Page 1 of 3
Current all time greats?
Posted: 28 Nov 2021, 20:16
by TonyJ
Canelo seems to be the only fighter currently fighting who has reached true all time great statues, and it’s obviously no easy feat but who are other fighters that have the potential to reach all time great achievements?
Usyk
Inoue
Ryan Garcia
Crawford
Spence
Loma
Benavidez
Teofimo let’s see how he bounces back
Notable mention
Ggg clock is ticking fast but still has one of two big wins in him imo.
Haney looks like a KO waiting to happen but we’ll see.
Tank may never get a chance to prove if he’s the real deal or not.
Those guys all have potential to get there especially the young guys have time on they’re side. Others like Usyk 34, loma 34 Bud 34 are on the wrong side of 30 so clocks ticking on them but things can still be achieved.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 28 Nov 2021, 20:26
by bobcatbox
Chocolatito.
Boots Ennis has potential to be a once in a generation talent at 147-154.
I think Fury is flirting with ATG status if he can string a few more big title defenses together. Especially if he meets and defeats Usyk, which he should.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 28 Nov 2021, 20:39
by TonyJ
bobcatbox wrote: ↑28 Nov 2021, 20:26
Chocolatito.
Boots Ennis has potential to be a once in a generation talent at 147-154.
I think Fury is flirting with ATG status if he can string a few more big title defenses together. Especially if he meets and defeats Usyk, which he should.
You’re right forgot Ennis and Vergil both definitely have that potential.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 28 Nov 2021, 20:52
by NateJR
Shakur Stevenson, especially if he does what he claims he will and win titles all the way up to 147.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 28 Nov 2021, 20:54
by TonyJ
NateJR wrote: ↑28 Nov 2021, 20:52
Shakur Stevenson, especially if he does what he claims he will and win titles all the way up to 147.
Yup Shakur forgot about him.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 28 Nov 2021, 22:08
by KiwiRider
Chockkie is already there in his weight class.
Canelo is a shoe in.
Crawford has wasted the last few years of his prime. He could have cleaned out welter straight after SLW, but sat around doing nothing of real note. Probably too late now.
Things move too slow at HW for Uysk to cement any real legacy. 6 months for a rematch? Forgettaboutit
Inoue has a chance. May need better promotion to get the fights made.
Spence, way too soon. How many good wins has he had? About 5 too few to even be considered.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 28 Nov 2021, 22:13
by TonyJ
Yes Canelo is the only shoe in right now.
You’re right I tend to overlook Chocolatito because his last few losses but he’s still competing witht the top of the division and arguably beat Estrada who’s also still young primed and doing big things.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 28 Nov 2021, 23:58
by DrDuke
Potential can be seen in many fighters. It's way too early to mention the likes of Shakur Stevenson or Ryan Garcia.
The likes of Canelo, Crawford, Inoue, Taylor, Usyk, Fury, Lomachenko, Golovkin, Gonzalez are on the verge indeed.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 00:04
by mcrow24
I think Canelo is the only all-time great right now.
Some of the others mentioned here could make the list if they can win some more big fights. Some of these really young guys have no business being mentioned at this point. Many a young stud prospect or even young champ has failed to move beyond that status.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 01:46
by TonyJ
DrDuke wrote: ↑28 Nov 2021, 23:58
Potential can be seen in many fighters. It's way too early to mention the likes of Shakur Stevenson or Ryan Garcia.
The likes of Canelo, Crawford, Inoue, Taylor, Usyk, Fury, Lomachenko, Golovkin, Gonzalez are on the verge indeed.
Canelo already is.
The other guys are on the verge if they can get a couple more good wins.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 02:19
by gregregegg
Canelo clearly is.
I think Usyk already clearly is. Gold medalist, All the belts fighting away through a strong cruiser division, smoked a big, prime heavy with arguably the deepest resume of the current era. Its as good as it gets really.
I wouldent have anyone else definatly there yet although GGG should probably be, and crawford may well be in hindsight.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 04:41
by Enlightened-One
TonyJ wrote: ↑28 Nov 2021, 20:16
Canelo seems to be the only fighter currently fighting who has reached true all time great statues, and it’s obviously no easy feat but who are other fighters that have the potential to reach all time great achievements?
Ryan Garcia
Spence
Benavidez
Yeofimo
Haney
Tank
Some of the names you’ve mentioned haven’t achieved anything particularly noteworthy.
I can’t believe you’re claiming these guys might become future all time greats, based on their current ages and feats!!!!!
