Page 1 of 1

Surprisingly Tough Victories For All Time Greats In Their Prime

Posted: 21 Jul 2026, 08:22
by keithmoonhangover
They're an all time great, they still win the fight, but it was a lot harder than expected.

I'll start us off with Evander Holyfield's fight with Bert Cooper. Bert was a replacement for a replacement, but still, Holyfield should have dominated him.

What examples can you think of?

Re: Surprisingly Tough Victories For All Time Greats In Their Prime

Posted: 21 Jul 2026, 08:31
by gilgamesh
Holmes with Mike Weaver
Lennox Lewis with Mavrovic
Floyd Mayweather with Castillo (both fights, especially the 1st)

Re: Surprisingly Tough Victories For All Time Greats In Their Prime

Posted: 21 Jul 2026, 12:58
by Expug
There are lots of these for sure.
Pipino Cuevas - Randy Shields comes to mind.

Re: Surprisingly Tough Victories For All Time Greats In Their Prime

Posted: 21 Jul 2026, 21:02
by Ambling Alp II
Yeah, there are a ton of the. A couple off of the top of my head:

Louis-Farr
Duran-Lampkin

Re: Surprisingly Tough Victories For All Time Greats In Their Prime

Posted: 21 Jul 2026, 22:10
by gilgamesh
Andre Ward had a pretty tough go of it with Sakio Bika. He clearly won don't get me wrong, but it was one of his tougher fights at 168.

Re: Surprisingly Tough Victories For All Time Greats In Their Prime

Posted: 21 Jul 2026, 23:30
by gilgamesh
Michael Spinks had a particularly tough go of it with Eddie Davis

Re: Surprisingly Tough Victories For All Time Greats In Their Prime

Posted: 22 Jul 2026, 07:23
by Controversial
I done a similar thread very recently

viewtopic.php?t=271322

Re: Surprisingly Tough Victories For All Time Greats In Their Prime

Posted: 22 Jul 2026, 11:37
by gilgamesh
Controversial wrote: 22 Jul 2026, 07:23 I done a similar thread very recently

viewtopic.php?t=271322
I remembered that one. I'll combine the 2 if you want. It's basically the same subject.

Re: Surprisingly Tough Victories For All Time Greats In Their Prime

Posted: 24 Jul 2026, 17:47
by Caractacus
-1939-