BoxRec

Feel free to add any others that I may have missed

At heavyweight - Fury or Joshua?

At Supermiddle - Degale, Groves or Smith?

At Middle - Eubank or Saunders?

At Lightmiddle - Smith or Williams?

At Lightwelter - Catterall or Davies Jnr?

At Lightweight - Flanagan or Crolla?

At Superfeather - Smith (again) or Walsh?

At Feather - Frampton or Selby?

At Superbantam - Quigg or Galahad or Yafai?

At Superfly - Yafai or Conlan?

In my humble opinion these are all fighters without anyone being dominant over the other. I can offer my opinion but until they meet (Eubank Saunders aside) we have no idea.

Taansend wrote:Feel free to add any others that I may have missed

At heavyweight - Fury or Joshua?

At Supermiddle - Degale, Groves or Smith?

At Middle - Eubank or Saunders?

At Lightmiddle - Smith or Williams?

At Lightwelter - Catterall or Davies Jnr?

At Lightweight - Flanagan or Crolla?

At Superfeather - Smith (again) or Walsh?

At Feather - Frampton or Selby?

At Superbantam - Quigg or Galahad or Yafai?

At Superfly - Yafai or Conlan?

In my humble opinion these are all fighters without anyone being dominant over the other. I can offer my opinion but until they meet (Eubank Saunders aside) we have no idea.

For my two bobs worth......

I'd lean towards Fury but he hasn't been in with a big punching, youthful, determined heavyweight yet so I'll be neutral.

Probably Smith. Degale the best boxer but he drifts in & out of fights. Groves I love but his chin is not brilliant.

I would go with Eubank these days as Saunders seems to be f*cking about.

Smith or Williams? No f*cking clue.

Lightwelter - I'd love your input

I can't choose between Flanagan or Crolla.

I'd pick Walsh over Smith but it's not a strong pick.

I'd have Selby beating Frampton in a boring fight. Carl best against fighters coming at him.

Yafai.

And Yafai

Aw, I was hoping this was going to be a Britain’s Guv’nor thread....

Taansend wrote:Feel free to add any others that I may have missed

At heavyweight - Fury or Joshua?

At Supermiddle - Degale, Groves or Smith?

At Middle - Eubank or Saunders?

At Lightmiddle - Smith or Williams?

At Lightwelter - Catterall or Davies Jnr?

At Lightweight - Flanagan or Crolla?

At Superfeather - Smith (again) or Walsh?

At Feather - Frampton or Selby?

At Superbantam - Quigg or Galahad or Yafai?

At Superfly - Yafai or Conlan?

In my humble opinion these are all fighters without anyone being dominant over the other. I can offer my opinion but until they meet (Eubank Saunders aside) we have no idea.

Right now Fury.

DeGale is the man at 168 just now.

I'd go for Eubank over Saunders if they were to fight again. Close though.

Smith v Williams would be a very good contest. Right now I'd favour Smith.

Catterall or Nurse at 140. Nurse is a tough nights work for any domestic guy. Josh Taylor will be taking over soon though

Flanagan over Crolla I reckon but not with any confidence.

Walsh beats Smith handily IMO. Very underrated.

Frampton all day at 126.

I think Quigg beats Galahad at SBW but Yafai could be a dark horse there. Still I'll go with Quigg.

Yafai beats Conlon in a decent little scrap.

Taansend wrote:I would go with Eubank these days as Saunders seems to be f*cking about.

Atleast he got a solid win over Andy Lee, Eubank has been facing part timers and domestic opponents, rather than showing any improvement in opposition, if anything his opposition has been regressing.

Fury, I wouldn't even have Joshua at the #2 spot to be honest. Haye would clean his clock.
Smith
Saunders
Smith
Davie Jr
Flanagan
Smith
Frampton
Quigg
Conlan

Fury
Bellew
Clev
DeGale
Saunders
Smith
Brook
Daws
Flanagan
Smith
Frampton
Quigg
McDonnell
Yafai
Selby

At heavyweight - Fury or Joshua? FURY

At Supermiddle - Degale, Groves or Smith? DEGALE

At Middle - Eubank or Saunders? SAUNDERS

At Lightmiddle - Smith or Williams? SMITH

At Lightwelter - Catterall or Davies Jnr? CATTERALL

At Lightweight - Flanagan or Crolla? FLANAGAN

At Superfeather - Smith (again) or Walsh? SMITH

At Feather - Frampton or Selby? FRAMPTON

At Superbantam - Quigg or Galahad or Yafai? QUIGG

At Superfly - Yafai or Conlan? CONLAN

Taansend wrote:Feel free to add any others that I may have missed

At heavyweight - Fury or Joshua?

At Supermiddle - Degale, Groves or Smith?

At Middle - Eubank or Saunders?

At Lightmiddle - Smith or Williams?

At Lightwelter - Catterall or Davies Jnr?

