BoxRec

*

I was just about to pose this question. I am not sure who wins but I think that they both get put to sleep by The Preying Mantis On Ice (Wilder).

50/50 match to me. I think it'd be a close decision whoever came out on top. I might favor Whyte ever so slightly due to better conditioning.

I hate to pick against Whyte who I have a lot of time for, but as I see it Baby outworks him and has better handspeed. As I said on the Wach thread I don't see Baby's weight or conditioning as an issue, in fact I'd count stamina as one of his best attributes. Another one is his chin. Joshua or Wilder might exploit the ease with which Miller can get tagged, but I think you must have exceptional power to discourage Miller, never mind knock him out. I don't think Whyte's power is up to the task.

See it similar to the Del Boy fight, so could go either way. I’ll go Whyte to sneak a close one

Miller all day. He doesn’t need tremendous power to put Whyte away and W won’t hurt him. I was impressed by Miller yesterday. So relaxed, very comfortable, un-dettered even when Wach had his moments of success. Was outworking him prior to the injury and stuck to that. Miller knows his limits and doesn’t try to load up too much and doesn’t gas himself out plus he has a decent chin. Whyte will be outworked, Miller could eventually start walking through him and Millers team will have the better game plan.

Miller probably wears him down gradually, either very late stoppage very close points win.

I was impressed with Miller. By today's HW standard, he excels.

I'd pick him over Whyte.

I voted Miller by decision. He was more impressive than Whyte, but to me neither were very impressive. Matching the two up seems like a pretty even fight. I view both as slightly above gate-keeper status, which doesn't say much for today's heavyweight scene.

Miller by late stoppage

miller, but theyre very well matched

It's quite amazing how much acclaim Whyte gets for landing one punch on AJ and being beaten by the ghost of Chisora. Miller would end this little fantasy for sure.

I wouldn’t expect to see a bout between Whyte and Miller during the first half of next year, because both men are tantalisingly close to securing lucrative world title opportunities (i.e. Dillian versus Wilder; and Jarrell versus Joshua).

In terms of the outcome of this mythical match-up, I’d expect Dillian Whyte to outwork and outbox the moderately obese ‘Big Baby’ en route to scoring a comfortable decision victory.

I’d like to see how Miller would cope with Whyte’s excellent body shots, since the ‘Big Baby’ is hardly a devastating puncher and also doesn’t move around the ring very well.

The American is clearly incapable of adopting the same lateral movement tactics employed by Robert Helenius when he fought Whyte…

I regret not predicting that the winner would be whoever doesn't suffer a freak injury.