Page 1 of 1
What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 07:08
by fightfan95
Another list for you guys. Who wins?
Naseem Hamed v Erik Morales
Evander Holyfield v Tyson Fury
Nigel Benn v Mikkel Kessler
Shane Mosley v Kostya Tszyu
Carl Thompson v Jean-Marc Mormeck
I like this list personally - some great fights!

Re: What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 08:41
by Happy Slapper
Naseem Hamed
Evander Holyfield
Mikkel Kessler
Shane Mosley
Jean-Marc Mormeck
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 09:53
by Bard of Boxrec
Morales UD/late stoppage
Holyfield TKO5
Kessler TKO10
Mosley TKO10
Mormeck TKO9
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 16:13
by Monte Fisto
fightfan95 wrote:Another list for you guys. Who wins?
Naseem Hamed v Erik Morales
Evander Holyfield v Tyson Fury
Nigel Benn v Mikkel Kessler
Shane Mosley v Kostya Tszyu
Carl Thompson v Jean-Marc Mormeck
I like this list personally - some great fights!

Morales
Holyfield
Benn
Mosley (hardest to pick)
Thompson
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 16:31
by gilgamesh
Morales
Holyfield
Don't know enough about Benn to say one way or another on this one
Mosley
Don't know enough about Thompson to say one way or another
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 16:41
by littlepug
gilgamesh wrote:Morales
Holyfield
Don't know enough about Benn to say one way or another on this one
Mosley
Don't know enough about Thompson to say one way or another
Wow never heard anyone say they didn't know much about Benn before ! how come he's not been on your radar before mate ?
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 17:29
by gilgamesh
littlepug wrote:gilgamesh wrote:Morales
Holyfield
Don't know enough about Benn to say one way or another on this one
Mosley
Don't know enough about Thompson to say one way or another
Wow never heard anyone say they didn't know much about Benn before ! how come he's not been on your radar before mate ?
Before my time as a fan, and I've never went back and watched any of his fights. I've read about him, and am familiar with him and his accomplishments, but having not watched any of his fights I can't be certain what kinda stylistic matchup he brings to the table, and I like to be familiar with fighters styles when picking a winner in a Dream Match.
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 17:37
by littlepug
gilgamesh wrote:littlepug wrote:gilgamesh wrote:Morales
Holyfield
Don't know enough about Benn to say one way or another on this one
Mosley
Don't know enough about Thompson to say one way or another
Wow never heard anyone say they didn't know much about Benn before ! how come he's not been on your radar before mate ?
Before my time as a fan, and I've never went back and watched any of his fights. I've read about him, and am familiar with him and his accomplishments, but having not watched any of his fights I can't be certain what kinda stylistic matchup he brings to the table, and I like to be familiar with fighters styles when picking a winner in a Dream Match.
Ok cheers, I would highly recommend you to check him out on YOUTUBE I think the barkely, Watson and mcllelann fights would make you an instant fan

Re: What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 19:01
by SaadOffTheDeck
Morales by dec
Holyfield by early destruction(he could probably beat him now)
Benn
Mosley
Mormeck
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 20:42
by jamesmcdonnell
Mosley would have absolutely wrecked Kostya Tszyu, it's a real shame that Mosley didn't park at 140, he would have been pretty much unbeatable.
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 25 Feb 2016, 23:30
by ClivePatrickLyons
Morales wins split dec Hamed
Holyfield wins Tko 8 Fury
Benn wins Tko 7 Kessler
Moseley win un dec Tszyu
Mormeck wins Tko 12
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 26 Feb 2016, 05:30
by Bard of Boxrec
jamesmcdonnell wrote:Mosley would have absolutely wrecked Kostya Tszyu, it's a real shame that Mosley didn't park at 140, he would have been pretty much unbeatable.
Agreed, Oscar would have too. Tszyu was very overrated.
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 26 Feb 2016, 09:02
by jamesmcdonnell
Riddick Blowe wrote:jamesmcdonnell wrote:Mosley would have absolutely wrecked Kostya Tszyu, it's a real shame that Mosley didn't park at 140, he would have been pretty much unbeatable.
Agreed, Oscar would have too. Tszyu was very overrated.
Tszyu was a very good fighter, but I think he was fortunate that some of the other talent leapfrogged 140.
Re: What if? #4
Posted: 26 Feb 2016, 09:04
by jamesmcdonnell
Riddick Blowe wrote:Morales UD/late stoppage
Holyfield TKO5
Kessler TKO10
Mosley TKO10
Mormeck TKO9
chimes more or less with my thoughts, although you could never totally count Carl out, he had unbelievable power, and could turn a fight with a single punch.