At Lightweight - Flanagan or Crolla?

At Superfeather - Smith (again) or Walsh?

At Feather - Frampton or Selby?

At Superbantam - Quigg or Galahad or Yafai?

At Superfly - Yafai or Conlan?

In my humble opinion these are all fighters without anyone being dominant over the other. I can offer my opinion but until they meet (Eubank Saunders aside) we have no idea.

Fury but find them tricky to split, Joshua looks a million dollars disposing of B level fighters whilst Fury has beaten the better opposition but can be accused of looking ungainly at times and isn't much of a banger.

Have a feeling Callum can dominate the Super middle division, certainly think he gives both of them hard fights, wonder how Groves would handle that power?

Think Saunders would pip Eubank again, Eubank doesn't seem to have learnt from the mistakes that cost him the first fight, still telegraphs, attacks in straight lines, lacks a jab etc

Smith for now but Williams looks a class talent

Cant split Catterall and Davies junior right now in all honesty, maybe we'll have more idea when we see them in against Nurse, Jenkins, Daws level fighters

Crolla for me, Flanagan has looked relatively average Magdaleno fight aside whilst Crolla seems to have found a new level to his game

Smith just about for me, just looks to have a bit more too him and has boxed at the slightly higher level

Despite his flashy style Selby eats a bit to much leather for me, can see him getting outfought on the inside

Got to be Quigg, sparring stories aside he's much more experienced than Galahad and looks by far the bigger stronger kid, Yafai is still something of a prospect

Yafai easy work, Conlans a brave kid but Yafai is just a class above for me

HW Fury.
Even though I didn't think he'd beat Wlad and thought his resume was unimpressive before, Cunningham, Chisora x2, a much more useful Kevin Johnson and Hammer is still better than all of Joshua's wins.

SMW Degale.
In hindsight, he probably should have got the nod over Groves. His resume is much better. He looks bad sometimes, but so did Calzaghe, so did Froch, so did Eubank, so did Benn. I think he will come out on top as the best SMW, but he might catch abother loss and he will earn his stripes.

At Middle - Eubank or Saunders?
I hate Saunders but he's still more proven. I would love to see Eubank (who I still quite like) beat him up in the rematch. But for now the horrible ducking little gobshite has me listening when he says he is the best.

At Lightmiddle - Smith or Williams?
Couldn't give a shit, mate.

At Lightwelter - Catterall or Davies
No idea. This is a terrible division for us, isn't it? Never even watched either of them fight.

At Lightweight - Crolla
At Superfeather - dunno
At Feather - Frampton, based on his recent performances. Selby looked a bit fragile last time I saw him and Frampton seems to have a decent dig.

At Superbantam - I don't really watch the division and I know I'll get hate for it but Galahad looked mustard prior to his ban, so I'll go with him.

At heavyweight - Fury

At Supermiddle - Degale

At Middle - Eubank

At Lightmiddle - Smith

At Lightwelter - Burns

At Lightweight - Crolla

At Superfeather - Smith

At Feather - Frampton

At Superbantam - Quigg

At Superfly - Yafai

PredatorHayds wrote:Fury
Bellew
Clev
DeGale
Saunders
Smith
Brook
Daws
Flanagan
Smith
Frampton
Quigg
McDonnell
Yafai
Selby

Ignore my above LWW choice. Burns over Daws

Got to be fury.

At heavyweight - Fury

At Supermiddle - Degale

At Middle - Saunders

At Lightmiddle - Smith

At Lightwelter - Catterall

At Lightweight - Flanagan

At Superfeather - Smith

At Feather - Frampton

At Superbantam - Quigg

At Superfly - Yafai

At heavyweight - Fury or Joshua? Fury

At Supermiddle - Degale, Groves or Smith? De Gale

At Middle - Eubank or Saunders? Saunders

At Lightmiddle - Smith or Williams? Smith

At Lightwelter - Catterall or Davies Jnr? Burns

At Lightweight - Flanagan or Crolla? Flanagan

At Superfeather - Smith (again) or Walsh? Walsh

At Feather - Frampton or Selby? Frampton

At Superbantam - Quigg or Galahad or Yafai? Quigg

At Superfly - Yafai or Conlan? Butler and Mcdonnell best bantam

At heavyweight - Fury

At Supermiddle - Degale

At Middle - Saunders (at the moment) Eubank JR needs more rounds

At Lightmiddle - Smith

At Lightwelter - Burns (Grudgingly) Nurse close second until he fights at world level

At Lightweight - Flanagan ( Crolla can perform at world class level but Flanagan is tough as old boots)

At Superfeather - Smith

At Feather - Frampton

At Superbantam - Quigg

At Superfly - Yafai

Liam Walsh is the best superfeather & potentially best lightweight. He KO's Stephen Smith if it could be made and I think he'd continue his progres at LW.