BoxRec

Duran from the Hagler fight vs Martinez from the Chavez fight.

12 rounds, 160lbs.

Who takes it?

Martinez UD

Sergio Martinez by decision and understandably so. He is not going to slug it out with Roberto Duran but box him.

Duran at those weight classes, Jr Middleweight and above, had lots of trouble with slick boxers like Martinez.

Yup. The only version of Martinez that Duran definitely beats at 160 is the one who should have retired after he tore up his knee (post Chavez). Before that more than likely Martinez boxes Duran from the outside and wins a UD