Dec 1932
Central Park Arena, Orange, New Jersey
Aug 1932
Fort Hamilton Arena, Brooklyn, New York
Nov 1929
Broadway Arena, Brooklyn, New York
Oct 1929
Uptown Lenox S.C., New York, New York
Goldberg was on the canvas twice in the ninth round, but was saved from a knockout by the bell.
Sep 1929
Forum, Montreal, Quebec
Jul 1929
Dexter Park Arena, Woodhaven, Queens, New York
Often incorrectly reported as having occurred July 9.
Apr 1929
Heinemann Park, New Orleans, Louisiana
Apr 1929
Convention Hall, Rochester, New York
Mar 1929
Olympia A.C., New York, New York
Feb 1929
Uptown Lenox S.C., New York, New York
Feb 1929
Arena, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Jan 1929
South Main Street Armory, Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania
Jan 1929
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Dec 1928
Arena, New Haven, Connecticut
Nov 1928
Broadway Auditorium, Buffalo, New York
Nov 1928
Broadway Arena, Brooklyn, New York
Oct 1927
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Canzoneri "showed that he is unversed in the art of pulling his punches and making them appear real. A crowd of approximately 10, 000 began calling for action in the fourth round. While Dundee, essaying a comeback after a year's layoff was widely cheered as he entered the ring he was roundly booed at the final bell. Many of the spectators left the garden at the end of the seventh round." (AP) Dundee, who weighed 140 pounds the month before, entered at 125?.
Oct 1926
Recreation Park, San Francisco, California
World Jr. Lightweight Title
Aug 1926
Ebbets Field, Brooklyn, New York
Dundee broke a bone in his right arm just below the elbow during the third round.
Mar 1926
Arena Colon, Havana
Jan 1926
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Jul 1925
Queensboro Stadium, Long Island City, Queens, New York
Jun 1925
Coney Island Stadium, Brooklyn, New York
May 1925
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
The verdict was received by a chorus of boos from the crowd. Then Sergeant John F. Mullins of the "Fighting 69th, " resplendent in his service uniform and medals, stood in the center of the ring and played "Taps" on a bugle - marking the very last boxing match to be held at the old Madison Square Garden.
Apr 1925
Auditorium, Washington, District of Columbia
From Washington newspapers (Laurence Fielding), reported as a 10-round win for Finnegan and not a 4-round knockout for Dundee as was shown here previously. Also, out-of-town newspapers (e.g. Pittsburgh Post, Philadelphia Record) reported a 10-round win for Finnegan.
Mar 1925
Mechanics Building, Boston, Massachusetts
Oct 1924
Public Hall, Cleveland, Ohio
Sep 1924
Queensboro Stadium, Long Island City, Queens, New York
Jun 1924
Henderson's Bowl, Brooklyn, New York
World Jr. Lightweight Title
National Sports Alliance Relief Fund Card
(Dundee vacates the World Featherweight Title on August 20, 1924. Result from New York City newspapers.)
Jun 1924
Open-air Arena, East Chicago, Indiana
Dundee "was defeated by a wide margin." (Iowa City Press Citizen) According to the Chicago Tribune, Mandell won 6 rounds, Dundee three, and one was even.
Jun 1924
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Apr 1924
Civic Auditorium, Canton, Ohio
Newspaper decision from the Massillon Evening Independent
Apr 1924
Broadway Auditorium, Buffalo, New York
Feb 1924
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Dec 1923
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
World Jr. Lightweight Title
The New York Times scored this fight 10 rounds for Bernstein, three for Dundee and two even--The Newark Star-Eagle also felt that this was the type of decision that would ruin boxing. Referee voted for Bernstein while the two judges voted for Dundee.
Dec 1923
Arena Gardens, Detroit, Michigan
Nov 1923
Elm Rink, New Bedford, Massachusetts
Aug 1923
Shetzline Ballpark, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Three Philadelphia newspapers (Inquirer, Record, and the Public Ledger all had Wagner winning,
Jul 1923
Polo Grounds, New York, New York
World Featherweight Title
Criqui down four times
Jun 1923
Auditorium, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Newspaper decision from the Milwaukee Journal
May 1923
Coney Island Velodrome, Brooklyn, New York
World Jr. Lightweight Title
Bernstein was down for an 8-count in round three.
May 1923
Armouries, Windsor, Ontario
Apr 1923
Coliseum, Toronto, Ontario
The Globe & Mail gave Dundee all 12 rounds. The Star felt it was a closer, but agreed that Dundee had a clear edge. In the 9th round, Dundee suffered a bad cut above his right eye which he claimed was the result of an elbow. The papers felt it was a right hand that did the damage.
