Harrison Vs Brodie who would win?

hide · Post by **hide** » 18 Feb 2004, 13:27

In my own opinon i think Harrison would win,maybe late soppage or points maybe because i am Scottish i favour Harrison,i think it would also depend were it was held ,Glasgow or Manchester whatever fighter got there home town would surely have a massive advantage

REAL_DEAL · Post by **REAL_DEAL** » 18 Feb 2004, 13:52

I think Harrison is too strong for Brodie, but it will never happen

JimStone · Post by **JimStone** » 18 Feb 2004, 13:58

If you're talking about Scott I think he'd win.

If you're talking about Audley, I'd go for Brodie, early

hide · Post by **hide** » 18 Feb 2004, 14:26

If Brodie gets beat in his rematch against Chi,which i think he will there every chance it could happen, dont you think?Saying that it would proberly be a step back for Harrison who may think he has nothing to gain,except being crowned the best Featherweight in Britain

hitman_hatton1 · Post by **hitman_hatton1** » 18 Feb 2004, 15:18

this is the domestic fight i most want to c and by rights it should happen

but unfortunately the way boxing is thes days i just can't c it.

who wins: brodie on pts

Twinkle Toes · Post by **Twinkle Toes** » 18 Feb 2004, 15:59

I think Harrison would win, Brodie is a little to open for my liking, and that would suit Harrison down to the ground.

stujones · Post by **stujones** » 18 Feb 2004, 18:27

Its a tough fight to call, I think Chi was basically to strong for Brodie in the first meeting. Now, that is Harrison's forte - however, is he as strong as Chi?

I would give the edge to Harrison, but its so tough to call mainly because Brodie ran Chi so close - and I'm not sure who is better Chi or Harrison. I just edge Harrison to stop Brodie late (maybe behind at the time).

Georgie Borges · Post by **Georgie Borges** » 18 Feb 2004, 18:37

hide wrote:In my own opinon i think Harrison would win,maybe late soppage or points maybe because i am Scottish i favour Harrison,i think it would also depend were it was held ,Glasgow or Manchester whatever fighter got there home town would surely have a massive advantage

The reason you are called HIDE is because you are hiding under another username arent you Mr Potato Head

hide · Post by **hide** » 19 Feb 2004, 08:52

I think you need to loY off that crack pipe MATE

hide · Post by **hide** » 19 Feb 2004, 08:53

Priff · Post by **Priff** » 19 Feb 2004, 09:05

hide wrote:#lay

You can edit your posts after you submit them.
Click the edit button on the top-right of your post.

steve richards · Post by **steve richards** » 19 Feb 2004, 11:25

Harrison would win late on, brodie is a good fighter but marks up, and going in with a man like harrison he would be in for a hell of a fight, harrison seems to fight better toe to toe than brodie, and i'd bet my house he'd beet the winner of brodie vs chi.

J · Post by J » 19 Feb 2004, 11:54

i think Chi beats either of them, he gave morales nightmares as I recall, harrison couldnt beat the lesser mexiacans on first attempt let alone someone of morales stature. I thought Chi was unlucky to only get a draw against brodie and had him 2 rounds up.

mickeybeard · Post by **mickeybeard** » 19 Feb 2004, 12:11

I'd pick Brodie if he can rember to stand back and box. For all Harrison's toughness, he looks one paced. It took him until the second fight to figure out that he could walk through Medina's punches and rough him up. I think Brodie would be landing hard, crisp shots to head and body, rather than pit-a-pat jabs.

Unfortunately, Brodie seems capable of getting into a life-or-death war in an empty room, so I think I'd pick Scott by late stoppage after Brodie throws his gamplan out the window in the middle rounds.

J · Post by J » 19 Feb 2004, 12:14

mickeybeard wrote: Unfortunately, Brodie seems capable of getting into a life-or-death war in an empty room, so I think I'd pick Scott by late stoppage after Brodie throws his gamplan out the window in the middle rounds.

Great post, love that life or death war in an empty room, he does tend to do that though hey, loses his boxing on the outside in the middle rounds in quite a few fights and gets drawn in. He reckons he will box chi this time be interesting to see, cant fault Mike though, brave lad with plenty of heart.

steve689 · Post by **steve689** » 20 Feb 2004, 17:32

Harrison-Chi now that would be a good war, Harrison has god strength and never stops pressing forward with accurate shots and i think his general pressure and workrate would be too much for Brodie. As much as i like Brodie he has always been a sucker for a good shot and can be hit and hurt, Harrison would probably have too much for him and stop him late. Can you see the smarter Boxer Brodie keeping out of the way of the relentless Harrison for 12 rounds? I could not, i would however like to see Harrison-Chi, too warriors plowing forward and hitting each other none stop. Yes please!

J · Post by J » 23 Feb 2004, 09:05

likewise fingers crossed mate!

mrbassie · Post by **mrbassie** » 23 Feb 2004, 11:08

I would go with Brodie by stoppage late. Harrison is one dimensional and Medina exposed him as such, he won the return because he turned it into a foul filled brawl and the ref let him.
In the first fight Medina ws hurting him in the late rounds with body punches, he also had some minor success with body punches occasionally in the rematch.
I think after a few rounds and a few hhard digs to the body Brodie would start to control him.

Harrison Vs Brodie who would win?

Harrison Vs Brodie who would win?

Re: Harrison Vs Brodie who would win?