of Parker, Meehan, Martz, Joshua, Whyte, Chisora, Erdos and Gospic. Posting your own top 15 will not count as a vote. Please cast your vote in the manner than I have done above.

Joshua 10
Parker 15, Cunningham out
Chisora 14

Cunningham out as had dropped out to cruiser weight
Joshua to 14
Parker to 15

No changes.

Actually a tough one. But I guess
Joshua 14
Parker 15
Chisora out

I have wanted Chisora out for a while

Shouldn't we also be voting on Chisora?

tiny_acres wrote:Shouldn't we also be voting on Chisora?

Yes, I didn't know he had fought - thanks. I'm editing the topic to include him, can everyone who has already voted please edit their votes to include Chisora.

Parker up to clear #12 (ahead of Scott and Teper), Martz remains unranked
Joshua up to clear #12 (ahead of Scott and Teper), Martz remains unranked
Chisora remains at #10, Erdos and Gospic remain unranked

If there is a more proper way to vote for Joshua > Parker > Scott, then we should try to iron out how that works. Because if I vote for Parker Up To #13, then that will get inferred as being behind Scott and Teper.

Lackeos wrote:Parker up to clear #12 (ahead of Scott and Teper), Martz remains unranked
Joshua up to clear #12 (ahead of Scott and Teper), Martz remains unranked
Chisora remains at #10, Erdos and Gospic remain unranked

If there is a more proper way to vote for Joshua > Parker > Scott, then we should try to iron out how that works. Because if I vote for Parker Up To #13, then that will get inferred as being behind Scott and Teper.

If you vote for Parker to #13 and Joshua to #12, that relegates Scott and Teper to equal #14.

Topic A - Parker in at #14. Martz remains unranked.

Topic B - Joshua up to #12, Whyte remains unranked.

Topic C - Chisora down to #15, his opponents remain unranked.

Joshua up to #13

Chisora down to #14

I'm not sure if those are the right numbers, but I want Joshua immediately behind Teper and Scott, and Chisora the next guy after Joshua. Unfortunately this gives an undeserved boost to Stiverne, whom I think should be even lower than he currently is, but in my opinion it's a positive change overall. Parker has impressed but due to his relatively weak opposition is just short of a top 15 spot for me.

So why are we voting on Parker? Hes not on the list an he fought no one on the list or even near it. I think we should wait for vacant spots on the list before we vote new people in like we have done in the past.

My vote.

Parker stays out.

He has not yet proven himself worthy for top 15 spot. My guess is he will do it soon.

Chisora up to 9.

Some points for activity here. Also i think he would murder Szpilka who should not even be on this list.

Joshua to 14.

Mostly for activity. Cunningham has done very little lately so i don't mind moving him down for now.

Joshua up to 14th, just behind the two boys who are joint 12th

Chisora remains 10th

Parker up to 15th at the expense of Cunningham who should drop out as he is moving back down to Cruiser.

Obviously all their recent opponents remain unranked.

Parker and Joshua proved much more already as most of the guys I see in this top 15, I think even Whyte is better as Teper and that cruiserweight that already lost against half Europe, and Malic Scott who barely ever fought Europeans

asdfjkl wrote:Parker and Joshua proved much more already as most of the guys I see in this top 15, I think even Whyte is better as Teper and that cruiserweight that already lost against half Europe, and Malic Scott who barely ever fought Europeans

Stop banging on about nothing and cast your vote

1 Wladimir Klitschko
2 Povetkin
3 Anthony Joshua
4 Joseph Parker
5 Pulev
6 Chagaev
7 Bryant Jennings
8 Deontay Wilder
9 Carlos Takam
10 Vyacheslav Glazkov
11 Ustinov
12 Dillian Whyte
13 Lucas Browne
14 Erkan Teper
15 Arthur Szpilka

Remember Chisora beat Malik Scott.

If it is subjective then my vote is;
Joshua up to 4. if objective then up to 11.
Parker in at 12.
Chisora at 13
Scott at 14=
Spilka at 14=
Cunningham drops out now going to box at cruiserweight.

Votes have been tallied, Chisora slips to #10=, Joshua improves to #14, Parker enters at #15, Cunningham slips out of the rankings (although he would have been removed after fighting at cruiserweight anyway).