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 04:49
by gregregegg
KiwiRider wrote: ↑28 Nov 2021, 22:08
Chockkie is already there in his weight class.
Canelo is a shoe in.
Crawford has wasted the last few years of his prime. He could have cleaned out welter straight after SLW, but sat around doing nothing of real note. Probably too late now.
Things move too slow at HW for Uysk to cement any real legacy. 6 months for a rematch? Forgettaboutit
Inoue has a chance. May need better promotion to get the fights made.
Spence, way too soon. How many good wins has he had? About 5 too few to even be considered.
Usyk already has a real legacy. Olympic gold, Probably the best cruiserweight run of all time, then chisora and AJ at heavyweight.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 05:28
by jamesmcdonnell
gregregegg wrote: ↑29 Nov 2021, 04:49
KiwiRider wrote: ↑28 Nov 2021, 22:08
Chockkie is already there in his weight class.
Canelo is a shoe in.
Crawford has wasted the last few years of his prime. He could have cleaned out welter straight after SLW, but sat around doing nothing of real note. Probably too late now.
Things move too slow at HW for Uysk to cement any real legacy. 6 months for a rematch? Forgettaboutit
Inoue has a chance. May need better promotion to get the fights made.
Spence, way too soon. How many good wins has he had? About 5 too few to even be considered.
Usyk already has a real legacy. Olympic gold, Probably the best cruiserweight run of all time, then chisora and AJ at heavyweight.
Usyk is one of a handful of people to move up to win a heavyweight title, and he did it against a guy who at least at one point, was considered the best heavyweight out there. So he's a lock for me.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 06:07
by jimcook
if canelo is, then ggg certainly is ,cos he beat canelo twice.
crawford is certainly an atg. spence will run away to 154 to avoid him....guaranteed.
loma.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 13:03
by BroughtonRulesRefuge
TonyJ wrote: ↑28 Nov 2021, 20:16
Canelo seems to be the only fighter currently fighting who has reached true all time great statues, and it’s obviously no easy feat but who are other fighters that have the potential to reach all time great achievements?
Usyk
Inoue
Ryan Garcia
Crawford
Spence
Loma
Benavidez
Teofimo let’s see how he bounces back
Notable mention
Ggg clock is ticking fast but still has one of two big wins in him imo.
Haney looks like a KO waiting to happen but we’ll see.
Tank may never get a chance to prove if he’s the real deal or not.
Those guys all have potential to get there especially the young guys have time on they’re side. Others like Usyk 34, loma 34 Bud 34 are on the wrong side of 30 so clocks ticking on them but things can still be achieved.
- -AJ obviously...Duh!!!
Unified all Wlad's titles and gave the great champ a crack at regaining them, and no fighter in any generation can said to have done more with titles, purses, and gate attendance with less fights than AJ.
Wiped out Haymon's heavy stable much as Hercules would've done. Banished Blubber Fury and Warren from the Isle to go begging to Arum to secure them a fight with the low hanging fruit of Deyonce for peanut purses because they couldn't compete with AJ filling stadiums in Britain all for the riches of Kings.
Yeah, AJ with a couple of setbacks still better than the rest of this lot save Canelo who has longevity over him, but guaranteed Usyk will be manhandled much as he was in the first fight until he managed to pop AJ's eye into temporary blindness in that fateful 9th round.
Usyk has earned his own HOF stripes with AJ as has his training mate Loma who had Teo ducking that rematch for a skinny little Aussie who whooped the pantyhose off Teo and his fat daddy. We'll see now if Kambo can man up to the biggest stadium fight in Aussie history against Loma, but of course Loma first has to clear the bigger, stronger, equally hard hitting Commey.
What else you boys need to know?
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 13:09
by margaret thatcher
ya, and remember that usyk only beat aj by 11 points out of a total of 685 points
348
337
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 14:40
by Cent0089
TonyJ wrote: ↑28 Nov 2021, 20:16
Canelo seems to be the only fighter currently fighting who has reached true all time great statues, and it’s obviously no easy feat but who are other fighters that have the potential to reach all time great achievements?
Usyk
Inoue
Ryan Garcia
Crawford
Spence
Loma
Benavidez
Teofimo let’s see how he bounces back
Notable mention
Ggg clock is ticking fast but still has one of two big wins in him imo.
Haney looks like a KO waiting to happen but we’ll see.
Tank may never get a chance to prove if he’s the real deal or not.
Those guys all have potential to get there especially the young guys have time on they’re side. Others like Usyk 34, loma 34 Bud 34 are on the wrong side of 30 so clocks ticking on them but things can still be achieved.