Mar 1923
Rink S.C., Brooklyn, New York
One of the many fights on this night to raise money for war-torn France. (New York Times)
Feb 1923
Louisiana Auditorium, New Orleans, Louisiana
Feb 1923
Mechanics Building, Boston, Massachusetts
Feb 1923
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
World Jr. Lightweight Title
Flores floored 4 times during the bout.
Jan 1923
Mechanics Building, Boston, Massachusetts
Dec 1922
Auditorium, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Newspaper decision from the Milwaukee Journal
Dec 1922
Clermont Avenue Rink, Brooklyn, New York
Dec 1922
Broad A.C., Newark, New Jersey
Nov 1922
Arena, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Public Ledger and Philadelphia Inquirer. The venue in which this program was held was the former Ice Palace. It remained in use for many years, known simply as the "Arena."
Nov 1922
Broadway Arena, Brooklyn, New York
Aug 1922
Velodrome, New York, New York
World Jr. Lightweight Title
Aug 1922
Ebbets Field, Brooklyn, New York
Jul 1922
City Auditorium, Houston, Texas
Newspaper decision from the Galveston Daily News
Jul 1922
Queensboro Stadium, Long Island City, Queens, New York
National Sports Alliance Benefit Card. This was billed as an exhibition, but a decision was given.
Jul 1922
Ebbets Field, Brooklyn, New York
World Jr. Lightweight Title
Attendance: 10, 000
Jun 1922
Douglas Park, Rock Island, Illinois
Newspaper decision from the Davenport Democrat and Leader
May 1922
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Apr 1922
Casino, Worcester, Massachusetts
Apr 1922
Civic Arena, Toronto, Ontario
Intended to be for Jr. Lightweight title but Goodrich was 1 pound overweight. "Had the decision been given to the Buffalo youth it would have been unfair, but there were many in attendance who thought that a draw would have injured neither...Goodrich repeatedly sent the fans into an ecstasy of delight by the manner in which he traded his wares with the champion." - Globe & Mail
Mar 1922
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Feb 1922
Town Hall, Scranton, Pennsylvania
The referee halted this bout, claiming the men were not trying. He had warned them in the fifth to "do more real fighting."
Feb 1922
Infantry Hall, Providence, Rhode Island
Date: Saturday, February 18, 1922
Paper: Boston Herald (Boston, MA)
Page: 8
Feb 1922
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Jan 1922
4th Regiment Armory, Baltimore, Maryland
From Baltimore newspapers (Laurence Fielding).
Jan 1922
Mechanics Building, Boston, Massachusetts
Jan 1922
Ice Palace, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Public Ledger and the Philadelphia Inquirer.
Dec 1921
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Dec 1921
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Dundee received the newspaper decision from three Philadelphia newspapers, the Record, the Public Ledger, and the Inquirer.
Dec 1921
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Inquirer and the Philadelphia Public Ledger.
Nov 1921
Broadway Arena, Brooklyn, New York
Nov 1921
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
World Jr. Lightweight Title
Tex Rickard presented the jewelled belt for this newly-created division/title.
Oct 1921
Triangle Park, Dayton, Ohio
Sep 1921
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
Aug 1921
Shibe Park, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Popular verdict - a win for Dundee according to the Philadelphia Public Ledger, Inquirer, and Record.
Aug 1921
Boxing Drome, The Bronx, New York
Aug 1921
Chadwick Park, Albany, New York
Reported in the August 2, 1921 Niagara Falls Gazette, Times-Union
Jul 1921
Broadway Arena, Brooklyn, New York
Jul 1921
Shibe Park, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala), the Philadelphia Record), and the Philadelphia Inquirer (Jack Kincaid).
Jun 1921
Pioneer Sporting Club, New York, New York
Jun 1921
Mechanics Building, Boston, Massachusetts
May 1921
Twin City A.C., East Chicago, Indiana
May 1921
Forbes Field, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from Pittsburgh Post, according to which Ray won decisively.
Apr 1921
Auditorium, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Newspaper decision from the Milwaukee Journal
Apr 1921
Motor Square Garden, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from Pittsburgh Post for Ray. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette had it a draw. Pittsburgh Press gave edge to Dundee.
First fight to be radio broadcast from ringside -- announcer was Post sportswriter Florent Gibson
Feb 1921
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Dec 1920
Pilsbury Winter Gardens, New Orleans, Louisiana
From the New Orleans Times-Picayune. This was a hard, evenly-fought affair.
