Page 1 of 1

Is George Carpentier the greatest French boxer of all-time?

Posted: 14 Jan 2008, 01:28
by elmersalsa
Was he the greatest French boxer of all-time? France is a country that had a couple of great champions

Posted: 14 Jan 2008, 01:48
by dagosd2000
I just got finished watching the movie"La Vie En Rose" Great film. Anyway,I've got to pick Marcel Cerdan. The "Orchid Man's" chin was a little suspect. Cerdan had a great won/loss record though his competition was mostly in Europe. There is a little home movie footage of his fight with LaMotta. You can see Cerdan's right arm dangling down. Whether that was a result of a knock down or a "hip roll" you can see that his arm was injured.

Posted: 14 Jan 2008, 06:46
by dr_devious
Marcel Cerdan is France's greatest boxer

Posted: 14 Jan 2008, 10:21
by klompton
Marcel Thil.
prime vs prime he beats Cerdan

Posted: 14 Jan 2008, 12:51
by Arbachakov
Bouttier was better than Thil imo.Albeit slightly.

Excellent stylist.

Posted: 14 Jan 2008, 20:58
by ringsider
France....... its best fighter? :roll:

What is that some kind of joke? :lol: :lol: :lol:

Posted: 14 Jan 2008, 21:47
by BoxBuzz
Fabrice Tiozzo comes to mind. ringsider...back me up on this.

film

Posted: 15 Jan 2008, 20:21
by robert.snell1
dagosd2000 wrote:I just got finished watching the movie"La Vie En Rose" Great film. Anyway,I've got to pick Marcel Cerdan. The "Orchid Man's" chin was a little suspect. Cerdan had a great won/loss record though his competition was mostly in Europe. There is a little home movie footage of his fight with LaMotta. You can see Cerdan's right arm dangling down. Whether that was a result of a knock down or a "hip roll" you can see that his arm was injured.
what is this film ? forgive my ignorance

Re: film

Posted: 15 Jan 2008, 21:05
by dagosd2000
robert.snell1 wrote:
dagosd2000 wrote:I just got finished watching the movie"La Vie En Rose" Great film. Anyway,I've got to pick Marcel Cerdan. The "Orchid Man's" chin was a little suspect. Cerdan had a great won/loss record though his competition was mostly in Europe. There is a little home movie footage of his fight with LaMotta. You can see Cerdan's right arm dangling down. Whether that was a result of a knock down or a "hip roll" you can see that his arm was injured.
what is this film ? forgive my ignorance
La Vie En Rose is the story of Edith Piaf. A street urchin who sang in the streets of Paris,was discovered by the owner of a night club,made her debut,and rose to be an international star. The reason I mentioned the movie in the post was because of her torrid affair with Marcel Cerdan. Piaf persuaded Cerdan to return early yo New York(where Piaf was performing)to begin his training for his rematch with LaMotta. Cerdan's plane crashed in the Azores. His sudden loss devasted her. A brilliant film produced in France with English subtitles.

Posted: 16 Jan 2008, 10:44
by elmersalsa
I gotta say that Georges Carpentier, by looking at his record, was the greatest of the French. :TU: :TU: :TU: