BoxRec

mine, probably has to be the first lewis-holyfield.

roy jones at the olympics is another.

has anyone on here seen the second schmeling-sharkey? how bad a decision was it? thanks!

Emmauel Augustus v Burton
Fenech v Nelson 1
Hearns v Leonard 2

Whitaker v Chavez
Tiberi v Toney
Coetzee v Snipes

Three horrible decisions.

Fenech Nelson has to be one of the worst iv seen altho David Barnes Jimmy Vincent was bad on a smaller scale.

JOSE MANTEQUILLA NAPOLES- ARMANDO MUÑIZ I.

Emile Griffith vs Jorge Fernandez I
Flash Elorde vs Vicente Derado
Ben Villaflor vs Victor Echegaray
Bob Foster vs Jorge Ahumada





msc

fenech - nelson 1 would be up there i wait to see how this next 'fight' between them will happen

i just woke up, so my mind is pretty fuzzy 8)
i dont know if its an all time worst decision but i score Hagler v. Leonard last nite 6 rounds hagler 4 rounds leonard with 2 even.....

Hagler-Leonard

Casamayor-Santa Cruz

Martin Sosa Cameron wrote:Emile Griffith vs Jorge Fernandez I
Flash Elorde vs Vicente Derado
Ben Villaflor vs Victor Echegaray
Bob Foster vs Jorge Ahumada





msc

The Foster-Ahumada decision was terrible.

Ahumada won the light heavyweight title and was robbed because he was not the home country fighter.

A pathetic and obvious example of crooked officiating.

That decision was a shyness for boxing; and the first of Griffith vs Fernandez, a scandal...





msc

bjermaine wrote:mine, probably has to be the first lewis-holyfield.

roy jones at the olympics is another.

has anyone on here seen the second schmeling-sharkey? how bad a decision was it? thanks!

Lewis - Holyfield 1 is mine too. Holy was never in serious danger of getting KO'ed, but I would have given him two rounds TOPS.

Martin Sosa Cameron wrote:That decision was a shyness for boxing; and the first of Griffith vs Fernandez, a scandal...

msc

Martin,

Can you tell me more about the Jorge Fernandez-Emile Griffith fights?

I never saw those.

granberry wrote:

Martin Sosa Cameron wrote:Emile Griffith vs Jorge Fernandez I
Flash Elorde vs Vicente Derado
Ben Villaflor vs Victor Echegaray
Bob Foster vs Jorge Ahumada





msc

The Foster-Ahumada decision was terrible.

Ahumada won the light heavyweight title and was robbed because he was not the home country fighter.

A pathetic and obvious example of crooked officiating.

i never saw the foster fight but he himself has said in numerous interviews that he lost that fight. i've seen scores of some journalists who scored the fight 13-2 for ahumada. ahumada never became champ either. it makes me sick.

Jaybee From The Castle wrote:

bjermaine wrote:mine, probably has to be the first lewis-holyfield.

roy jones at the olympics is another.

has anyone on here seen the second schmeling-sharkey? how bad a decision was it? thanks!

Lewis - Holyfield 1 is mine too. Holy was never in serious danger of getting KO'ed, but I would have given him two rounds TOPS.

exactly. i had the fight 10-2, lennox.

Shulz-Foreman

Byrd-Oquendo

Reid v Ottke.

Whitaker v Ramirez 1

Antuofermo -Minter I.
Hatcher-Sacco I
Ottke-Brewer, Reid

Lewis-Holyfield I was bad but I wouldn't say it's the worst. Many of the rounds were dull with Lewis not landing much and Holyfield not doing anything except going forward. Especially considering it was scored a draw and not a Holyfield victory. I had it 8-4 Lennox

Some of the worst:

Burton-Augustus
Diamond-Huerta
Patterson-Maxim
Ali-Norton III (I can't understand those who say it was close)

banjo wrote:Whitaker v Ramirez 1

Often overlooked, as a result of the more high-profile Whitaker-Chavez decision of '93. Good call, Banj. Whitaker won hands fucken down.

Goodnight, Irene wrote:

banjo wrote:Whitaker v Ramirez 1

Often overlooked, as a result of the more high-profile Whitaker-Chavez decision of '93. Good call, Banj. Whitaker won hands fucken down.

I just can't understand what those judges saw to score it for Ramirez. It's definitely the worst decision that I have seen although there's probably worse out there.

granberry wrote:

Martin Sosa Cameron wrote:That decision was a shyness for boxing; and the first of Griffith vs Fernandez, a scandal...

msc

Martin,

Can you tell me more about the Jorge Fernandez-Emile Griffith fights?

I never saw those.

Jorge Fernandez was one of the greatest Argentinian fighters of all time; see his fabulous record in http://www.boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?hu ... &cat=boxer

In his first fight against Emile Griffith, June 3, 1960, N.Y.C., the crowd believed Fernandez was with ampleness the winner, but when they know the decision, absolutely unjust (referee: Petey Della 4-5 [Griffith], judge: Jack Gordon 4-5 [Griffith], judge: Joe Agnello 6-4 [Fernandez]), the attendance exploded protesting, and during more than 15 minutes, throwed a lot of "projectiles" to the ring: chairs, bottles, tin cans, stones and others, until the police stopped the hullaballo, but the decision wasn't changed



Another worst decision:

Masasi Kudo vs Manuel Gonzalez


msc