Page 1 of 2
British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 28 Feb 2009, 21:00
by Horse
1. (1.) Joe Calzaghe
2. (2.) Ricky Hatton
3. (3.) David Haye
4. (4.) Carl Froch
5. (6.) Clinton Woods
6. (5.) Junior Witter
7. (7.) Nicky Cook
8. (8.) Enzo Maccarinelli
9. (10.) Rendall Munroe
10. (9.) Jamie Moore
11. (11.) Alex Arthur
12. (12.) Ian Napa
13. (15.) John Duddy (Irish)
14. (14.) Kevin Mitchell
15. (17.) Amir Khan
16. (18.) Bernard Dunne (Irish)
17. (19.) Wayne Elcock
18. (NE.) Martin Rogan (Irish)
19. (20.) Kell Brook
20. (13.) Matt Skelton
21. (16.) Jonathan Thaxton
22. (21.) Gavin Rees
23. (22.) Ryan Rhodes
24. (23.) Paul Appleby
25. (24.) Darren Barker
26. (25.) John Murray
27. (26.) Paul McCloskey
28. (27.) Brian Magee
29. (28.) David Barnes
30. (29.) Dean Francis
Out - (30.) Bradley Pryce
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 28 Feb 2009, 21:00
by Horse
Any comments, criticisms or P4P lists are very welcome.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 28 Feb 2009, 21:03
by Deadendgeneration
Just not sure Calzaghe should be included with him having officially retired though I guess we can wait and see if he stays that way but I think he will.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 28 Feb 2009, 21:09
by earsjohn
Deadendgeneration wrote:Just not sure Calzaghe should be included with him having officially retired though I guess we can wait and see if he stays that way but I think he will.
Calzaghe has a good 2 years left if Scott Harrison and Wayne McCullogh are anything to go by (according to this list in recent times!!! ;;-) )
Would probably have Skelton and Thaxton below Darren Barker, but other than that the list seems good to me.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 28 Feb 2009, 21:16
by brian13
Enzo Macc is ahead of Cook
Arthur should one or two places lower
Joe Calzaghe is retired
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 01 Mar 2009, 09:02
by craigjenkins05
murray should be above khan hes fought better people than khan, maybe my opinion will change depending on the barrera fight
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 01 Mar 2009, 13:12
by alexpaterson
not much 2 argue with there
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 01 Mar 2009, 19:38
by Horse
Deadendgeneration wrote:Just not sure Calzaghe should be included with him having officially retired though I guess we can wait and see if he stays that way but I think he will.
I prefer to wait a while after a retirement, if the fighter has recently been active, before removing them from the list.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 01 Mar 2009, 19:44
by Horse
earsjohn wrote:Calzaghe has a good 2 years left if Scott Harrison and Wayne McCullogh are anything to go by (according to this list in recent times!!! ;;-) )
The difference is that they never retired. I wouldn't keep a retired fighter in the list that long.
earsjohn wrote:Would probably have Skelton and Thaxton below Darren Barker, but other than that the list seems good to me.
I would like to wait until Barker beats a better standard of opposition before moving him up to that sort of level. He hasn't really beaten anyone yet.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 01 Mar 2009, 23:11
by metropol
Horse wrote:earsjohn wrote:Calzaghe has a good 2 years left if Scott Harrison and Wayne McCullogh are anything to go by (according to this list in recent times!!! ;;-) )
The difference is that they never retired. I wouldn't keep a retired fighter in the list that long.
earsjohn wrote:Would probably have Skelton and Thaxton below Darren Barker, but other than that the list seems good to me.
I would like to wait until Barker beats a better standard of opposition before moving him up to that sort of level. He hasn't really beaten anyone yet.
Joe has retired so he should not be on the list. So why is he ?