Nov 1920
Manhattan Casino, New York, New York
The venue became the first club under the state's new Walker Boxing Law, which had legalized boxing in the state earlier this year, to have its permit revoked by the boxing commission. Commissioners attending the bout reported that there had been "wild infractions of the boxing law, the laws of safety and a complete disregard of the rights and comfort of ticket holders." McPartland declared a draw after two judges disagreed (one judge had even, other had Jackson ahead)."
Sep 1920
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Jul 1920
1st Regiment Armory, Newark, New Jersey
Jul 1920
Mechanics Building, Boston, Massachusetts
Dundee floored Downes in the sixth round and gave him a severe trouncing.
Jun 1920
2nd Regiment Armory, Trenton, New Jersey
Trenton Evening Times
ND per RRB and Buffalo Courier
Jun 1920
Mechanics Building, Boston, Massachusetts
Jun 1920
Shibe Park, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Three Philadelphia newspapers (Record, Inquirer, Public Ledger) gave the newspaper decision to Dundee.
May 1920
Cuddy's Arena, Lawrence, Massachusetts
May 1920
Navin Field, Detroit, Michigan
Newspaper decision from the Detroit Free Press.
May 1920
1st Regiment Armory, Newark, New Jersey
Jackson won the newspaper decision. (New York Times, Chicago Tribune and Washington Post)
Apr 1920
Neil Park, Columbus, Ohio
Mar 1920
4th Regiment Armory, Jersey City, New Jersey
Jackson the "newspaper decision." (New York Times) According to the Jersey Journal (Herb Goldman), Jackson won six of the eight rounds.
Feb 1920
Municipal Auditorium, Atlanta, Georgia
The referee declared it a draw, but three sports writers at the ringside stated Lawler had the better of seven rounds. (Often reported as occurring Feb. 26.)
Feb 1920
4th Regiment Armory, Jersey City, New Jersey
Dec 1919
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala), the Philadelphia Inquirer (Jack Kincaid), and the Philadelphia Record.
Nov 1919
Auditorium, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Newspaper decision from the Milwaukee Journal
Nov 1919
4th Regiment Armory, Jersey City, New Jersey
"Mel Coogan, of Brooklyn, outfought Johnny Dundee, of New York, in five of the eight rounds in their contest." (Reno Evening Gazette) The Philadelphia Record also reported Coogan as the winner.
Nov 1919
1st Regiment Armory, Newark, New Jersey
Oct 1919
Auditorium, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Newspaper decision from the Milwaukee Journal
Oct 1919
West Street Rink, Lawrence, Massachusetts
Dundee gave away 15 pounds wnd yet won easily.
Sep 1919
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Dundee won the "newspaper decision, " according to three Philadelphia newspapers: the Record, Public Inquirer, Inquirer.
Sep 1919
Mechanics Building, Boston, Massachusetts
Sep 1919
1st Regiment Armory, Newark, New Jersey
Sep 1919
Marieville Gardens, North Providence, Rhode Island
Sep 1919
4th Regiment Armory, Jersey City, New Jersey
Jackson won the newspaper decision from the following NJ newspapers: The Paterson Morning Call, The Passaic Daily News, The Long Branch Daily Record, amd The Camden Courier-Post. The NY Times also favored Jackson. Dundee won: Illustrated Boxing News, Sep 6, 1919
Aug 1919
Shibe Park, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
The Philadelphia Record and the Inquirer voted for Dundee as winner, an the (Public Ledger called it a draw.
Aug 1919
Open-Air Arena, Jersey City, New Jersey
Newspaper decision from the Chicago Tribune.
Jul 1919
Fenway A.A., Boston, Massachusetts
This was a promotion of the Fenway A.A.
Jul 1919
Mechanics Building, Boston, Massachusetts
Jun 1919
Arena, Syracuse, New York
Jun 1919
Shibe Park, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
The Philadelphia Record favored Dundee as winner of the newspaper decision, but the Philadelphia Public Ledger and Philadelphia Inquirer gave it to Leonard.
Jun 1919
Shibe Park, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision in favor of Dundee from three Philadelphia newspapers: Public Ledger, Record, Inquirer.
May 1919
Exposition Building, Portland, Maine
Newspaper decision from the Boston Globe.
May 1919
Auditorium, Saint Paul, Minnesota
May 1919
Auditorium, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Newspaper decision from the Milwaukee Journal
Newspapermen voted: draw, 3; Dundee, 2; Mitchell, 1
Mar 1919
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Mealey was down twice in the 2nd round. Dundee won the newspaper decision from three Philadelphia newspapers: Inquirer, Record, Public Ledger.
Feb 1919
Duquesne Gardens, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from Pittsburgh Post, according to which Dundee was a clear winner.
Jan 1919
1st Regiment Armory, Newark, New Jersey
Jersey Journal and Trenton Evening Times.
