Page 1 of 2

Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 11 Mar 2009, 17:16
by Rocky Balboa
I was just reading KO Magazine, September, 1989 edition.

Robinson's resume is quite remarkable. Names on his CV include:

LaMotta, Turpin, Armstrong, Sammy Angott, Fullmer, Olson, Paul Pender, Graziano, Gavilan, Basilio. Not to mention Ray challenged Joey Maxim for the LHW title. Ok, so he was unsucessful, but nonetheless, its still an achievement in itself!

Is Robinson's resume the most impressive in boxing history? I certainly think its right up there with the very best. The list of opponents throughout his career is top-drawer!

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 11 Mar 2009, 17:18
by steve689
Up there indeed....best ever p4p IMHO :TU: :box:

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 11 Mar 2009, 20:46
by Scrap
Im not so sure, as regards how good He was. It was a strange time for knowing what the Bottom Line was. He was without doubt a good fighter.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 03:25
by teddy007
Scrap wrote:Im not so sure, as regards how good He was. It was a strange time for knowing what the Bottom Line was. He was without doubt a good fighter.
"He was without doubt a good fighter" That is an understatement if I ever read/heard one.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 05:03
by Poncey
Based upon his period it has to be. Moore is the only one for me that comes remotely close.

You also forgot Zivic. An often overlooked LW that beat a faded Armstrong, with Robinson in attendance nonetheless (Armstrong was his hero). Also Joey Archer and Giardello deserve a mention on that list.

The Maxim fight was one that Robinson was allegedly winning, but the intolerable heat got the better of him and he had to quit. His physician reported that he almost died in the ring from dehydration. It took him over a week to fully recover. Think he slept for 2 days after that fight.

I'm still on the fence as to who was better' Armstrong or Robinson.

It's a disgrace that his first 5 fights with La Motta aren't available.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 05:06
by Phenomenal-Nutrition
Resume wise he has some very good names, but he didn't face the best of his times, avoided the very best WW/MW of his era in Charles Burley and the black dynamite crew, which were basically all the top black fighters who were excluded from title fights etc. Burley fought far far better opposition than Robinson, but didn't always win. Robinson also didn't face Cerdan the other top WW/MW of his time, but that was no fault of his own as Cerdan died

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 05:10
by Phenomenal-Nutrition
Robinson was lucky he never had to take a dive but he carried allot of fighters under instruction from the MOB. He was supposed to carry Henry Armstrong. Once he accidently scored a KO against someone he was supposed to KO and by all accounts was terrified but the mobster accepted 'these things happen'

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 05:21
by Poncey
Phenomenal-Nutrition wrote:Resume wise he has some very good names, but he didn't face the best of his times, avoided the very best WW/MW of his era in Charles Burley and the black dynamite crew, which were basically all the top black fighters who were excluded from title fights etc. Burley fought far far better opposition than Robinson, but didn't always win. Robinson also didn't face Cerdan the other top WW/MW of his time, but that was no fault of his own as Cerdan died
I disagree about Burley. Purely as only one video exists of him ever fighting so he's just to hard to guage.

Sure, Futch said he was the greatest never to win a championship, so that's a statement to respect. But He wasn't tested at the level of Basilio, De Marco, Zale and Graziano level. So we'll never know. I've always felt we buy in to the mysticism of Burley. He lost to a prime Zivic at a weight he seemed more natural at based upon his record only.

La Motta destroyed Cerdan, so based upon the A beat B beat C theory, it's null and void. For me, Cerdan was an over-protected fighter that was exposed when he fought at the very top.

I strongly disagree Burley fought even better opposition, let alone far, far, better. So we'll respectfully agree to disagree. :TU:

I agree that the 40s, 50s and early 60s are such a hard era to guage because of the Mob involvement from Bunny, et al.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 05:30
by The Law
Even Ali considers Robinson as the greatest pound for pound fighter ever.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FGHhtS7PKGA

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 05:53
by Poncey
The Law wrote:Even Ali considers Robinson as the greatest pound for pound fighter ever.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FGHhtS7PKGA
...and Robinson considered Armstrong as the GOAT. Where does it end?! :witzend:

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 05:54
by Poncey
BIGMARK wrote:
Phenomenal-Nutrition wrote:Robinson was lucky he never had to take a dive but he carried allot of fighters under instruction from the MOB. He was supposed to carry Henry Armstrong. Once he accidently scored a KO against someone he was supposed to KO and by all accounts was terrified but the mobster accepted 'these things happen'
i always believed he was one of the few boxers who the mob failed to control in that era and because of this it took him a while to get his chance. Of course the mob would of played some roll a long the way but in Robinsons case not as much as others, i could be wrong.
According to his biog, you're right. :TU:

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 06:18
by bennie
Robinson licked Sammy Angott, Marty Servo and Fritzie Zivic in his first year as a pro - all of them dangerous former world champions.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 06:30
by McCannW14
bennie wrote:Robinson licked Sammy Angott, Marty Servo and Fritzie Zivic in his first year as a pro - all of them dangerous former world champions.
That sums it up for me.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 07:12
by Scrap
Robinson was mobbed controled, trouble is I cant give my sources. Just that they are very good Historians, and it came as a shock to them, as to me :oo . Great Fighter yes.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 07:16
by jamesmcdonnell
Emerson Poncey Name Ghent wrote:Based upon his period it has to be. Moore is the only one for me that comes remotely close.

