BoxRec

The fights that should have happened, but didn't.

Which fights would you like to have seen?

And who would have won?

I'll start us off. I really wished RJJ had fought Dariusz Michalczewski and I would have picked the Pole to win by decision.

Tito vs Mosley

I'd favor Mosley

Floyd vs Kostya Tszyu

Floyd W12

gilgamesh wrote:Floyd vs Kostya Tszyu

Floyd W12

I'd have to bet the other way. Fascinating fight though.

Bowe vs Lewis.....Bowe by stoppage.

This one was on my Dream Fights list for years. It's a bummer we didn't get to see it.

Rafael Marquez vs Jhonny Gonzalez

Would've been an absolute war, probably with both men hitting the canvas, but I figure Marquez would've ultimately come out on top with a KO win around the 7th or 8th round in what very would could've been the Fight of the Year had it happened.

keithmoonhangover wrote:The fights that should have happened, but didn't.

Which fights would you like to have seen?

And who would have won?

I'll start us off. I really wished RJJ had fought Dariusz Michalczewski and I would have picked the Pole to win by decision.

Damned stupid pick... Super slow Julio Gonzalez beat Michalczewski in Germany... and Roy Jones beat Julio Gonzalez so easily it was ridiculous. Michalczewski spent his career hiding in Germany -- from Antonio Tarver and Roy Jones... He wasn't like Gustav Scholz who was undefeated in his first 68 fights, came to the US to campaign in 1954, and couldn't get an appropriate Middleweight fight lined up.

Gustov Scholz vs Sugar Ray Robinson would have been interesting... Michael Nunn vs Sugar Ray Leonard didn't happen for obvious reasons... Leonard abandoned the Middleweight Title like Canelo did... Mike McCallum vs Marvin Hagler...

Mike McCallum exposes ducker Marvin Hagler: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TKMOqDLVFuk

Sugar Ray Leonard vs Aaron Pryor

Leonard wins a clear decision, but it would've been fun.

Mayweather vs Tszyu would have been interesting come to think of it... because one of the punches Floyd got nailed with where straight right hands -- and Zab Judah was even easier to hit with straight right hands - so he was a sitting duck for Tszyu... I still would have my money on Floyd to win, but an upset could happen because Tszyu ripped that straight right hand so well at his peak.

Historically, the 3 Welterweight fighters who would have beaten Floyd were Vernon Forrest... Errol Spence... and Kell Brook... Forrest had a terrific right hand at his peak for the 1st Mosley fight.. Mosley was 38-0 and called VF's right "the Whooo punch" ... After his first shoulder surgery VF was never the same.. He couldn't throw.. Spence and Brook are too big, strong, and tough for Floyd and punch too hard and fast.. It's Maidana times 10.

Salvador Sanchez vs Eusebio Pedroza...I'd pick Pedroza by UD.

Roberto Duran vs Alexis Arguello...Duran by TKO late.

Sugar Ray Robinson vs Tony Zale...A classic matchup between boxer vs puncher.

Sugar Ray Robinson vs Charley Burley

keithmoonhangover wrote:I really wished RJJ had fought Dariusz Michalczewski and I would have picked the Pole to win by decision.

I can't envisage that.

There's definitely a few that spring to mind immediately.

On the British side:

Ricky Hatton vs Junior Witter
Hatton could be troubled by clever boxers, I think Witter could frustrate him. But even so, I'd be facing Hatton to stop him.

Joe Calzaghe vs Carl Froch
Depends on the tear it is made. The older Froch got, the more chance I give him to win. But Calzaghe has to be the favourite.

Eusebio Pedrosa vs Azumah Nelson
I go back and forth on this one. Forseeably it could be a draw.

Joe Frazier vs Ken Norton
We didn't see it, but I do think Joe would have slaughtered him.

elmersalsa wrote:Salvador Sanchez vs Eusebio Pedroza...I'd pick Pedroza by UD.

I can't see that. I think Sanchez does him.

Crease wrote:

keithmoonhangover wrote:I really wished RJJ had fought Dariusz Michalczewski and I would have picked the Pole to win by decision.

I can't envisage that.

I saw a lot of his fights and I'd have bet on it. He wanted RJJ badly, but neither of them would leave home.

gilgamesh wrote:Floyd vs Kostya Tszyu

Floyd W12

Totally disagree. Patterson by KO1

Hamed v Barrera II - after the result was announced I seem to remember Naz (still in the ring) saying something about a rematch...can't remember his exact words but the impression I got was the rematch would happen.

Ambling Alp II wrote:

gilgamesh wrote:Floyd vs Kostya Tszyu

Floyd W12

Totally disagree. Patterson by KO1

Ade L wrote:Hamed v Barrera II - after the result was announced I seem to remember Naz (still in the ring) saying something about a rematch...can't remember his exact words

Bravado talk of a defeated man...

I believe that was the moment that Naz finally realised that he wasn't invincible after all.

After so many years of victories & hype, i think that he had been believing his own greatness. Thinking himself unbeatable for a long time before Barrera stopped his win streak.

Don't think it was impossible that Hamed could've crossed swords with Morales, Marquez, pac and mayweather, PLENTY of middleweight matchups that never happened in the 90s, would've liked to have seen Benn v Jackson, Toney v Eubank and Jones v Mclellan

Crease wrote:

Ade L wrote:Hamed v Barrera II - after the result was announced I seem to remember Naz (still in the ring) saying something about a rematch...can't remember his exact words

Bravado talk of a defeated man...

I believe that was the moment that Naz finally realised that he wasn't invincible after all.

After so many years of victories & hype, i think that he had been believing his own greatness. Thinking himself unbeatable for a long time before Barrera stopped his win streak.

In fairness, he was well past his peak when he fought Barrera. At his absolute best, other boxers could barely land a punch on him.

gilgamesh wrote:Sugar Ray Leonard vs Aaron Pryor

Leonard wins a clear decision, but it would've been fun.

I think it would have ended sooner than that. Between rounds 8 and 10. Leonard would have been all wrong for the Cincinnati Hawk.

Thomas Hearns vs Donald Curry

elmersalsa wrote:Thomas Hearns vs Donald Curry

James Toney vs Bernard Hopkins (circa 2003)

It was briefly being talked about these two fighting at a catchweight around this time following Toney's win over Jirov, but prior to the Holyfield bout.

Barry McGuigan vs Azumah Nelson would have been quality