BoxRec

murata-brant came up on the side of the youtube bar today

brant dominates the first fight, absolutely lighting murata up and winning almost every round

but then murata destroys him in 2 in the rematch



what are cases where a guy lost a fight one sided, but then won a rematch?

Holly Holm vs Anne Sophie Mathis gets kayoed in the first fight, gets written off, and wins the rematch.

It was an early stoppage, but Brian Rose beat Carson Jones comfortably on points after being stopped in the first round in the first meeting.

Willie Pep/Saddler
Terry Norris/Simon Brown
Patterson/Johansson (?)
Lewis/Rahmon


or am I missing something here?

Louis/Schmeling

oogiebe wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:11 Willie Pep/Saddler
Terry Norris/Simon Brown
Patterson/Johansson (?)
Lewis/Rahmon


or am I missing something here?

Think Lewis was up on all the cards when he got put to kip.

(craig) wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:27

oogiebe wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:11 Willie Pep/Saddler
Terry Norris/Simon Brown
Patterson/Johansson (?)
Lewis/Rahmon


or am I missing something here?

Think Lewis was up on all the cards when he got put to kip.

Getting put to sleep is a pretty clear loss

(craig) wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:27

oogiebe wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:11 Willie Pep/Saddler
Terry Norris/Simon Brown
Patterson/Johansson (?)
Lewis/Rahmon


or am I missing something here?

Think Lewis was up on all the cards when he got put to kip.

That is true, so maybe it doesn't fit into Mag's OP

the ko was big but the fight itself wasnt one sided, what i had in mind were fights where one guy showed general dominance or just basically blew him out quick, but then the rematch the other guy won

a close fight that ends with a big ko has a different dynamic for a rematch than a dominant win, does. i think generally its easier to see how the guy in the close fight can adjust than it is for the dominated guy

but it still does happen

witherspoon- bonecrusher

timmy wins wide first fight, then crusher kos him in 1 the rematch

although this rematch is notorious for rumors that witherspoon threw the fight to get away from king. not sure if thats true at all, people love to make excuses for spoon and his 'off' nights

margaret thatcher wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:51 witherspoon- bonecrusher

timmy wins wide first fight, then crusher kos him in 1 the rematch

although this rematch is notorious for rumors that witherspoon threw the fight to get away from king. not sure if thats true at all, people love to make excuses for spoon and his 'off' nights

Was going to mention that one, but was thinking about getting blown out of the first fight only to come back and win the second.

Norton/Garcia

A bit of time between fights, but Garcia had norton wobbling around the ring from the first round.

tonyevs wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:37

(craig) wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:27

oogiebe wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:11 Willie Pep/Saddler
Terry Norris/Simon Brown
Patterson/Johansson (?)
Lewis/Rahmon


or am I missing something here?

Think Lewis was up on all the cards when he got put to kip.

Getting put to sleep is a pretty clear loss

I agree getting put to sleep is conclusive but the OP asked for one sided losses that were avenged.

(craig) wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 04:21

tonyevs wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:37

(craig) wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 03:27

Think Lewis was up on all the cards when he got put to kip.

Getting put to sleep is a pretty clear loss

I agree getting put to sleep is conclusive but the OP asked for one sided losses that were avenged.

This

DeGale Truax?

AJ Ruiz?

Jones Hopkins

McCall Lewis. I mean waste necessarily one sided but Lennox still got flattened

Audley Harrison v Danny Williams
Danny Williams v Matt Skelton

Sergey Kovalev vs Eleider Alvarez

Seth Mitchell v Johnathan (sic) Banks.
Made some money on their first fight. Lost on the rematch. Couldn't see anything other than a repeat in that rematch. Never overestimate Banks. Very frustrating.

Pat Cowdell getting blitzed in one round versus Najib Daho, in the rematch Pat beat Najib by 9th round stoppage.

Cholo_cws wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 11:47 Seth Mitchell v Johnathan (sic) Banks.
Made some money on their first fight. Lost on the rematch. Couldn't see anything other than a repeat in that rematch. Never overestimate Banks. Very frustrating.

Fix,fix,fix.

I'm trying to think of a dominant points win for a boxer, but then table turned in a rematch and the loser of the first one wins wide points decision.

Would Ali v Fraser 1 and 2 qualify?

Old bones Ian wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 14:47 I'm trying to think of a dominant points win for a boxer, but then table turned in a rematch and the loser of the first one wins wide points decision.

Would Ali v Fraser 1 and 2 qualify?

I don't think either I or II was dominant.

Old bones Ian wrote: ↑23 Oct 2021, 14:28 Pat Cowdell getting blitzed in one round versus Najib Daho, in the rematch Pat beat Najib by 9th round stoppage.

Good example, Williams and Harrison too.