BoxRec

I think this is an interesting fight actually

Split decision last time, the winner maybe to fight the McDonnell/ Solis winner

What's everyone's thoughts on who wins?

Stuey didn't get going early enough for me last time, I hope he does this time obviously as a friend

Good fight though for me anyway.....

Thought Hall won last time think butler knicks this though age might just catch up with stuey think butlers youth will win him this fight I still think it's a very tough night for him though would love to see stuey get the win though going to be a good fight

Butler points, the last fight was in the north east the rematch is in Liverpool with likely a load of Liverpool fighters on the card.

I'd rather Hall just got a straight shot at Burnett.

The first fight was solid. Seems like I had it for Hall, but it's been a while and I'm not 100% sure anymore.

The rematch should be solid.

Looking forward to this bill to be fair.

Butler v Hall
Dodd v Stalker
Fielding v Brophy
Farrell v Davies

You'd expect Smith v Skoglung to be here too altho the promotional situation on that fight doesn't seem that clear to me.

Horse wrote:I'd rather Hall just got a straight shot at Burnett.

That's what I thought was happening. Surprised to read this today.

Stuarty30 wrote:That's what I thought was happening. Surprised to read this today.

He could have fought both of them, before moving on to unify.

Good learning fights with a bit of risk.

Made sense to me.

Horse wrote:

Stuarty30 wrote:That's what I thought was happening. Surprised to read this today.

He could have fought both of them, before moving on to unify.

Good learning fights with a bit of risk.

Made sense to me.

Yeah true.

Stuarty30 wrote:

Horse wrote:I'd rather Hall just got a straight shot at Burnett.

That's what I thought was happening. Surprised to read this today.

Burnett has a mandatory due against this guy.

http://boxrec.com/boxer/614887

jameswilson wrote:Looking forward to this bill to be fair.

Butler v Hall
Dodd v Stalker
Fielding v Brophy
Farrell v Davies

You'd expect Smith v Skoglung to be here too altho the promotional situation on that fight doesn't seem that clear to me.

The card is decent actually it's four domestic British level fights

Outside of Dodd beating Stalker I'm not confident in any picks.

I think the Tete defeat has ruined Butler at the top level.

I will be having a nibble on Hall via Points.

PredatorHayds wrote:I think the Tete defeat has ruined Butler at the top level.

I will be having a nibble on Hall via Points.

If it's close Hall gets robbed... which is what I think will happen.

Just had a look at Butlers resume. By the time of this fight it will have been two and a half years since the Tete fight.

In that time Butler has just faced Latino nobodies in his peak years. At least Hall has fought that Guerrero who was a similar level and Haskins who he arguably beat ( dreadful fight though).

Bored of Hall now to be honest....reminds me of the IBF South African circle jerk days at 130

Winner gets Burnett, loser gets the winner of that (probably Burnett), Haskins get added back to the merry-go-round, and so on.

jameswilson wrote:Looking forward to this bill to be fair.

Butler v Hall
Dodd v Stalker
Fielding v Brophy
Farrell v Davies

You'd expect Smith v Skoglung to be here too altho the promotional situation on that fight doesn't seem that clear to me.

Surprised that Davies is coming back that soon. Tough kid. Smith/skoglund is the 16th. I think it's in Liverpool.

crusader wrote:Bored of Hall now to be honest....reminds me of the IBF South African circle jerk days at 130

Winner gets Burnett, loser gets the winner of that (probably Burnett), Haskins get added back to the merry-go-round, and so on.

Is that it looks like will happen to Burnett belt(mandatory aside)? Or does it look like he'll try unify against the hatton trained fighter?

watsupdoc87 wrote:

crusader wrote:Bored of Hall now to be honest....reminds me of the IBF South African circle jerk days at 130

Winner gets Burnett, loser gets the winner of that (probably Burnett), Haskins get added back to the merry-go-round, and so on.

Is that it looks like will happen to Burnett belt(mandatory aside)? Or does it look like he'll try unify against the hatton trained fighter?