Dec 1918
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
"Neither man showed spirited aggressiveness and they suffered no punishment." Nevada State Journal Both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala) gave Mealey the newspaper decision.
Dec 1918
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
Nov 1918
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Record in favor of Dundee.
Nov 1918
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Popular verdict-a draw (New York Times).
Nov 1918
State Armory, Bridgeport, Connecticut
Newspaper decision from the Norwalk Hour
Nov 1918
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Dundee won the "newspaper decision." (New York Times) Newspaper decision as given in the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala).
Oct 1918
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
Sep 1918
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
Sep 1918
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
Aug 1918
Armory A.A., Jersey City, New Jersey
(New York Times) Paterson News had Tuohey winning
Aug 1918
Armory, Boston, Massachusetts
Jun 1918
Open-Air Arena, Jersey City, New Jersey
From the Jersey Journal (Herb Goldman). Dundee won six of the eight rounds. Moe than 4, 000 fans attended.
Jun 1918
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
Note: The promoter was the Armory A.A., but the venue was the Arena, and was often the case in this period.
Jun 1918
Arena, New Haven, Connecticut
May 1918
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Dundee won the newspaper decision according to the Philadelphia Public Legend (Paul Zabala) and the Philadelphia Record.
May 1918
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
(New York Times, Boston Globe)
Mar 1918
Arena, New Haven, Connecticut
(The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer)
Mar 1918
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
Mar 1918
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision in favor of Dundee from the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala), and from the Philadelphia Record.
Feb 1918
Louisiana Auditorium, New Orleans, Louisiana
Jan 1918
Dauphine Theater, New Orleans, Louisiana
Dec 1917
Casino Hall, Bridgeport, Connecticut
Dec 1917
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala). The Pittsburgh Post said that three reporters favored Ray, two Dundee, and one had it even. It was a rousing battle.
The other scheduled fights on this program were: Bobby Burns v. Jack Wolpert, 6 rounds; Mike Ertle v. Goody Welsh, 6 rounds; Al Bauer v. George Reynolds, 6 rounds; Jack Mosely v. Battling Dundee, 6 rounds.
Nov 1917
Unity Cycle Club, Lawrence, Massachusetts
Nov 1917
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
The promoter was the Armory A.A., but the venue was the Arena.
Nov 1917
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision in favor of Dundee from the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala), the Inquirer, and the Philadelphia Record.
Nov 1917
Pioneer Sporting Club, New York, New York
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Record and the Pittsburgh Post.
Oct 1917
Pioneer S.C., New York, New York
Oct 1917
Manhattan Casino, New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid). This was a promotion of the Empire A.C.
Oct 1917
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Tendler received the newspaper decision from both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala). However it was a close fight.
Sep 1917
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
New York Times and NY Sun
Sep 1917
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
Sep 1917
Fairmont A.C., The Bronx, New York
Popular verdict - a win for Dundee (New York Times). Evening World says Dundee beat Jack Russo of New Orleans, who had arrived in NYC that week.
Aug 1917
Shibe Park, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala) said that Dundee won the newspaper decision.
Jul 1917
Pioneer S.C., New York, New York
(New York Times, NY Sun, NY Tribune) Paterson News scored it 9-0-1 for Dundee
Jul 1917
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
Welling won the newspaper decision. (Trenton Evening Times) (New York Times)
Jul 1917
Shibe Park, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala) favored Chaney, but the Philadelphia Record considered Dundee to be the winner.
Jun 1917
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
Dundee won the "newspaper decision." (New York Times)
Jun 1917
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
The promoter was the Armory A.A., but the venue was the Arena.
Jun 1917
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
Dundee won the "newspaper decision." (New York Times; New York Telegraph (Bat Masterson))
May 1917
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
May 1917
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
The Armory A.A. held most of its promotions at the Arena at this time.
May 1917
Grand Opera House, Boston, Massachusetts
Apr 1917
Broadway S.C., Brooklyn, New York
Apr 1917
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Dundee received the newspaper decision from both the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala) and the Philadelphia Record.
Apr 1917
Pioneer S.C., New York, New York
Mar 1917
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala) gave the newspaper decision to Tendler. The Inquirer called it a draw. Dundee lost the press decision, it was not a newspaper win for Dundee as previously shown.
Mar 1917
Pioneer S.C., New York, New York
(New York Times) The consensus of the New York newspapers was a win for Dundee. (Jack Kincaid)
Mar 1917
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision in favor of Dundee from the Philadelphia Record and from the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala).
Feb 1917
Broadway S.C., Brooklyn, New York
Jack Kincaid found that two Brooklyn newspapers favored Callahan and two called it a draw.
