Page 1 of 1
Top 10 preformances vs Canelo since Mayweather.
Posted: 07 Nov 2021, 03:31
by gregregegg
Heard a few people really rating how plant did. got me thinking howwell did he do compared to others in his position.....
Rank your order of top 10 best efforts vs the current top dog in boxing.
For me it goes.
1) GGG 1
2) Lara
3) GGG 2
4) Jacobs
5) Kov
6) Plant
7) Billy
8) Kahn
9) Cotto
10)Smith (cnt actualy decide which one).
This is my order of who went closet to beating canelo.... (i think top 2 did beat canelo).
Re: Top 10 preformances vs Canelo since Mayweather.
Posted: 07 Nov 2021, 03:53
by KiwiRider
Smith dilemma:
Liam was fighting to win, Callum was trying to survive. Make of that what you will. Personally I like the guy trying to win.
Re: Top 10 preformances vs Canelo since Mayweather.
Posted: 07 Nov 2021, 03:56
by DrDuke
1. Golovkin II. The best scalp easily.
2. Jacobs. A proved top fighter.
3. Cotto. A proved top fighter of those period.
4. Kovalev. He was a belt-holder, but his conditions and reputation clearly were declined.
5. Callum Smith. He was arguably the best SMW at that point, but was coming off a lackluster performance.
6. Lara. On paper it should be higher, but it was a very dodgy decision.
7-8. BJS / Plant. Both were belt-holders with thin resumes.
9. Golovkin I. On paper should be higher, but he lost that.
10. Khan. More of a name on a resume, than an actual big win.
Re: Top 10 preformances vs Canelo since Mayweather.
Posted: 07 Nov 2021, 04:01
by Onetimeonly
DrDuke wrote: ↑07 Nov 2021, 03:56
1. Golovkin II. The best scalp easily.
2. Jacobs. A proved top fighter.
3. Cotto. A proved top fighter of those period.
4. Kovalev. He was a belt-holder, but his conditions and reputation clearly were declined.
5. Callum Smith. He was arguably the best SMW at that point, but was coming off a lackluster performance.
6. Lara. On paper it should be higher, but it was a very dodgy decision.
7-8. BJS / Plant. Both were belt-holders with thin resumes.
9. Golovkin I. On paper should be higher, but he lost that.
10. Khan. More of a name on a resume, than an actual big win.
Think you read it backwards.
Re: Top 10 preformances vs Canelo since Mayweather.
Posted: 07 Nov 2021, 04:05
by DrDuke
Onetimeonly wrote: ↑07 Nov 2021, 04:01
DrDuke wrote: ↑07 Nov 2021, 03:56
1. Golovkin II. The best scalp easily.
2. Jacobs. A proved top fighter.
3. Cotto. A proved top fighter of those period.
4. Kovalev. He was a belt-holder, but his conditions and reputation clearly were declined.
5. Callum Smith. He was arguably the best SMW at that point, but was coming off a lackluster performance.
6. Lara. On paper it should be higher, but it was a very dodgy decision.
7-8. BJS / Plant. Both were belt-holders with thin resumes.
9. Golovkin I. On paper should be higher, but he lost that.
10. Khan. More of a name on a resume, than an actual big win.
Think you read it backwards.
Oh indeed, I misread it as 'top performances of Canelo'.
Re: Top 10 preformances vs Canelo since Mayweather.
Posted: 07 Nov 2021, 04:13
by DrDuke
Okay, now VS Canelo, not BY him.
1. Golovkin I. He won Canelo.
2. Lara. I lean more towards him than Canelo in their bout.
3. Golovkin II. Made a close fight.
4. Jacobs. Close, but here Canelo finally won without any doubts.
5. Cotto. Made it competetive and was able to last until the end.
6. Kovalev. Winning on points before getting KOed.
7. Khan. Winning on points before getting KOed too.
8. Plant. Made it competetive and almost lasted until the end.
9. Saunders. Made it relatively competetive, but not for long.
10. Callum. Simply survived, but better than his brother, because the bro didn't score a lot of success, just a bit more of it, while he was crushed evetually.
Re: Top 10 preformances vs Canelo since Mayweather.
Posted: 07 Nov 2021, 05:19
by margaret thatcher
1. ggg 1
2. ggg 2
3. lara
4. kov
5. jacobs
6. cotto
7. plant
8. saunders
9.khan
10. angulo
Re: Top 10 preformances vs Canelo since Mayweather.
Posted: 07 Nov 2021, 15:51
by gregregegg
Interesting that people I talk to directly rate it as a 7thish best effort effort, yet I have seen considerable posts (social media) suggesting plant had canelo bamboozled and it’s almost rematch worthy…
Plant did well early, everyone but yildrum and fielding have done well early though…
Re: Top 10 preformances vs Canelo since Mayweather.
Posted: 07 Nov 2021, 16:10
by gilgamesh
Golovkin twice who beat Canelo twice obviously are #1 and #2. The rest are debatable.
Re: Top 10 preformances vs Canelo since Mayweather.
Posted: 07 Nov 2021, 16:32
by KiwiRider
DrDuke wrote: ↑07 Nov 2021, 04:13
Okay, now VS Canelo, not BY him.
1. Golovkin I. He won Canelo.
2. Lara. I lean more towards him than Canelo in their bout.
3. Golovkin II. Made a close fight.
4. Jacobs. Close, but here Canelo finally won without any doubts.
5. Cotto. Made it competetive and was able to last until the end.
6. Kovalev. Winning on points before getting KOed.
7. Khan. Winning on points before getting KOed too.
8. Plant. Made it competetive and almost lasted until the end.
9. Saunders. Made it relatively competetive, but not for long.
10. Callum. Simply survived, but better than his brother, because the bro didn't score a lot of success, just a bit more of it, while he was crushed evetually.
X2
This.
My Smith preference is different but negligible.