Page 1 of 1

Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 07:20
by dbflex
http://www.boxingnewsonline.net/BN08/detail.asp?id=1018

The latest Flex speaks where the likable Liverpudlian talks about his life, career and his domestic rivals. Feedback – positive or negative – appreciated as always, either via comments on the site itself or on here.

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 07:29
by Asterix
I thought he lost to Bob Ajisafe (close) and then beat Darren Stubbs (easily). Crazy stuff.

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 07:43
by jBacca
Good little read. Prefer it when articles are in that format and not long-winded.

Asterix, i called it the same as you (as i think everyone else bar the judges did).

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 07:56
by Dioufy
Asterix wrote:I thought he lost to Bob Ajisafe (close) and then beat Darren Stubbs (easily). Crazy stuff.
:TU:

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 08:03
by Chambers2
I agree with Carl regarding the Stubbs fight, I thought he won the 1st and 3rd rounds. I'm still gobsmacked that the judges managed to add up 3 rounds incorrectly, it's hardly fcuking rocket science :witzend: It must've been a terrible way for Dilks to find out he was out of the tournament and a 'few' grand lighter.

I thought the Ajisafe fight was close and could have gone either way, but I thought Carl was the slightly busier and deserved the nod

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 08:05
by dbflex
The judges didn't add anything up wrong. When the master scorecard was transferred to a cue-card (for the MC to read from) the two names were put the wrong way round. Still unforgivable but more understandable.

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 08:08
by Chambers2
dbflex wrote:The judges didn't add anything up wrong. When the master scorecard was transferred to a cue-card (for the MC to read from) the two names were put the wrong way round. Still unforgivable but more understandable.
Cheers for the clarification, it's still piss poor officiating though

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 08:15
by n1ebf
bet they don't get sacked and thrown out in the street in tar and feathers though like the nobs that they are.

why risk the possibility that might happen, why not just give the master scorecard to the MC.

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 08:39
by stepper
It was farcical, I was watching with a very casual boxing fan who just thought the whole thing was bent and pointless and that we should switch over and watch Celebrity Dinners, damn I love that woman :bow:

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 10:02
by dbflex
Any more comments on the article? I'm not fishing for compliments here; negative comments will also be considered.

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 10:09
by whicker
dbflex wrote:The judges didn't add anything up wrong. When the master scorecard was transferred to a cue-card (for the MC to read from) the two names were put the wrong way round. Still unforgivable but more understandable.
I do feel sorry for Dilks, but it is worse for Stubbs.

He won the fight , OK the verdict was debatable but never the less that IS the nature of boxing. He won the fight on the judges card, that is the final decision.

Because of an error he was denied his "moment of glory" being declared the winner, and was in a very disadvantaged position going into the final as he must have "wound down" a little after he thought he had lost.

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 10:09
by n1ebf
ignore this post
NEBF

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 12:40
by dbflex
Any more comments on the article? I'm not fishing for compliments here; negative comments will also be considered.

Re: Carl Dilks: When they took it away from me I felt sick

Posted: 04 Mar 2009, 16:34
by hitman09
dbflex wrote:The judges didn't add anything up wrong. When the master scorecard was transferred to a cue-card (for the MC to read from) the two names were put the wrong way round. Still unforgivable but more understandable.
They still badly fvcked it up. No way did Dilks lose that one.