Jan 1917
Tulane Arena, New Orleans, Louisiana
Jan 1917
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Result from Philadelphia newspapers: the Record and the Public Ledger (Paul Zabala).
Dec 1916
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision in favor of Dundee from both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Public Ledger.
Dec 1916
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision for Dundee from Philadelphia Record. Newspaper decision for Tillman from Philadelphia Public Ledger.
Tillman was down in round one and Dundee in round six. But the Evening Public Ledger gives Dundee the newspaper win.
Nov 1916
Broadway Arena, Brooklyn, New York
Newspaper decision for Dundee from the Brooklyn Citizen, New York Herald and New York Times. The New York Sun, the Brooklyn DailyEagle and the Brooklyn Times-Union reported a win for Wallace.
Dundee was knocked down in the fourth round. Consensus seems to favor a newspaper draw.
Nov 1916
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Leonard was "held even" in a "fierce battle." (Trenton Evening Times)
Wire reports (Ed. Bull.) had Leonard ahead. "Dundee defeats Leonard has big margin of points..." (New York Times). Both the Philadelphia Public Ledger and the Philadelphia Record said that Dundee was the winner. The Philadelphia Inquirer called it a draw.
Oct 1916
Future City A.C., Saint Louis, Missouri
Dundee won the newspaper decision (Chicago Tribune, Salt Lake Tribune).
Sep 1916
Convention Hall, Kansas City, Missouri
Aug 1916
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Dundee won the newspaper decision. (Sandusky Star Journal)
Aug 1916
Armory, Boston, Massachusetts
Jul 1916
Lovington Field, East Chicago, Indiana
Mixed results in newspapers: Fort Wayne News reported win for Dundee;
Decatur Review reported a draw; wire services reported "majority of reporters" had it a draw. Update: Extensive description and round-by-round coverage gives fight to Dundee. Source: Chicago Tribune. The Times(East Chicago)reported a tough fight but a win for Dundee 7/5/1916: "The Italian was too clever, although the Swede kept trying at all times and put up a fight which will in no way belittle his pugilistic prowess. Both played for the body when fighting at close quarters, and their bodies were a crimson color when they quit."
Jun 1916
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Newspaper decision for Leonard from George G. Underwood (NY Press), NY Herald.
Newspaper decision for Dundee from NY Times, Igoe (NY World).
A draw from W.O. M'Geehan (NY Tribune), W.B. Masterson (NY Telegraph), W.S. Farnsworth (NY American).
The consensus of New York City newspapers is a draw (searched by Jack Kincaid).
May 1916
Marieville Gardens, North Providence, Rhode Island
May 1916
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision in favor of Dundee from both the Philadelphia Public Ledger and the Philadelphia Record.
May 1916
Broadway Auditorium, Buffalo, New York
(Chicago Tribune)
Buffalo Boxing Record reports a draw. "...Dundee's leap-frog stunts had O'Leary puzzled during most of the ten rounds..." Lethbridge Herald
May 1916
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
Note: At this time the programs of the Armory A.A. were generally held at the Boston Arena.
Apr 1916
Broadway Arena, Brooklyn, New York
Newspaper decision from the Brooklyn Daily Eagle and New York Times
Mar 1916
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Dundee down in 8th. Five newspapers favored Leonard and five preferred Dundee, so it was a draw.
Feb 1916
Louisiana Auditorium, New Orleans, Louisiana
The New Orleans Item, New Orleans States and New Orleans Times-Picayune all agreed that this was a bad decision.
Feb 1916
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision in favor of Dundee from both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala).
Jan 1916
Stockyards Stadium, Denver, Colorado
Jan 1916
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision in favor of Dundee is from the Philadelphia Public Ledger and the Philadelphia Record.
Jan 1916
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Public Ledger and the Record in favor of Dundee.
Dec 1915
Italian Riverside Club, New Haven, Connecticut
Dec 1915
Pioneer Sporting Club, New York, New York
Newspaper decision from the New York Times, and from other New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid). Except for the Brooklyn Eagle which had Bloom winning.
Nov 1915
Clermont Avenue Rink, Brooklyn, New York
Dundee won the newspaper decision. (Fort Wayne News) (New York Times) and generally in New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Nov 1915
Auditorium, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Newspaper decision from the Milwaukee Free Press
Oct 1915
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Jack Kincaid found that 8 New York City newspapers favored Dundee, two gave it to Ritchie, and one called it a draw. Dundee appeared to have been hurt by a right hand in the 8th round, and was battered around the ring by Ritchie.
