BoxRec

1. (1.) Joe Calzaghe
2. (2.) Ricky Hatton
3. (3.) David Haye
4. (4.) Junior Witter
5. (5.) Clinton Woods
6. (6.) Alex Arthur
7. (7.) Carl Froch
8. (8.) Enzo Maccarinelli
9. (9.) Jamie Moore
10. (10.) Rendall Munroe

11. (11.) Amir Khan
12. (12.) Kevin Mitchell
13. (13.) John Duddy
14. (14.) Wayne Elcock
15. (15.) Bernard Dunne
16. (17.) Nicky Cook
17. (18.) Gavin Rees
18. (19.) Matt Skelton
19. (20.) Ian Napa
20. (21.) Colin Lynes

21. (22.) David Barnes
22. (23.) Dean Francis
23. (24.) Danny Williams
24. (25.) Kevin McIntyre
25. (26.) Bradley Pryce
26. (NE.) Darren Barker
27. (27.) Paul Appleby
28. (28.) Jonathan Thaxton
29. (29.) Carl Johanneson
30. (30.) Michael Jennings

Out - (16.) Scott Harrison

Any comments, criticisms or P4P lists are very welcome.

Yeh, Bernard Dunne isn't British and while officially, Duddy is... I don't think he'd be happy in that list either.

NaFianna wrote:Yeh, Bernard Dunne isn't British and while officially, Duddy is... I don't think he'd be happy in that list either.

i agree

so with this being a BRITISH forum id rather them names were never mentioned again

over to the current scene please

NaFianna wrote:Yeh, Bernard Dunne isn't British and while officially, Duddy is... I don't think he'd be happy in that list either.

I said the exact same thing last month and was told that Irish boxers were allowed I then asked would he rename it to british and Irish and he said he wouldnt.
I think you should do one or the other tbh horse.

metropol wrote:

NaFianna wrote:Yeh, Bernard Dunne isn't British and while officially, Duddy is... I don't think he'd be happy in that list either.

I said the exact same thing last month and was told that Irish boxers were allowed I then asked would he rename it to british and Irish and he said he wouldnt.
I think you should do one or the other tbh horse.

Absolutely... listen... you're either British or your not. Dunne is not British- he can't be on the list!

what about martin rogan he's done well over the last 6 months

Horse wrote:Any comments, criticisms or P4P lists are very welcome.

About time Scott Harrison was left off.

Just wondering if you included Barker based on the fact that you couldn't really change the list in August so felt obliged to make one change.

Barker top 15. put Enzo 6th ahead of Arthur and Froch as he's beaten higher level of opposition(excluding Bobby Gunn of course)

NaFianna wrote:Yeh, Bernard Dunne isn't British and while officially, Duddy is... I don't think he'd be happy in that list either.

Seeing as Duddy does not hold British citizenship(and never has done) and was born outside Britain I think you can resoundingly say he is not British. The only place which officially' reports him as British is this site.

I have to agree with earlier comments, either it's a British and Irish list or just British and should be named accordingly.

we cant have British and Irish on an British Forum - they should just be deleted

You telling me John Murray is NOT among the 30 best fighters in Britain? Suppose he is only an unbeaten British champion who is consistently calling out Khan and who put in a career best shift in his last fight.

TheGoods wrote:You telling me John Murray is NOT among the 30 best fighters in Britain? Suppose he is only an unbeaten British champion who is consistently calling out Khan and who put in a career best shift in his last fight.

were would put Murray, i think has as much right as mcintye & appleby, but Horse does like a bit of scottish bias

personally id ditch mcintyre and put murray in at 30

The goods,
Same goes for Rhodes.
You telling me he's not a top 30 fighter ?

NaFianna wrote:Yeh, Bernard Dunne isn't British and while officially, Duddy is... I don't think he'd be happy in that list either.

Duddy is placed quite highly, so maybe he would be happy with it.

sweetscience wrote:i agree

so with this being a BRITISH forum id rather them names were never mentioned again

over to the current scene please

Good point.

Elcock at 14 and no Murray or Rhodes? Ye Gods...

metropol wrote:I said the exact same thing last month and was told that Irish boxers were allowed I then asked would he rename it to british and Irish and he said he wouldnt.
I think you should do one or the other tbh horse.

I think there is a third way.

NaFianna wrote:Absolutely... listen... you're either British or your not. Dunne is not British- he can't be on the list!

Yet he is.

horse dont be arsey about it just be reasonable and take him off . The person who was saying get off the forum , I dont know whether your joking or not, I think your joking, but if your serious take a look at the amot of threads that are not about british

1southpaw wrote:what about martin rogan he's done well over the last 6 months

Rogan has a lot more to prove before he gets a place in the top 30. So far I don't think he has beaten a top 10 ranked British heavyweight.

DG. wrote:About time Scott Harrison was left off.

Probably, I still hope he comes back though.

metropol wrote:horse dont be arsey about it just be reasonable and take him off . The person who was saying get off the forum , I dont know whether your joking or not, I think your joking, but if your serious take a look at the amot of threads that are not about british

Sure if he's gonna put Irish in the top Brit fighters, he might as well put Mexicans and Americans in there too- you might be able to fill a top 50 or top 100 that way ;)

NaFianna wrote:

metropol wrote:horse dont be arsey about it just be reasonable and take him off . The person who was saying get off the forum , I dont know whether your joking or not, I think your joking, but if your serious take a look at the amot of threads that are not about british

Sure if he's gonna put Irish in the top Brit fighters, he might as well put Mexicans and Americans in there too- you might be able to fill a top 50 or top 100 that way ;)

Or if he kept it at top 30 there might not be many brits in it at all.

stujones wrote:Just wondering if you included Barker based on the fact that you couldn't really change the list in August so felt obliged to make one change.

I took Scott Harrison out this month, so that would have been a change.

Barker entered the list because I think he is a better choice than the alternatives. The fact that he boxed this month, and can enter higher than position No. 30, is just a bonus.

Horse wrote:

metropol wrote:I said the exact same thing last month and was told that Irish boxers were allowed I then asked would he rename it to british and Irish and he said he wouldnt.
I think you should do one or the other tbh horse.

I think there is a third way.

NaFianna wrote:Absolutely... listen... you're either British or your not. Dunne is not British- he can't be on the list!

Yet he is.

Want to explain this third way ?