BoxRec

Carnera by easy decision or late stoppage. Valuev sucked. Primo was slightly underrated as he had an okay jab and far better movement than Valuev. Certainly, Promo was not match for a Louis or even Baer.

I'd favor Valuev here. Neither is especially skilled, Valuev is tougher and takes a better shot. I think that'd be enough for him to make the difference.

My guess is that Valuev wins on points. He was bigger and and appears to have had more technical skills than Carnera.

I was just watching a clip of Carnera vs Louis and Primo actually had a decent jab. Valvev? Not so much. Louis and Baer were great punchers.