Champion: Tyson Fury
1. Wladimir Klitschko
2. Alexander Povetkin
3. Deontay Wilder
4. Kubrat Pulev
5. Bryant Jennings
6. Carlos Takam
7. Vyacheslav Glazkov
8. Ruslan Chagaev
9. Artur Szpilka
10= Dereck Chisora
10= Bermane Stiverne
12= Malik Scott
12= Erkan Teper
14. Anthony Joshua
15. Joseph Parker

Are we having one for the Ortiz victory?

Lennox wrote:Remember Chisora beat Malik Scott.

If it is subjective then my vote is;
Joshua up to 4. if objective then up to 11.
Parker in at 12.
Chisora at 13
Scott at 14=
Spilka at 14=
Cunningham drops out now going to box at cruiserweight.

I can't really accept indecisive votes like this, although happily in this case, it wouldn't have made a difference. Non-mathematical rankings are always somewhat subjective. I don't mind what criteria people use when they vote, as long as they follow the prescribed format, unlike this guy:

asdfjkl wrote:1 Wladimir Klitschko
2 Povetkin
3 Anthony Joshua
4 Joseph Parker
5 Pulev
6 Chagaev
7 Bryant Jennings
8 Deontay Wilder
9 Carlos Takam
10 Vyacheslav Glazkov
11 Ustinov
12 Dillian Whyte
13 Lucas Browne
14 Erkan Teper
15 Arthur Szpilka

Note: This topic is for voting on the rankings of Parker, Meehan, Martz, Joshua, Whyte, Chisora, Erdos and Gospic. Posting your own top 15 will not count as a vote. Please cast your vote in the manner than I have done above.

tiny_acres wrote:Are we having one for the Ortiz victory?

Of course :)

jezzamundo wrote:

tiny_acres wrote:Are we having one for the Ortiz victory?

Of course :)

Thanks.I enjoy these and they are one of my favorite parts of this forum

tiny_acres wrote:

jezzamundo wrote:

tiny_acres wrote:Are we having one for the Ortiz victory?

Of course :)

Thanks.I enjoy these and they are one of my favorite parts of this forum

jezzamundo wrote:

Lennox wrote:Remember Chisora beat Malik Scott.

If it is subjective then my vote is;
Joshua up to 4. if objective then up to 11.
Parker in at 12.
Chisora at 13
Scott at 14=
Spilka at 14=
Cunningham drops out now going to box at cruiserweight.

I can't really accept indecisive votes like this, although happily in this case, it wouldn't have made a difference. Non-mathematical rankings are always somewhat subjective. I don't mind what criteria people use when they vote, as long as they follow the prescribed format, unlike this guy:

asdfjkl wrote:1 Wladimir Klitschko
2 Povetkin
3 Anthony Joshua
4 Joseph Parker
5 Pulev
6 Chagaev
7 Bryant Jennings
8 Deontay Wilder
9 Carlos Takam
10 Vyacheslav Glazkov
11 Ustinov
12 Dillian Whyte
13 Lucas Browne
14 Erkan Teper
15 Arthur Szpilka

Note: This topic is for voting on the rankings of Parker, Meehan, Martz, Joshua, Whyte, Chisora, Erdos and Gospic. Posting your own top 15 will not count as a vote. Please cast your vote in the manner than I have done above.

nice edit!

asdfjkl wrote:

jezzamundo wrote:

Lennox wrote:Remember Chisora beat Malik Scott.

If it is subjective then my vote is;
Joshua up to 4. if objective then up to 11.
Parker in at 12.
Chisora at 13
Scott at 14=
Spilka at 14=
Cunningham drops out now going to box at cruiserweight.

I can't really accept indecisive votes like this, although happily in this case, it wouldn't have made a difference. Non-mathematical rankings are always somewhat subjective. I don't mind what criteria people use when they vote, as long as they follow the prescribed format, unlike this guy:

asdfjkl wrote:1 Wladimir Klitschko
2 Povetkin
3 Anthony Joshua
4 Joseph Parker
5 Pulev
6 Chagaev
7 Bryant Jennings
8 Deontay Wilder
9 Carlos Takam
10 Vyacheslav Glazkov
11 Ustinov
12 Dillian Whyte
13 Lucas Browne
14 Erkan Teper
15 Arthur Szpilka

Note: This topic is for voting on the rankings of Parker, Meehan, Martz, Joshua, Whyte, Chisora, Erdos and Gospic. Posting your own top 15 will not count as a vote. Please cast your vote in the manner than I have done above.

nice edit!

Which edit are you referring to?