BoxRec

Sorry bout the delay!

1 Calzaghe
2 Haye
3 Hatton
4 Witter
5 Woods
6 Maccaranelli
7 Arthur
8 Froch
9 Khan
10 Rees
11 Lynes
12 Moore
13 Cook
14 Jennings
15 Hunter
16 Lee
17 Duddy
17 Mitchell
19 Elcock
20 Matthews

Think Munroe should be in their after his European title win

Marc.C wrote:Think Munroe should be in their after his European title win

After the deadline.

being kind on arthur there

herearemy british/celtic p4p's without emersons rose tinted testicles......

1. calzaghe - definately numberone, no problem with that

2. haye - potentially the number one, question marks over chin

3. froch - another potential number one, good chin, big heart

4. hatton - fading away

5. witter - can he come again, im not sure

6. cook - great attributes,schooled arthur

7. woods - old guard, on waydown

8. moore - good potential for an old fella !!, promising but needs a big fight soon

9. maccarinelli - can he come again ?? chin question marks

10. barker - potential superstar, but chin question marks

11. arthur - exposed as a pretend world champion,brit/euro class at best

12. lynes - great little technician,would be a good re match with witter

13. rhodes - second coming,indian summer etc....potentially?

14. khan - foundout and exposed,offensively world class,defensively area class !!

15. duddy - slugger, too chancy to hit the big time

16. jennings - excellent fella, but lack of career building opportunities

17. mitchell - not sure how good he could be, decent power, questionable defence, decent heart

18. rees - over achieved

19. elcock - on the way down, over achieved

20. lee

rhino222 ........ Spot on

DuranTheGreat wrote:rhino222 ........ Spot on

far from it Froch above Hatton is laughable and i also think Munroe should be in the top 20

munroe is a good call actually, but from bin man to rhinos top 20 is a big leap, so i will recycle your thoughts for the time being..

as for froch above hatton, well, i certainly think so, hatton has not looked decent since beating kostya, and i challenge anyone to prove otherwise (and dont mention his KO of the shop worn castillo !!)

froch is an unknown quantity, he could easily go all the way. if hatton was a piece of food in asda, it would say 'oops' on his label

past his sell by date !!! SO GET USED TO IT. HE IS FINISHED IM AFRAID, I EXPECT MALLIGNAGGI TO BEAT HIM ON POINTS OR LATE STOPPAGE, HATTON IS JUST TOO EASY TO NAIL.

rhino222 wrote:munroe is a good call actually, but from bin man to rhinos top 20 is a big leap, so i will recycle your thoughts for the time being..

as for froch above hatton, well, i certainly think so, hatton has not looked decent since beating kostya, and i challenge anyone to prove otherwise (and dont mention his KO of the shop worn castillo !!)

froch is an unknown quantity, he could easily go all the way. if hatton was a piece of food in asda, it would say 'oops' on his label

past his sell by date !!! SO GET USED TO IT. HE IS FINISHED IM AFRAID, I EXPECT MALLIGNAGGI TO BEAT HIM ON POINTS OR LATE STOPPAGE, HATTON IS JUST TOO EASY TO NAIL.

You said it there Froch is an unknown quantity, so how can he be above a 2 weight world champion who fought the best P4P out there, I think Froch is a very good fighter with lots of ability but to put him above Hatton is a bit premature, scenario- Hatton stops Mallignaggi and Frochs unconvincing against Pascal then how does your ratings stand ??