Sep 1915
Ebbets Field, Brooklyn, New York
Aug 1915
Auditorium, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Newspaper decision from the Milwaukee Free Press
Mitchell was floored twice
Jul 1915
Ebbets Field, Brooklyn, New York
Dundee won the newspaper decision according to the New York Times. Rivers did come on strong in the last two rounds though.
Jun 1915
Ebbets Field, Brooklyn, New York
Dundee's foot work was fast and tireless, he ducked away from Cross' punches and won the bout. (New York Times)
May 1915
Ebbets Field, Brooklyn, New York
May 1915
Joe Levy's Open Air Club, Cincinnati, Ohio
May 1915
Broadway Auditorium, Buffalo, New York
"Dundee's speed is too much for Rocky Kansas" Syracuse Herald. Buffalo Evening News scored it 4-2-4 for Dundee. Buffalo Times scored it a draw. Buffalo Courier and Buffalo Enquirer scored it for Dundee.
Mar 1915
Broadway Arena, Brooklyn, New York
Dundee won the newspaper decision. (Fort Wayne News)
Mar 1915
Phoenix A.C., Memphis, Tennessee
Referee hack awarded Dundee a decision but the audience thought it pretty even. Special Wire to Buffalo Courier
Mar 1915
Broadway S.C., Brooklyn, New York
Mar 1915
135th Street A.C., New York, New York
"Johnny Dundee outfought Benny Leonard in a fast 10-round bout." (Trenton Evening Times) (New York Times) Jack Kincaid found that seven New York City newspapers favored Dundee as winner, and only one gave it to Leonard.
Feb 1915
McDonoughville Arena, New Orleans, Louisiana
Reported in the Times-Picayune. This was a fast, furious battle.
Jan 1915
Hippodrome, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Newspaper decision from the Milwaukee Free Press
Dec 1914
Arena, Vernon, California
Reported to be the last 20-round bout staged prior to the new anti-prize fight law going into effect in California.
Oct 1914
Coffroth's Arena, Daly City, California
Ritchie about 10 pounds heavier.
Oct 1914
Piedmont Pavilion, Oakland, California
Sep 1914
Arena, Vernon, California
Jul 1914
Arena, Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua
Jul 1914
Pelican Stadium, New Orleans, Louisiana
Newspaper draw from the New Orleans Times-Picayune (Jack Kincaid). The New Orleans Item gave it to Mandot.
Jun 1914
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
May 1914
Irving A.C., Brooklyn, New York
Dundee won the newspaper decision. (New York Times)
Apr 1914
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala). The Inquirer also favored Dundee.
Apr 1914
Arena, Boston, Massachusetts
Previously listed as 10 round draw at Cambridge, MA. Source:Boston Globe
Apr 1914
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
"Shooting rights and lefts to the face too fast to count, Johnny Dundee handed Charley "Kid" Thomas an artistic lacing in the final bout at the National A.C. here tonight." Lima Daily News Dundee won the newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala) and he Philadelphia Record.
Mar 1914
Irving A.C., Brooklyn, New York
Mar 1914
Windsor A.C., Windsor, Ontario
Evening Record (Windsor, Ontario)
Mar 1914
Irving A.C., Brooklyn, New York
Popular verdict-a draw. (New York Times) The Brooklyn newspaper consensus was also a draw (Jack Kincaid).
Mar 1914
Atlantic Garden A.C., New York, New York
Feb 1914
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Dundee won newspaper decision according to the Philadelphia Public Ledger (Paul Zabala) and the Philadelphia Record.
Feb 1914
National S.C., New York, New York
Feb 1914
Broadway Auditorium, Buffalo, New York
Newspaper decision for Kansas from Buffalo Courier, Buffalo Enquirer (7-1-2), Buffalo Morning Express, Buffalo News (6-1-3), Buffalo Times.
Feb 1914
Auditorium, Waterbury, Connecticut
Waterbury Republican scored for Shugrue 8-3-1 in rounds.
"All the New York papers give Johnny Dundee the decision over Shugrue in Waterbury last night although the Connecticut critics concede the honors to Shugrue. Dundee is a member of a prominent New York manager's stable and this may account for the verdicts of the metropolitan writers."-- The Bridgeport (CT) Farmer.
Hartford Courant: "Shugrue outpoints Clever Dundee Boy."
Norwich Bulletin (Conn) reported "Shugrue Got Decision"
Feb 1914
Empire A.C., New Star Casino, New York, New York
Dundee won according to the NY Times, NY Sun, and NY Evening World.
Jan 1914
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Jan 1914
Empire A.C., New Star Casino, New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid). Several NY City newspapers scored in a draw.
Jan 1914
Crescent A.C., Brooklyn, New York
As Johnny Reich, Reiss likely-Dundee won-The Brooklyn Standard Union.
