BoxRec

According to boxrec.com: / According to HOF records:
W L D W L D ND NC
1. Harry Greb 260, 21, 16 / 105, 8, 3, 183
2. Young Stribling 256, 16, 14 / 221, 12, 14, 36, 2
3. Ted Lewis 228, 44, 21 / 173, 30, 65, 65
4. Jack Britton 222, 54, 43 / 104, 27, 21, 190
5. Maxie Rosenbloom 221, 43, 32 / 210, 38, 26, 23 2
6. Sam Langford 197, 46, 46 / 168, 38, 37, 48, 2
7. Johnny Dundee 194, 62, 40 / 210, 56, 31, 31
8. Battling Levinsky 193, 56, 35 / 77, 19, 15, 178
9. Archie Moore 187, 23, 1 / 194, 26, 8, 1
10. Benny Leonard 184, 17, 13 / 85, 5, 1, 121
11. Jack Dillon 177, 22, 30 / 94, 7, 14, 129 1
12. Cocoa Kid 176, 56, 9 / Not in the HOF. Why?
13. Benny Bass 175, 39, 6 / In the HOF, but no fight record?
14. Sugar Ray Robinson 173, 19, 6 / 175, 19, 6 2
15. Tommy Freeman 170, 20, 22 / Not in HOF
16. Alabama Kid 168, 59, 20 / Not in HOF
17. Johnny King 161, 49, 14 / Not in HOF
18. Chalky Wright 160, 43, 17 / 145, 39 16
19. Fritzie Zivic 158, 65, 10 / 159, 64, 9, 1
20. Wesley Ramey 158, 29, 11 / Not in HOF
21. Jackie Berg 157, 26, 9 / 157, 26, 9
22. Tiger Jack Fox 156, 22, 12 / Not in HOF
23. Fred Galiana 155, 22, 12 / Not in HOF
24. three tied for the 24 spot.
A. Henry Armstrong 151, 21, 10 / 151, 21, 9
b. Luis F. Thompson 151, 14, 15 / Not in HOF
c. Paul Junior 151, 24, 14

According to boxrec.com these are the top winners (150+ wins) in the sport of boxing. How accurate these records really are? If boxrec. com records are accurate, how come Cocoa Kid is not in the HOF with 176 wins? He holds wins against Louis Kaplan, Holman Williams, and Chalky wright. One loss and one draw against Charley Burley. Not a bad resume. What are your opinions?

You're missing Willie Pep who should be at number 3.

Seamus wrote:You're missing Willie Pep who should be at number 3.

Thank you.
3. Willie Pep 230, 11,1 same for the HOF 230,11,1

Ok no more top ten discoveries or you'll push Archie out of the top ten and ruin my day.

BoxBuzz wrote:Ok no more top ten discoveries or you'll push Archie out of the top ten and ruin my day.

Here you go: Freddie Miller, 203-31-7.

Also overlooked: George Marsden, 183-94-36.

Don't forget Len Wickwar, the king of them all with 337 wins.

tegenm wrote:Don't forget Len Wickwar, the king of them all with 337 wins.

..... and one of Wickwar's opponents: Billy Bird, 237-71-20. Or George Rose, 192-37-4.

The Brits to a lot of fightin....

Damn it stop finding people or I have to make a new list. Thank you. The original question still stands. How accurate are these records here in boxrec?

pundit wrote:

tegenm wrote:Don't forget Len Wickwar, the king of them all with 337 wins.

..... and one of Wickwar's opponents: Billy Bird, 237-71-20. Or George Rose, 192-37-4.

The Brits to a lot of fightin....

blows my mind, god I wish the fight game still had fellows like these.