In an ideal world it should be Burnett fighting Rodriguez then the butler hall winner

Whilst McDonnell fights solis then Zhakiyanov to clear up the WBA mess.

Then the do unification.

Didnt expect to see ohara out again so quick. I wonder if how much he can work on after the taylor fight.

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:

jameswilson wrote:Looking forward to this bill to be fair.

Butler v Hall
Dodd v Stalker
Fielding v Brophy
Farrell v Davies

You'd expect Smith v Skoglung to be here too altho the promotional situation on that fight doesn't seem that clear to me.

Surprised that Davies is coming back that soon. Tough kid. Smith/skoglund is the 16th. I think it's in Liverpool.

Wouldn't if be ironic is The Sauerlands just staged it in Flint, Michigan for a laugh.

Naandrew wrote:

watsupdoc87 wrote:

crusader wrote:Bored of Hall now to be honest....reminds me of the IBF South African circle jerk days at 130

Winner gets Burnett, loser gets the winner of that (probably Burnett), Haskins get added back to the merry-go-round, and so on.

Is that it looks like will happen to Burnett belt(mandatory aside)? Or does it look like he'll try unify against the hatton trained fighter?

In an ideal world it should be Burnett fighting Rodriguez then the butler hall winner

Whilst McDonnell fights solis then Zhakiyanov to clear up the WBA mess.

Then the do unification.

Cheers. Makes me head hurt trying to work out all these champions, super champs ect

watsupdoc87 wrote:

Naandrew wrote:

watsupdoc87 wrote:
Is that it looks like will happen to Burnett belt(mandatory aside)? Or does it look like he'll try unify against the hatton trained fighter?

In an ideal world it should be Burnett fighting Rodriguez then the butler hall winner

Whilst McDonnell fights solis then Zhakiyanov to clear up the WBA mess.

Then the do unification.

Cheers. Makes me head hurt trying to work out all these champions, super champs ect

That's an ideal scenario and as we know in boxing that never happens. Bantamweight will get very interesting in the next year. Inoue will be moving up possibly after his HBO debut in a couple of months.

I also fancy 24 year old Luis Nery to beat WBC and Ring magazine champion Yamanaka in a few weeks.

Then you have Tete who desperately needs a marquee fight.

Naandrew wrote:

watsupdoc87 wrote:

Naandrew wrote: In an ideal world it should be Burnett fighting Rodriguez then the butler hall winner

Whilst McDonnell fights solis then Zhakiyanov to clear up the WBA mess.

Then the do unification.

Cheers. Makes me head hurt trying to work out all these champions, super champs ect

That's an ideal scenario and as we know in boxing that never happens. Bantamweight will get very interesting in the next year. Inoue will be moving up possibly after his HBO debut in a couple of months.

I also fancy 24 year old Luis Nery to beat WBC and Ring magazine champion Yamanaka in a few weeks.

Then you have Tete who desperately needs a marquee fight.

I found Yamanaka and Uchiyama criminally ignored in boxing circles and P4P lists the last couple of years.
Age has caught up with one and like you say Yamanaka looks ripe for the taking now. Maybe Nery is the man to do it.

Looking forward to this one on Saturday, both guys don't seem to like each other so should make for a tasty scrap, I think it will be pretty much the same as their 1st fight, Butler showing the more eye catching shots with Hall setting the pace finding his range more as the fight goes on, I thought Hall nicked the 1st fight by a point but it was close

Butler's opposition since the loss to Tete has been woeful, he's had about 6 fights since then and they've come against poor opponents, Hall's definitely the biggest test since that loss, Stuey on the other hand has been in with Caballero and Haskins again in tough 12 rounders, Hall might be older but he's still fit as a fiddle and will make Butler did deep, ive always been a big fan of Butler he's one of the most talented fighters in the country IMO but he's lost a lot of momentum and his lack of a tough 12 round contest recently makes me go with Hall in this one, it'll be close again I reckon but I fancy Hall to nick it this time, his win over Guerrero is better than any of the wins Butler's had since the 1st fight

What Title is it for?

Londonirish wrote:What Title is it for?

Its a eliminator for McDonnell's WBA "Ordinary" belt