Jan 1914
Pelican Stadium, New Orleans, Louisiana
"Dundee was accredited with having the best of the first two rounds, Welsh showed superiority in the fourth, eighth and tenth rounds, and the others were even." (Atlanta Constitution) Newspaper decision from the New Orleans Times-Picayune (Herb Goldman).
Dec 1913
Civic Auditorium, Canton, Ohio
A draw from Canton Evening Repository, Walter C. Kelly (Cleveland Plain Dealer), J. P. Garvey (Cleveland Leader), Massillon Evening Independent, INS wire. Newspaper decision for Dundee from H. T. McDaniel (New Orleans Item).
Nov 1913
Pelican Stadium, New Orleans, Louisiana
Dundee won the "newspaper decision." (New York Times)
Oct 1913
Arena, Vernon, California
Aug 1913
Arena, Vernon, California
Jul 1913
Albuquerque, New Mexico
Dixon knocked down three times in the fight.
Jun 1913
Arena, Vernon, California
Dundee was an "easy winner." (Reno Evening Gazette)
Apr 1913
Arena, Vernon, California
World Featherweight Title
Jan 1913
Olympia Boxing Club, New York, New York
Jan 1913
Auditorium, Waterbury, Connecticut
Newspaper decision from the Naugatuck Daily News, New York Times, The Bridgeport Evening Farmer and New Haven Union.
Jan 1913
Clermont Avenue Rink, Brooklyn, New York
Dundee won the newspaper decision. (New York Times)
Jan 1913
Clermont Avenue Rink, Brooklyn, New York
Dundee won the newspaper decision (Brooklyn Times Union; New York Times).
Dec 1912
44th Street A.C., New York, New York
"Johnny Dundee of New York gained the honors over Eddie Morgan" (New York Times)
Nov 1912
Arena, Vernon, California
Oct 1912
Orleans A.C., New Orleans, Louisiana
Oct 1912
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
Sep 1912
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
Popular verdict - a win for Dundee. "Thomas delivered the harder blows in the in-fighting but in open work Dundee was faster and his punches carried more steam". (New York Times)
Sep 1912
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
Newspaper decision provided by the New York Times
Sep 1912
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
According to Jack Kincaid, eight of the New York newspapers favored Kilbane, one (the American) preferred Dundee, and one scored it a draw.
Aug 1912
Luna Park Arena, Cleveland, Ohio
Results from the Cleveland Plain Dealer, which stated that Dundee won 7 of 12 rounds and should have been awarded the decision from hometown boy Brock.
Aug 1912
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
Newspaper decision for Dundee from NY Times and NY Sun.
Jul 1912
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
Dundee landed a left to the jaw, as Cobb turned with the punch his ankle gave way. It was necessary to carry him to his corner, the doctor diagnosed a dislocated ankle.
Cobb substituted for Patsy Kline.
Jul 1912
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York
The New York Sun, NY Evening World, Brooklyn Times, Brooklyn Citizen, Brooklyn Daily Eagle, Hudson Observer, Jersey Journal(6-4) all scored for Shugrue. NY Times called it a draw.
Jun 1912
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
May 1912
St. Nicholas Arena, New York, New York
Apr 1912
Alhambra, Syracuse, New York
"Clearly taking eight of the ten rounds, giving an exhibition of footwork and ring generalship such as is seldom seen, and battering his opponent's face into a shapeless mass of swelling and bruises, White had the battle by a wide margin." Syracuse Herald
Apr 1912
Manhattan Casino, New York, New York
(New York Times) The Empire A.C. operated at the Manhattan Casino.
Mar 1912
Manhattan Casino, New York, New York
(New York Times) The Empire A.C. operated at the Manhattan Casino.
Mar 1912
Alhambra, Syracuse, New York
Mar 1912
Clermont Avenue Rink, Brooklyn, New York
Dundee was better (New York Times, Brooklyn Daily Eagle). The Royale A.C. operated at the Clermont Rink.
Mar 1912
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
The Philadelphia Item gave the newspaper decision as a draw.
Mar 1912
Manhattan Casino, The Bronx, New York
O'Keefe won the newspaper decision per the Boston Globe, Chicago Tribune, and New York Tribune. The New York Times had it for Dundee. According to Jack Kincaid, most New York City newspapers favored O'Keefe. The Empire A.C. operated at the Manhattan Casino.
Feb 1912
National S.C., New York, New York
Dundee won the "newspaper decision." (New York Times)
Jan 1912
Long Acre A.A., New York, New York
Jan 1912
Fordon A.C., New York, New York
Dec 1911
Fordon A.C., New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York newspapers (Jack Kincaid) and the Philadelphia Item.
