Ratings - please read before commenting - Archived

[computerrank]

Thanks!

I will implement the start year (common title = recognized by all big orgs) and we will see ...

weight division; first year

$div_name[1]="Minimumweight"; 1988 (WBC, WBA, IBF)
$div_name[2]="Light Flyweight"; 1975 (WBC, WBA)
$div_name[3]="Flyweight";
$div_name[4]="Super Flyweight"; 1981 (WBC, WBA)
$div_name[5]="Bantamweight";
$div_name[6]="Super Bantamweight"; 1977 (WBC, WBA)
$div_name[7]="Featherweight";
$div_name[8]="Super Featherweight"; 1963 (WBC, WBA)
$div_name[9]="Lightweight";
$div_name[10]="Light Welterweight"; 1959 (World Ortiz)
$div_name[11]="Welterweight";
$div_name[12]="Light Middleweight"; 1962 (WBC, WBA)
$div_name[13]="Middleweight";
$div_name[14]="Super Middleweight"; 1988 (WBC, WBA, IBF)
$div_name[15]="Light Heavyweight";
$div_name[16]="Cruiserweight"; 1982 (WBC, WBA)
$div_name[17]="Heavyweight";

[computerrank]

... here are the results for the new start years:

1988 # Minimum WBC, WBA, IBF
1975 # Light Flyweigt WBC, WBA
1981 # Super Flyweight WBC, WBA
1977 # Super Bantamweight WBC, WBA
1963 # Super Featherweight WBC, WBA
1962 # Light Welterweight WBC, WBA
1962 # Light Middleweight WBC, WBA
1988 # Super Middleweight WBC, WBA, IBF
1982 # Cruiserweight WBC, WBA

Code: Select all

Cruiserweight

+-------------+----------------+------------------+
| last_name   | first_name     | rd               |
+-------------+----------------+------------------+
| De Leon     | Carlos         | 608.172162445226 | 
| Nelson      | Johnny         | 384.125039868528 | 
| Tiozzo      | Fabrice        | 249.007933682509 | 
| Wamba       | Anaclet        | 242.987056547728 | 
| Norris      | Orlin          | 213.632960306602 | 
| Thompson    | Carl           | 184.751874191823 | 
| Crous       | Piet           | 162.811360457776 | 
| Washington  | Adolpho        | 156.158699424931 | 
| Ocasio      | Ossie          | 154.624262420659 | 
| Odhiambho   | John           | 154.173542342815 | 
| Miller      | Nate           | 135.869302469984 | 
| Dominguez   | Marcelo Fabian | 124.065378660136 | 
| Lampkin     | Jeff           | 107.572021990502 | 
| Rothmann    | Sebastiaan     | 98.8917999172783 | 
| Burnett     | Jesse          | 94.1358394684224 | 
| McCrory     | Glenn          | 87.3179042158153 | 
| Ekassi      | Norbert        | 84.2807991769949 | 
| Ali         | Bash           | 79.5493343043474 | 
| Rocchigiani | Ralf           | 75.9457877762625 | 
| Angol       | Derek          | 72.7277180597885 | 
+-------------+----------------+------------------+

Super Middleweight

+------------+--------------+------------------+
| last_name  | first_name   | rd               |
+------------+--------------+------------------+
| Collins    | Steve        | 380.507434668042 | 
| Benn       | Nigel        |  325.08210229143 | 
| Eubank     | Chris        | 324.129123518516 | 
| Ottke      | Sven         | 251.680637328519 | 
| Malinga    | Thulani      | 207.643115945318 | 
| Liles      | Frankie      | 193.127364137946 | 
| Tiozzo     | Christophe   | 156.934796443305 | 
| Baek       | In-Chul      | 148.880226625886 | 
| Cherifi    | Hacine       | 136.003823425888 | 
| Cordoba    | Victor       | 116.417867896663 | 
| Tate       | Thomas       | 99.8022225666733 | 
| Obelmejias | Fulgencio    | 93.2171198871364 | 
| Lucas      | Eric         | 92.9193026313675 | 
| Wharton    | Henry        | 91.5349364569225 | 
| Grant      | Otis         | 79.9829795139251 | 
| Van Horn   | Darrin       | 79.2366959170547 | 
| Woodhall   | Richie       | 76.8859579602388 | 
| Brewer     | Charles      | 75.7530964702807 | 
| Arroyo     | Miguel Angel | 72.9450826130974 | 
+------------+--------------+------------------+