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 02 Mar 2009, 01:18
by jeej
Take Joe out. If he does come back, you can put him the next one.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 02 Mar 2009, 14:55
by Horse
brian13 wrote:Enzo Macc is ahead of Cook
Why?
brian13 wrote:Arthur should one or two places lower
I don't think there is much in it, but I think that Arthur is a better fighter than those immediately below him.
brian13 wrote:Joe Calzaghe is retired
So he says.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 02 Mar 2009, 14:59
by Horse
craigjenkins05 wrote:murray should be above khan hes fought better people than khan, maybe my opinion will change depending on the barrera fight
I actually believe that Khan's opposition is much better than Murray's. Which is why Khan is a good number of places higher than Murray on my list.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 02 Mar 2009, 16:43
by craigjenkins05
Horse wrote:craigjenkins05 wrote:murray should be above khan hes fought better people than khan, maybe my opinion will change depending on the barrera fight
I actually believe that Khan's opposition is much better than Murray's. Which is why Khan is a good number of places higher than Murray on my list.
who has khan fought worth talking about why can he go straight to a wbo eliminator why doesnt he have to go down the british, commonwealth or european title route like everyone else just because he has more exposure?
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 02 Mar 2009, 17:27
by Horse
alexpaterson wrote:not much 2 argue with there

Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 02 Mar 2009, 17:32
by Horse
metropol wrote:Joe has retired so he should not be on the list. So why is he ?
His last fight was not long ago and he has also made hints that he may return for the right fight, so I will keep him in until his retirement is more certain.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 04:09
by danfoster
i'd have thought that ryan rhodes should be in there, definitely
done a lot more than mcloskey than appleby for my money but only an opinion
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 04:11
by danfoster
i also think that enzo is very lucky to be as high as number 8 - i just feel that he is a very overrated boxer with few quality wins
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 04:56
by Ted
Is Brian Magee not Irish?
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 05:04
by banjo
Ted wrote:Is Brian Magee not Irish?
Horse will say no because he holds the British title
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 05:08
by Ted
thats weird logic, but rogan has the commonwealth - where does that put him?
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 05:09
by banjo
Ted wrote:thats weird logic, but rogan has the commonwealth - where does that put him?
no idea, I don't know how his mind works

Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 11:55
by metropol
Ted wrote:thats weird logic, but rogan has the commonwealth - where does that put him?
Ssssssshhhhhh, Were keeping him fo sho . I suppose the the amount of tri colors on display may of been a hint to horse.
Ive been over this with the equine one and i think we just had to agree to disagree although various arguments were put forward by different people as to why some on his list were Irish and had not been acknowledged as so .
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 13:00
by chrisfinch
craigjenkins05 wrote:Horse wrote:craigjenkins05 wrote:murray should be above khan hes fought better people than khan, maybe my opinion will change depending on the barrera fight
I actually believe that Khan's opposition is much better than Murray's. Which is why Khan is a good number of places higher than Murray on my list.
who has khan fought worth talking about why can he go straight to a wbo eliminator why doesnt he have to go down the british, commonwealth or european title route like everyone else just because he has more exposure?
Technically he is Commonwealth champion.
He hasn't defended it since Gomez and isn't likely to defend it anytime soon really.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 13:47
by Horse
jeej wrote:Take Joe out. If he does come back, you can put him the next one.
Why rush to take him out?
craigjenkins05 wrote:who has khan fought worth talking about
Who has Murray fought worth talking about?
craigjenkins05 wrote:why can he go straight to a wbo eliminator why doesnt he have to go down the british, commonwealth or european title route like everyone else just because he has more exposure?
Khan can go straight into a WBO eliminator because he has a big fanbase and makes money, Murray would be doing the same thing if he could. A lot of Britain's best boxers don't go down the "traditional" route.
Which British boxers are currently going down the British, Commonwealth and European route? Not many.
chrisfinch wrote:Technically he is Commonwealth champion.
He hasn't defended it since Gomez and isn't likely to defend it anytime soon really.
Also, like chrisfinch says, he has gone down the Commonwealth route, and unlike a lot of Commonwealth champions he has defended it against quite a few British fighters instead of unknown Africans.