Page 1 of 1
had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 28 Nov 2022, 12:33
by dickbelden
*
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 28 Nov 2022, 13:44
by adislav123
objectively rewatching the fight one really can't disagree that franklin at the very least deserved a draw.
realistically also everybody including franklin and his team knew already before that if they somehow leave the decision up to the corrupt judges they will get 100% guaranteed shat on.
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 28 Nov 2022, 13:51
by margaret thatcher
close fight, could've been a draw or close either way i thought
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 28 Nov 2022, 13:56
by Ruthless-RKO
margaret thatcher wrote: ↑28 Nov 2022, 13:51
close fight, could've been a draw or close either way i thought
A bit of a mixed bag here so far.
https://eyeonthering.com/boxing/dillian ... e-franklin
There is a 117-11 for Whyte however
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 28 Nov 2022, 18:26
by Bandog
TBH, it looked more like a tough man fight. Young Jared Anderson would have stopped either one.
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 29 Nov 2022, 02:37
by DrDuke
Draw is the best option for Franklin. I had it 115-113 for Whyte.
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 29 Nov 2022, 06:00
by wrighty
I had Franklin up 2. Could argue whyte should have had a knockdown in the final round, the ropes kept Franklin up
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 29 Nov 2022, 19:09
by Thomastearns
I'm biased in favour of Dillian Whyte.
However, if he hadn't pulled out those final 2 strong rounds I was prepared to accept that he'd been given the decision.
As it was, and I felt the same way in Hagler v Leonard and GGG v Canelo 1 and 2, it's up to the challenger to take away the belts from the defending champion.
Jermaine Franklin got very close, but didn't do quite enough.
A draw would have been more acceptable than those two 116-112 scorecards. It was certainly closer than that.
I hope Franklin uses this as a learning experience and comes back even stronger. His lack of experience in the 'championship rounds' left some room for the judges to fudge it.
In future he'll know better than to leave them that room.
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 29 Nov 2022, 20:06
by dickbelden
Thomastearns wrote: ↑29 Nov 2022, 19:09
I'm biased in favour of Dillian Whyte.
However, if he hadn't pulled out those final 2 strong rounds I was prepared to accept that he'd been given the decision.
As it was, and I felt the same way in Hagler v Leonard and GGG v Canelo 1 and 2, it's up to the challenger to take away the belts from the defending champion.
Jermaine Franklin got very close, but didn't do quite enough.
A draw would have been more acceptable than those two 116-112 scorecards. It was certainly closer than that.
I hope Franklin uses this as a learning experience and comes back even stronger. His lack of experience in the 'championship rounds' left some room for the judges to fudge it.
In future he'll know better than to leave them that room.
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 29 Nov 2022, 20:09
by dickbelden
Thomastearns wrote: ↑29 Nov 2022, 19:09
I'm biased in favour of Dillian Whyte.
However, if he hadn't pulled out those final 2 strong rounds I was prepared to accept that he'd been given the decision.
As it was, and I felt the same way in Hagler v Leonard and GGG v Canelo 1 and 2, it's up to the challenger to take away the belts from the defending champion.
Jermaine Franklin got very close, but didn't do quite enough.
A draw would have been more acceptable than those two 116-112 scorecards. It was certainly closer than that.
I hope Franklin uses this as a learning experience and comes back even stronger. His lack of experience in the 'championship rounds' left some room for the judges to fudge it.
In future he'll know better than to leave them that room.
I had LEONARD beating HAGLER---had GGG beating CANELO in the 1st 2 fights.
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 02 Dec 2022, 17:53
by ewenhay
Thomastearns wrote: ↑29 Nov 2022, 19:09
As it was, and I felt the same way in Hagler v Leonard and GGG v Canelo 1 and 2, it's up to the challenger to take away the belts from the defending champion.
Which belt does Whyte currently hold?
Re: had jermaine franklin winning 8 rounds vs dillian whyte---does any1 disagree ? *
Posted: 04 Dec 2022, 06:10
by Lenny Cravats
It was a bit of a mess to score. Whyte looked finished. I don't think Whyte won, but there was a lot of rounds that were unclear.