Page 1 of 1

Scorecard Question

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 05:11
by Max Molyneux
Has their ever been any other fights scored 119 - 105 except for Calzaghe Vs Lacy?

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 05:46
by Freiheit
Most likely, allthough I cant remember them.

Most lopsided card I have seen was in Vic Dachinyan vs Alejandro Montiel: 100-83 | 100-84 | 100-88

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 05:52
by Max Molyneux
Roy Jones apparently has 120 - 106 on two of his fights.

http://www.boxrec.com/boxer_display.php?boxer_id=001758

Too bad Joe got the point deduction otherwise he would of had a 15 points gap instead of 14 like Jones.

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 05:56
by knockout
Wlad v Byrd 1 was very wide on the scorecards.... 120-106 on one of them i think

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 09:48
by Andy Mac
I know Leonard / Terry Norris was a complete shutout and i think one of them was 120 - 106

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 11:05
by MightyWarrior
Tex Cobb lost all 15 rounds to Larry Holmes back in the 80's - 150-135.

One judge in Duran/Leonard 1 scored something like 10 rounds even! :o

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 11:14
by Haighy
Andrew "Six Heads" Lewis once beat Teddy Reid 120-102, 120-103, 119-105 for some sort of north american title back in 98.

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 13:59
by stujones
MightyWarrior wrote:Tex Cobb lost all 15 rounds to Larry Holmes back in the 80's - 150-135.

One judge in Duran/Leonard 1 scored something like 10 rounds even! :o
Yes, wasn't it 147-147. I recall team Duran raising his man when the MC said "Duran 147" - as he'd already given the fight by the first judge.

When the MC said "Leonard 147" - they soon put Duran back down.

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 14:03
by jonny
MightyWarrior wrote:Tex Cobb lost all 15 rounds to Larry Holmes back in the 80's - 150-135.

One judge in Duran/Leonard 1 scored something like 10 rounds even! :o
I take it that judge never worked another title fight. Ten rounds even, thats bad

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 14:22
by Freiheit
It was Angelo Poletti that scored the fight 148-147 (Duran won UD) Poletti's championship record: http://www.boxrec.com/officials.php?official_id=2553

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 14:27
by stujones
Freiheit wrote:It was Angelo Poletti that scored the fight 148-147 (Duran won UD) Poletti's championship record: http://www.boxrec.com/officials.php?official_id=2553
Was originally announced as a MD though.

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 14:54
by hitman_hatton1
i've recently been watching oscar de la hoya's career on dvd.

in one of his early fights he beat a guy on pts over 8 rds called mike grable. he wins 80-62, 80-63 and 80-64. :lol:

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 15:23
by mattyp151
Mayweather was beating Corrales 90-79, 90-78, 89-79 after 9. He put Corrales down in the 10th twice, which if the fight continued, it at least would've been 100-86, 100-85, 99-86....14, 15, and 13 with 2 rounds to go. Floyd takes those last two 10-9, you're looking 120-104, 120-103, 119-104...I think, my math sucks.

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 16:15
by Old bones Ian
Couple of strange ones for you from Jeff Fenech fights, when he fought Satoshi Shingaki he won by KO in 9, the scores at the time of the stoppage were 80-72 by 2 of the judges and an unbeliveable 80-80 by the 3rd , who just happened to have the same name as Shingaki's trainer, surely it couldn't be the same person??

http://www.boxrec.com/boxer_display.php?boxer_id=002941

And Jeff Fenech beat Tony Miller by the score 120-101 , thats pretty one-sided

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 16:31
by stujones
Thats got to be a typo? Surely.

I asked this question before, but did the WBU ever instigate the 20 point round system they were discussing.

I'm sure they did breifly, I couldn't really see the reasoning though.

Posted: 05 Jun 2006, 16:48
by mattyp151
stujones wrote:Thats got to be a typo? Surely.

I asked this question before, but did the WBU ever instigate the 20 point round system they were discussing.

I'm sure they did breifly, I couldn't really see the reasoning though.
20-19 would represent a closer round than 10-9. A clear round won without deduction or point lost would probably be 20-18, where as it's 10-9 in 10 point must. It's basically the same as a half point system with easier math.

Posted: 17 Jun 2006, 14:32
by Freiheit
Last night Jaffa Ballagou beat Lawrence Chapman 99-85 on all three cards.

Posted: 17 Jun 2006, 14:40
by Hagler2002
Andy Mac wrote:I know Leonard / Terry Norris was a complete shutout and i think one of them was 120 - 106
120 - 104

Posted: 17 Jun 2006, 17:28
by Andy Mac
Hagler2k6 wrote:
Andy Mac wrote:I know Leonard / Terry Norris was a complete shutout and i think one of them was 120 - 106
120 - 104
Thankyou very much for the info, I only remember it being highly embarrasing for the so called best fighter ever. bet the REAL SUGAR RAY WAS CHUCKLING..