BoxRec

Updated the list for this quarter - comments!?!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Vinta ... d_rankings

I would lee and mccloskey swap places. I would put james moore further down other than that I cant disagree to much.

metropol wrote:I would lee and mccloskey swap places. I would put james moore further down other than that I cant disagree to much.

spots 2,3 and 4 are all up for debate.

Moore has already dropped from #6 - as Murray hasnt fought in ages and hasnt fought anyone of note then I cant drop him further imo

do you think there should be any new entries?

Darren Corbett

Seriously, I would bump Rogie up a few places after some high profile wins. And sneak Declan Timlin in as well

current scene please mods

steve689 wrote:Seriously, I would bump Rogie up a few places after some high profile wins. And sneak Declan Timlin in as well

Rogie has just jumped up from #15 this quarter. If he beat say Skelton or someone like that then he'd have another big jump imo

Timlin - you serious?

steve689 wrote:Darren Corbett

I'd like to see him fight Jim Rock for the Irish Cruiserweight title

Think Rock is coming back mate as a Middleweight. As for Timlin, no a bit of a joke one there, I saw Timlin fight a Romanian at the National Stadium and it was DIRE. They should stick him in with Belshaw and let them whale away at each other.

Duddy is defintely no. 1, id put Dunne no. 2 and Lee no. 4

sligobhoy67 wrote:

metropol wrote:I would lee and mccloskey swap places. I would put james moore further down other than that I cant disagree to much.

spots 2,3 and 4 are all up for debate.

Moore has already dropped from #6 - as Murray hasnt fought in ages and hasnt fought anyone of note then I cant drop him further imo

do you think there should be any new entries?

Cant think of anyone off hand . Have you got any that may break through?

metropol wrote:

sligobhoy67 wrote:

metropol wrote:I would lee and mccloskey swap places. I would put james moore further down other than that I cant disagree to much.

spots 2,3 and 4 are all up for debate.

Moore has already dropped from #6 - as Murray hasnt fought in ages and hasnt fought anyone of note then I cant drop him further imo

do you think there should be any new entries?

Cant think of anyone off hand . Have you got any that may break through?

Maybe maybe the Cork fella called O'Sullivan, Gary I think, I havent seen him but heard that he is handy enough.

I think Brian magee is no 3. with Duddy 2 and Dunne 1.

Why isn't Colin Kenna included?

Dirk Kelly wrote:Why isn't Colin Kenna included?

I'm guessing from your location you're a possible friend/fan/family of Kenna but the simple truth is because he doesn't deserve to be there.
He's not one of Ireland's top 20 boxers. He's lost 7 of his last 8, is starting to look pretty shot and even in his better days he drew with Paul King.
He hasn't won a fight in almost 2 years either.

sligobhoy67 wrote:Maybe maybe the Cork fella called O'Sullivan, Gary I think, I havent seen him but heard that he is handy enough.

Not quite done enough to get in yet but watch this space, O'Sullivan could be very good. Seen him fight live a couple of times now and he didn't disappoint. Came in in great shape with good support and threw straight accurate bombs, showing real power. He moved Tye Williams around the ring like a ragdoll and stopped Peter Dunne which isn't too easy. Manager Paschal Collins told me he is due out again soon and keep an eye out for a profile in the near future on BBN

BigEars wrote:

Dirk Kelly wrote:Why isn't Colin Kenna included?

I'm guessing from your location you're a possible friend/fan/family of Kenna but the simple truth is because he doesn't deserve to be there.
He's not one of Ireland's top 20 boxers. He's lost 7 of his last 8, is starting to look pretty shot and even in his better days he drew with Paul King.
He hasn't won a fight in almost 2 years either.

Points taken, but surely if Rock, Sinclair and to a lesser extent Gomez is included then he merits an inclusion?

Can't believe its been almost two years since the Keith Long hug fest!

Dirk Kelly wrote:

BigEars wrote:

Dirk Kelly wrote:Why isn't Colin Kenna included?

I'm guessing from your location you're a possible friend/fan/family of Kenna but the simple truth is because he doesn't deserve to be there.
He's not one of Ireland's top 20 boxers. He's lost 7 of his last 8, is starting to look pretty shot and even in his better days he drew with Paul King.
He hasn't won a fight in almost 2 years either.

Points taken, but surely if Rock, Sinclair and to a lesser extent Gomez is included then he merits an inclusion?

Can't believe its been almost two years since the Keith Long hug fest!

Nope they've all done more than him in recent times.
Sorry but true.

brian13 wrote:Duddy is defintely no. 1, id put Dunne no. 2 and Lee no. 4

Im not sure that dunne could be put at number 2 . sure hes an ex ebu champ but he hasnt fought anyone of note really. Would you not say mcloskey has bettern claim to that spot?

Sligo, I think I have a few of Gary "Spike" O'Sullivans fights here if you want a look at them just drop me a PM mate.

Keep up the good work on the P4P stats and the wiki boxers listings.

Gareth wrote:Sligo, I think I have a few of Gary "Spike" O'Sullivans fights here if you want a look at them just drop me a PM mate.

Keep up the good work on the P4P stats and the wiki boxers listings.

Cheers mate - I'll drop ya a PM.

O'Sullivan in next on my list to do - after I create Clinton MacKenzie and tidy up Terry Marsh.

sligobhoy67 wrote: O'Sullivan in next on my list to do - after I create Clinton MacKenzie and tidy up Terry Marsh.

Make sure you spell his name Clinton McKenzie and not MacKenzie!!

i lads can ye pm me any pics bvids etc on spike

check this out

www.bebo.com/boxerspike

an pics be appriciated

sorry for the off topic

I think Rogan has a good shout for a top 3 spot after his last two wins especially.....