BoxRec

The first time they met (9/13/35) Boxrec shows this as 5-star matchup.

The second time they met just over two months later (11/29/35) it was a 3-star matchup.

In between fights Garcia had 3 wins and a draw.

Two years later when they met again it was back to a 5-star fight.

Is there a simple explanation for how/why that second fight calculates out to a 3-star fight? Thanks in advance.

Interesting.

Checking it today, the second Garcia fight is now listed as 5-stars just like the other two. I appreciate the correction. It would be nice to know if this were just a technical glitch with the formula or if there was another explanation.