BoxRec

One lost his MW Lineage to Sergio Martinez. The other won it from Martinez.

Of course, in fairness, they fought completely different versions of "Maravilla".

Still, let's take their versions from their fights against Martinez. Do you see Cotto being able to overcome Pavlik's height and reach advantage? Would Pavlik struggle with Cotto's movement?

Pavlik I get the feeling would be too physically strong for Cotto, and would probably stop him later in the fight.

The bad moda focca Pavlik batters the poor and tiny Cotto.

ya it would be a bloody end for cotto

Agree with the above. Pavlik would be too strong, could take Cotto’s punches and fire back with much more. The Martinez who beat Pavlik would have beaten Cotto as well