Dec 1911
Fordon A.C., New York, New York
Dundee won the "newspaper decision." (New York City newspapers, Jack Kincaid)
Dec 1911
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Item gave the newspaper decision to Reynolds.
Nov 1911
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision in both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record was a draw, however O'Toole took counts of "nine" in both rounds 4 and 6.
Nov 1911
Houston A.C., New York, New York
Newspaper Decision went to Dundee (New York Times) and from other New York newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Nov 1911
Olympic A.C., New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Oct 1911
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Thomas won the newspaper decision according to the Philadelphia Item.
Oct 1911
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Newspaper decision in favor of Dundee from the Philadelphia Item.
Sep 1911
Fairmont A.C., The Bronx, New York
Newspaper decision is from the New York Times.
Sep 1911
Port Jervis, New York
Aug 1911
Fairmont A.C., The Bronx, New York
Aug 1911
Fairmont A.C., The Bronx, New York
(New York Times for Dundee, but the NY Sun for Black
Jul 1911
Long Acre A.C., New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Jul 1911
Olympic A.C., New York, New York
Newspaper decision in favor of Shears from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Jun 1911
Brown's Gym, New York, New York
Newspaper decision in favor of McGovern given in New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Jun 1911
Fairmont A.C., The Bronx, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
May 1911
Port Jervis, New York
May 1911
Lotus Club Auditorium, Perth Amboy, New Jersey
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid). (Perth Amboy Evening News)
May 1911
National S.C., New York, New York
From New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Apr 1911
Prestone A.C., New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Apr 1911
Brown's Gym, New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Apr 1911
Olympic A.C., New York, New York
From New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Mar 1911
Prestone A.C., New York, New York
From New York City newspapers, decision in favor of Black (Jack Kincaid). The NY Sun and the NY Evening World both for Black. Only two NYC papers that reported this fight on the newspapers.com database.
Mar 1911
National A.C., Brooklyn, New York
Mar 1911
Olympic A.C., New York, New York
Newspaper decisions from the New York Times, and from other New York City newspapers, in favor of Sherman (Jack Kincaid).
Mar 1911
National A.C., Brooklyn, New York
Brooklyn Daily Eagle...'Young Mcgovern gave Johnny Dundee the beating of his life'.
Mar 1911
Preston A.C., New York, New York
From New York City newspapers.
Mar 1911
Olympic A.C., New York, New York
According to Jack Kincaid, Dundee was generally considered to have won the newspaper decision.
Feb 1911
Hudson Guild A.C., New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Feb 1911
National S.C., New York, New York
Results from the NY Evening Telegram.
Feb 1911
National S.C., New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers.
Feb 1911
Long Acre A.A., New York, New York
(New York Times) This fight was also reported in other New York City newspapers, newspaper decision in favor of Dundee (Jack Kincaid).
Feb 1911
National A.C., Brooklyn, New York
Second of two fights for Dundee on this date.
Feb 1911
National A.C., Brooklyn, New York
Reported in New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid). This was the first of two fights for Dundee on this date.
Feb 1911
Fairmont A.C., The Bronx, New York
Draw mewspaper verdict from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Feb 1911
Manhattan Casino, New York, New York
From New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Feb 1911
New Amsterdam Opera House, National S.C., New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Jan 1911
National A.C., Brooklyn, New York
Jan 1911
Empire A.C., New York, New York
Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Jan 1911
New Amsterdam Opera House, New York, New York
From New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Jan 1911
Midwood A.C., Brooklyn, New York
Newspaper decision from Brooklyn newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Jan 1911
Hudson Guild A.C., New York, New York
From New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Jan 1911
New York, New York
Dec 1910
National S.C., Lyric Hall, New York, New York
From New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Dec 1910
Manhattan Casino, New York, New York
From New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid). Seen in New York Times by Josh Rosenfeld.
Nov 1910
Fordon A.C., New York, New York
Nov 1910
New York, New York
Nov 1910
New York, New York
Nov 1910
New York, New York
Nov 1910
New York, New York
Nov 1910
New Amsterdam Opera House, New York, New York
From New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
Oct 1910
New York, New York
Sep 1910
New York, New York
Sep 1910
New York, New York
Sep 1910
New York, New York
Aug 1910
New York, New York
Aug 1910
New York, New York
Aug 1910
New York, New York
Aug 1910
New York, New York
Aug 1910
Sharkey A.C., New York, New York
Syracuse Herald. According to the 12/17/1922 NY Evening Herald, Dundee fought as "Young Marino". Exact date given in the 8/11/1925 Geneva Daily Times. This was Dundee's PRO DEBUT.