BoxRec

How would you rank these fighters from best to worst and why?

Bradley is proven to be better all of them and shouldn't even be compared to the other 3.

Bradley - Better than the rest and I don't even compare him.


Peterson Outside of Mattysse and Spence, he's been a tough fight for even those who beat him.
Alexander probably the most underrated of the bottom 3 as he's never been stopped.
Berto: While I respect that he's always there to fight, I think the other bottom guys deserved the same paydays and chances he got in his career.

Yeah, Bradley is 100 floors above the other three - clear wins over Alexander and Peterson. and also beat Marquez and took rounds off Pacquiao.

-------------------------------------------------------

I'd put Alexander next. I'd rather watch Peterson fight but DA does have that 10 round win over Maidana (probably got him at just the right time admittedly) which I think just trumps Peterson's best win. If memory serves he should have lost to Matthysse and Kotelnik.

Peterson has the very contentious win over Khan, but was badly KO'd in his prime by Matthysse. He gave Bradley a better fight than DA though.

-------------------------------------------------------

Berto was beaten in his prime by Ortiz, Guerrero and Soto-Karass. Against that his best win is probably the contentious one over Collazo.

Perhaps a better question would be between Alexander, Peterson, Maidana, Matthysse, Rios, Khan and Provodnikov?