Well What these guys need to do to reach ATG status IMI:
Usyk - beat Fury
Fury - beat Usyk
Inoue - lot of work to do, Casimero, then move up to 122 and handle fighters like Fulton, Figueroa
Lomachenko - wasted atg potential IMO, still, if he can beat Kambosos, Teo rematch and Davis before retiring i will rate him as an atg
Crawford - beat Spence and Ennis
Spence - beat Crawford and Ennis
Benavidez - no ATG potential
GGG - wasted atg potential, but IMO he was avoided by Sturm, Quillin and Martinez, he should have all those guys on his resume by stoppage wins. But if he can decisively beat at least one elite guy i have no problem rate him pretty high
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 14:52
by gregregegg
margaret thatcher wrote: ↑29 Nov 2021, 13:09
ya, and remember that usyk only beat aj by 11 points out of a total of 685 points
348
337
Oh fornicate, I forgot how close it was. Wow….
On a serious note I forgot about this absolute shocking use of statistics. Who was making this claim again? Surely they have starved to death since because they couldent figure out what way to screw their penutbutter lid.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 14:54
by margaret thatcher
that was our boi broughton

Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 29 Nov 2021, 23:19
by USMCer
BoxRec current All-Time "points" (Top 500):
1379 - Manny Pacquiao (#16),
RECENTLY RETIRED
1290 - Saul Alvarez (#20)
943 - Gennadiy Golovkin (#65)
916 - Terence Crawford (#72)
828 - Tyson Fury (#100)
789 - Alexander Povetkin (#113),
739 - Sergio Martinez (#135),
AGE 46
625 - Errol Spence Jr (#170)
602 - Kell Brook (#185)
599 - Oleksandr Usyk (#186)
558 - Anthony Joshua (#203)
557 - Nonito Donaire (#206)
551 - Shawn Porter (#212)
532 - Demetrius Andrade (#230)
523 - Jermall Charlo (#240)
470 - Mairis Briedis (#282)
460 - Naoya Inoue (#291)
458 - Deontay Wilder (#295)
458 - Mikey Garcia (#296)
428 - Jermell Charlo (#332)
409 - Roman Gonzalez (#350)
409 - Gilberto Ramirez (#351)
408 - Erislandy Lara (#353)
406 - Daniel Jacobs (#357)
393 - Oscar Valdez (#366)
383 - Vasyl Lomachenko (#378t)
383 - Juan Francisco Estrada (#378t)
350 - Leo Santa Cruz (#432)
329 - Gervanta Davis (#466)
311 - Callum Smith (#499)
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 30 Nov 2021, 03:18
by Boxing Prospect
Donaire
Maybe an outside chance call for Wanheng, for his weight class
K. Taylor
Fujioka
Serrano
Shields
And then some of the names mentioned
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 30 Nov 2021, 03:45
by TonyJ
jimcook wrote: ↑29 Nov 2021, 06:07
if canelo is, then ggg certainly is ,cos he beat canelo twice.
crawford is certainly an atg. spence will run away to 154 to avoid him....guaranteed.
loma.
No fantasy world crap here.
Show me where Ggg holds wins over Canelo??? I like ggg but no he has one draw and one loss to Canelo.
It’s like me saying Floyd needs to get that 0 removed because Castillo beat him In the first fight. As it stands Floyd retired undefeated it’s just the way it is.
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 30 Nov 2021, 09:28
by jimcook
so corrupt judges and drug cheats decide who is an atg??
ggg was twice the fighter canelo will ever be.
and i like canelo
Re: Current all time greats?
Posted: 30 Nov 2021, 09:57
by Bandog
TonyJ wrote: ↑28 Nov 2021, 20:16
Canelo seems to be the only fighter currently fighting who has reached true all time great statues, and it’s obviously no easy feat but who are other fighters that have the potential to reach all time great achievements?
Usyk
Inoue
Ryan Garcia
Crawford
Spence
Loma
Benavidez
Teofimo let’s see how he bounces back
Notable mention
Ggg clock is ticking fast but still has one of two big wins in him imo.
Haney looks like a KO waiting to happen but we’ll see.
Tank may never get a chance to prove if he’s the real deal or not.
Those guys all have potential to get there especially the young guys have time on they’re side. Others like Usyk 34, loma 34 Bud 34 are on the wrong side of 30 so clocks ticking on them but things can still be achieved.
Ryan Garcia? He might someday, but seems far fetched. Who knows.