Page 1 of 1
Who ranks higher
Posted: 01 Mar 2016, 15:42
by davie
Some of these are more obvious than others but some should start a good argument
Who ranks higher all time?
The Tigers - Dick or Flowers
The Leonards - Ray or Benny
The Henrys - Greb or Armstrong
The Kids - Gavilan or Chocolate
Carlos - Monzon or Ortiz
Gene - Tunney or Fullmer
2 Bobs - Fitsimmons or Montgomery
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 01 Mar 2016, 15:45
by Oiky
davie wrote:Some of these are more obvious than others but some should start a good argument
Who ranks higher all time?
The Tigers - Dick or Flowers
The Leonards - Ray or Benny
The Henrys - Greb or Armstrong
The Kids - Gavilan or Chocolate
Carlos - Monzon or Ortiz
Gene - Tunney or Fullmer
2 Bobs - Fitsimmons or Montgomery
tiger
ray
greb
monzon
fulmer
fitzsimmons
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 01 Mar 2016, 16:32
by davie
Oiky wrote:davie wrote:Some of these are more obvious than others but some should start a good argument
Who ranks higher all time?
The Tigers - Dick or Flowers
The Leonards - Ray or Benny
The Henrys - Greb or Armstrong
The Kids - Gavilan or Chocolate
Carlos - Monzon or Ortiz
Gene - Tunney or Fullmer
2 Bobs - Fitsimmons or Montgomery
tiger
Which one?
Also, Gavilan or Chocolate. (I was going to ask which kid do you prefer but couldn't think of a way of asking that didn't sound inappropriate)
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 01 Mar 2016, 17:00
by dr_devious
The Tigers - Dick
The Leonards - Ray
The Henrys - Greb or Armstrong - Draw
The Kids - Gavilan
Carlos - Monzon
Gene - Tunney
2 Bobs - Fitsimmons
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 01 Mar 2016, 17:10
by Oiky
davie wrote:Oiky wrote:davie wrote:Some of these are more obvious than others but some should start a good argument
Who ranks higher all time?
The Tigers - Dick or Flowers
The Leonards - Ray or Benny
The Henrys - Greb or Armstrong
The Kids - Gavilan or Chocolate
Carlos - Monzon or Ortiz
Gene - Tunney or Fullmer
2 Bobs - Fitsimmons or Montgomery
tiger
Which one?
Also, Gavilan or Chocolate. (I was going to ask which kid do you prefer but couldn't think of a way of asking that didn't sound inappropriate)
dick tiger and
yeah it would, i didn't even see them on the list at first, and kid gavilan
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 02 Mar 2016, 15:08
by davie
Dick Tiger
Sugar Ray Leonard
Henry Armstrong
Kids Gavilan
Carlos Monzon
Gene and Gene - Draw.
Bob Fitsimmons
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 02 Mar 2016, 16:12
by BoxBuzz
Was Harry Greb really Henry Greb?
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 02 Mar 2016, 16:39
by SaadOffTheDeck
Dick, Benny, greb, gavilan, monzon, Tunney, Fitzsimmons
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 02 Mar 2016, 17:02
by King Carlos
Dick
Benny
Armstrong, seeing as there was no Henry Greb to my knowledge. If we're talking about Harry Greb, then I'd rate him higher.
Gavilan
Monzon
Tunney
Fitzsimmons
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 02 Mar 2016, 17:59
by davie
BoxBuzz wrote:Was Harry Greb really Henry Greb?
Without checking I'm sure Boxrec has his full name as Edward Henry Greb. Although obviously he was known as Harry
I was having to stretch it a bit to get guys with the same name.
King Carlos, will I take your original answer or is this sufficient to qualify Greb as a Henry?
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 02 Mar 2016, 18:47
by cfang
The Tigers - Dick or Flowers - Dick
The Leonards - Ray or Benny - mmm tough one this - im going Benny
The Henrys - Greb or Armstrong - Greb
The Kids - Gavilan or Chocolate - Gavilan
Carlos - Monzon or Ortiz - Monzon
Gene - Tunney or Fullmer - Tunney
2 Bobs - Fitsimmons or Montgomery - Fitz
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 05 Apr 2016, 00:46
by davie
New question
Joe Walcott - Jersey or Barbados
Jack Dempsey - Nonpareil or Manassa mauler
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 05 Apr 2016, 04:32
by dr_devious
Barbados and Dempsey
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 05 Apr 2016, 07:52
by elmersalsa
davie wrote:Some of these are more obvious than others but some should start a good argument
Who ranks higher all time?
The Tigers - Dick or Flowers
The Leonards - Ray or Benny
The Henrys - Greb or Armstrong
The Kids - Gavilan or Chocolate
Carlos - Monzon or Ortiz
Gene - Tunney or Fullmer
2 Bobs - Fitsimmons or Montgomery
Dick Tiger
Benny Leonard
Henry Armstrong
Kid Gavilan
Carlos Monzon
Gene Tunney
Bob Fitzsimmons
Re: Who ranks higher
Posted: 05 Apr 2016, 09:23
by PredatorHayds
Dick
Ray
Green
Gavilán
Monzon
Fullmer
Fitzsimmons