BoxRec

1. (1.) Ricky Hatton
2. (2.) Joe Calzaghe
3. (3.) Clinton Woods
4. (4.) Junior Witter
5. (5.) Scott Harrison
6. (6.) Alex Arthur
7. (7.) Enzo Maccarinelli
8. (8.) David Haye
9. (9.) Howard Eastman
10. (10.) Nicky Cook

11. (11.) Damaen Kelly
12. (12.) Wayne McCullough
13. (13.) Carl Froch
14. (14.) Michael Hunter
15. (15.) Ted Bami
16. (16.) Matt Skelton
17. (17.) Jamie Moore
18. (20.) Brian Magee
19. (18.) Robin Reid
20. (19.) Esham Pickering

21. (21.) Graham Earl
22. (22.) Audley Harrison
23. (23.) Scott Dann
24. (24.) Ricky Burns
25. (25.) Kevin Anderson
26. (26.) Danny Williams
27. (27.) Carl Johanneson
28. (NE.) Barry Morrison
29. (28.) Wayne Alexander
30. (29.) Jonathan Thaxton

Out - (30.) Mark Hobson

Again, any comments, criticisms or Top 30 lists would be very welcome.

Isn't Damaen Kelly now retired mate?

Plus i would have Barry Morrison above Audley, Morrison won the British title. Audley has done nothing of note recently other than beat up bloater Williams off the back of two high profile losses and a facile blow out of a US journeyman. And probably knock Robin Reid down a bit at least lower than Kevin Anderson anyway. Just my opinion though Horse

Wayne McCullough? I knew there was talk of a comeback, but should he not have a fight first before getting on a list?

here is my top 10, what about you guys...

1. calzaghe
2. hatton
3. witter
4. woods
5. froch
6. haye
7. eastman
8. moore
9. cook
10. thaxton

No Alex Arthur Rhino?. I still have Scott Harrison officially ranked, if he is exluded then I would put Maccarinelli in at 10.

Joe Calzaghe
Ricky Hatton
Clinton Woods
Scott Harrison
Junior Witter
Nicky Cook
Howard Eastman.
Alex Arthur
Carl Froch
David Haye

i actually have arthur at 11 in mine, something not right about him in my eyes, when he is put under pressure he goes into his shell a bit. i suppose im calling him a 'bully' fighter, but hey, he could still perhaps do it at world level, as could a few others too. my heart puts thaxton in the top 10, just so so pleased to see him achieve something decent in the game when he won that title, but i was gutted lee meager lost the title. confusing i know but it makes sense in my head.

Where does Horse get these p4p rankings from?

rhino222 wrote:i actually have arthur at 11 in mine, something not right about him in my eyes, when he is put under pressure he goes into his shell a bit. i suppose im calling him a 'bully' fighter

I see your point Rhino but isn't the p4p list based on achievements rather than perceptions of weaknesses etc? Not being picky just wondering because Arthur has had a decent run and good reign of the Euro title post Gomez. I think i would nudge him into the top ten if i could be arsed to create one

steve689 wrote:Isn't Damaen Kelly now retired mate?

Kelly announced his retirement, but I am going to wait a while.

steve689 wrote:Plus i would have Barry Morrison above Audley, Morrison won the British title. Audley has done nothing of note recently other than beat up bloater Williams off the back of two high profile losses and a facile blow out of a US journeyman.:

Williams was ranked higher than Daws in my ranking, so Harrison climbed higher after his win than Morrison did.

steve689 wrote: And probably knock Robin Reid down a bit at least lower than Kevin Anderson anyway. Just my opinion though Horse

I don't knock people down unless they lose, so Anderson will have to win a few to overtake Reid.

m1kee50 wrote:Wayne McCullough? I knew there was talk of a comeback, but should he not have a fight first before getting on a list?

I never took him off my list, and as he intends to continue I am going to keep him on there.

[quote="Horse"][quote="m1kee50"]Wayne McCullough? I knew there was talk of a comeback, but should he not have a fight first before getting on a list?[/quote]

I never took him off my list, and as he intends to continue I am going to keep him on there.[/quote]

Fair enough, but i myself would have removed him due to inactivity. I notice you dont have peter oboh for example,is that due to injury or you do not feel he is good enough?

Max Molyneux wrote:Where does Horse get these p4p rankings from?

I make them up.

m1kee50 wrote:

Horse wrote:

m1kee50 wrote:Wayne McCullough? I knew there was talk of a comeback, but should he not have a fight first before getting on a list?

I never took him off my list, and as he intends to continue I am going to keep him on there.

Fair enough, but i myself would have removed him due to inactivity. I notice you dont have peter oboh for example,is that due to injury or you do not feel he is good enough?

Peter Oboh is good enough, but as he has been even more inactive and fought at a lower level than McCullough, I have not included him.