You also forgot Zivic. An often overlooked LW that beat a faded Armstrong, with Robinson in attendance nonetheless (Armstrong was his hero). Also Joey Archer and Giardello deserve a mention on that list.

The Maxim fight was one that Robinson was allegedly winning, but the intolerable heat got the better of him and he had to quit. His physician reported that he almost died in the ring from dehydration. It took him over a week to fully recover. Think he slept for 2 days after that fight.

I'm still on the fence as to who was better' Armstrong or Robinson.

It's a disgrace that his first 5 fights with La Motta aren't available.
Armstrong probably has the best 2-year record ever. He defended the welterweight title 19 times in 2 years, and stopped 18 of those opponents.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 07:42
by Deserter
On the subject of Armstrong - his achievements look phenomenal on paper but I've got one question that's really bugging me.
Can anyone envisage a fighter in the modern era, no matter how good they are, being able to dominate in all those different weight divisions like Armstrong did?
If not, was he just a complete freak of nature, or does it suggest that contrary to many beliefs, boxing was weaker then?
In part I can't help but think that with the advances in nutrition, training and knowing how to 'peak', it would be impossible even for Armstrong to replicate his achievements should he 'exist' in the current era, but I genuinely can't make up my mind on this one so I'd be interested to hear other views.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 07:51
by Scrap
Think they were Tougther then didnt eat Shit then, didnt get to many Obese people. They were Hard Times, so whats new in training Techniques that beats want. :DDD

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 08:19
by Deserter
Scrap wrote:Think they were Tougther then didnt eat Shit then, didnt get to many Obese people. They were Hard Times, so whats new in training Techniques that beats want. :DDD
You didn't answer my question Scrap - if Armstrong was operating now, could he have achieved the same feats? If not, why not?

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 09:01
by jamesmcdonnell
Deserter wrote:On the subject of Armstrong - his achievements look phenomenal on paper but I've got one question that's really bugging me.
Can anyone envisage a fighter in the modern era, no matter how good they are, being able to dominate in all those different weight divisions like Armstrong did?
If not, was he just a complete freak of nature, or does it suggest that contrary to many beliefs, boxing was weaker then?
In part I can't help but think that with the advances in nutrition, training and knowing how to 'peak', it would be impossible even for Armstrong to replicate his achievements should he 'exist' in the current era, but I genuinely can't make up my mind on this one so I'd be interested to hear other views.
Actually, Armstrong was a freak.

He apparently had an abnormally large heart - which allowed him to box at a ferocious pace for fifteen rounds without tiring. His heart rate was so low, that he had to warm up for two hours in the dressing room to get himself ready for the fight.


http://coxscorner.tripod.com/armstrong.html
Upon his death it was discovered that Armstrong’s heart was a third larger than that of the average person. This allowed him to fight at a ferocious pace for 15 rounds without loss of breath. It seems certain that he could have done the same thing in a 20 round bout.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 09:36
by Deserter
jamesmcdonnell wrote:
Deserter wrote:On the subject of Armstrong - his achievements look phenomenal on paper but I've got one question that's really bugging me.
Can anyone envisage a fighter in the modern era, no matter how good they are, being able to dominate in all those different weight divisions like Armstrong did?
If not, was he just a complete freak of nature, or does it suggest that contrary to many beliefs, boxing was weaker then?
In part I can't help but think that with the advances in nutrition, training and knowing how to 'peak', it would be impossible even for Armstrong to replicate his achievements should he 'exist' in the current era, but I genuinely can't make up my mind on this one so I'd be interested to hear other views.
Actually, Armstrong was a freak.

He apparently had an abnormally large heart - which allowed him to box at a ferocious pace for fifteen rounds without tiring. His heart rate was so low, that he had to warm up for two hours in the dressing room to get himself ready for the fight.


http://coxscorner.tripod.com/armstrong.html
Upon his death it was discovered that Armstrong’s heart was a third larger than that of the average person. This allowed him to fight at a ferocious pace for 15 rounds without loss of breath. It seems certain that he could have done the same thing in a 20 round bout.
Fascinating, but still doesn't really get to the heart of the matter (no pun intended). We all know boxers with great engines (remember Troy Dorsey?!), but that alone can't come close to accounting for the ability to be able to simultaneously rule over that wide a weight range.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 11:50
by Scrap
Deserter, sorry been out had a great Day,let me say to get to the top in the 30s and 40s the competition was intense there were millions of Fighters, if you could do it then Im pretty sure you could do it now. Other Sports have increased in numbers and eqiupment used. Boxing the only things thats changed are soles on shoes. so aresoles :DDD

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 12:40
by Scrap
I am not certain, but I believe He never weighted more than 10.2 even when He fought for the middleweight Title. If your good enougth your Big enougth. Hearts are developed by working them, you dont buy them of the shelf, theres a reason why the 2 Armstrong had them.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 12:55
by Scrap
Not so Mark, plenty of Arobic work will help the Hearts walls will increase over time as will Lung capacity. Mine was larger than normal, working at altitude Helps, living there is even better. Look at endurance Athletes and where they live.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 13:21
by dondada
Didn't Armstrong have a resting heart rate of 29? Jesus.

Re: Ray Robinson's resume!

Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 13:24
by Scrap
Was that measured laying down or stood up Ian