BoxRec

15 rounds, circa 1946-1948, who wins?

Sugar Ray..

Sugar Ray Robinson was in a league all by his self. He was a total package all the way around. Ike Williams i also hold in high regard. I am from the Trenton NJ area and Ike by far is the greatest ever to come out of the capital city. Ike was one of the greatest lightweights of all time Sugar Ray was one of the greatest welterweights ever he is just to big for Ike. Yes these are two of the very best ever however Sugar Ray is greater bigger and faster and that is the difference.

PFP I have these men in my top 5 of fighters I've seen. Robinson would stop him.

As good that I like the great Ike Williams, who in my view is one of the top 50 greatest pound per pound fighters ever, I cannot see him beating the original Sugar Man. The year 1948 was the year when both were at their peak, really.

Robinson wins by late KO.