Light Middleweight

+------------+------------+------------------+
| last_name  | first_name | rd               |
+------------+------------+------------------+
| Mazzinghi  | Sandro     | 1102.68142061817 | 
| Norris     | Terry      | 671.674838375411 | 
| Benitez    | Wilfred    | 591.037876244275 | 
| Hope       | Maurice    | 576.938686596964 | 
| Little     | Freddie    | 487.869565332279 | 
| Kim        | Ki Soo     |  406.18344769051 | 
| Kalule     | Ayub       | 350.532672950134 | 
| Visintin   | Bruno      | 343.234308635914 | 
| Boudouani  | Laurent    | 277.547844778721 | 
| Hayward    | Stanley    | 267.820916429897 | 
| Mattioli   | Rocky      | 240.801422724438 | 
| Dupas      | Ralph      | 226.396425418975 | 
| Harrington | Stan       | 188.615756683331 | 
| Santos     | Carlos     | 184.388612719235 | 
| Hamani     | Loucif     |  181.23040275742 | 
| Vargas     | Fernando   | 174.288653077721 | 
| Santos     | Daniel     | 172.151309463881 | 
| Galloway   | Manning    |  164.15412380375 | 
| Moyer      | Denny      | 159.067971959453 | 
| Acaries    | Louis      | 138.079204603153 | 
+------------+------------+------------------+

Light Welterweight

+------------+-------------+------------------+
| last_name  | first_name  | rd               |
+------------+-------------+------------------+
| Locche     | Nicolino    | 1166.07367691185 | 
| Chavez     | Julio Cesar | 1071.79062398707 | 
| Cervantes  | Antonio     | 887.325496180544 | 
| Tszyu      | Kostya      | 700.788039546136 | 
| Arcari     | Bruno       | 677.609778653342 | 
| Pryor      | Aaron       | 630.055405221508 | 
| Hernandez  | Carlos      | 591.281870131718 | 
| Perkins    | Eddie       | 473.242421200061 | 
| Loi        | Duilio      | 329.377001983083 | 
| Coggi      | Juan Martin | 321.421066889512 | 
| Camacho    | Hector      | 257.198504184972 | 
| Mayweather | Roger       | 240.229271359575 | 
| Kaplan     | Louis       | 224.211959875032 | 
| Taylor     | Meldrick    | 212.981980317299 | 
| Joyce      | Willie      | 179.995263305612 | 
| Mamby      | Saoul       | 175.611805628729 | 
| Muangsurin | Saensak     | 170.551090156935 | 
| Randall    | Frankie     | 166.686905515322 | 
| Davies     | Len         | 164.191547113823 | 
| Thompson   | Hector      | 158.797667005273 | 
+------------+-------------+------------------+

Super Featherweight

+------------+------------+------------------+
| last_name  | first_name | rd               |
+------------+------------+------------------+
| Arguello   | Alexis     | 792.938537375842 | 
| Nelson     | Azumah     | 739.564174880063 | 
| Elorde     | Flash      | 645.038894009073 | 
| Serrano    | Samuel     | 571.091063920449 | 
| Kobayashi  | Hiroshi    | 506.115539372434 | 
| Barrientos | Rene       | 405.739949112459 | 
| Escalera   | Alfredo    | 380.183856809081 | 
| Mitchell   | Brian      |  314.44216740609 | 
| Molina     | John John  |  305.39953825746 | 
| Lockridge  | Rocky      | 303.049786678977 | 
| Shibata    | Kuniaki    | 273.909256208659 | 
| Marcano    | Alfredo    | 251.147236717284 | 
| Hernandez  | Genaro     | 235.770327401809 | 
| Corrales   | Diego      | 235.708858977419 | 
| Lopez      | Tony       | 229.316234316354 | 
| Numata     | Yoshiaki   | 226.870418910155 | 
| Villaflor  | Ben        | 220.275449355827 | 
| Amaya      | Antonio    |  217.83540799044 | 
| Gatti      | Arturo     | 215.989111731558 | 
| Michael    | Barry      | 206.839247614358 | 
+------------+------------+------------------+

Super Bantamweight

+------------------+---------------+------------------+
| last_name        | first_name    | rd               |
+------------------+---------------+------------------+
| Gomez            | Wilfredo      | 1208.21879982006 | 
| Vazquez          | Wilfredo      | 372.720659871131 | 
| Zaragoza         | Daniel        | 287.024189406331 | 
| Fenech           | Jeff          |  276.36590600126 | 
| Palma            | Sergio Victor | 248.246054464607 | 
| McKinney         | Kennedy       | 210.832242823412 | 
| Cardona          | Ricardo       | 191.155639341615 | 
| Monshipour       | Mahyar        | 188.182253967978 | 
| Callejas         | Victor        | 169.911930926533 | 
| Harris Patterson | Tracy         | 157.480353677769 | 
| Jones            | Junior        | 149.268102592739 | 
| Cruz             | Leonardo      | 146.054218687044 | 
| Lee              | Seung Hoon    | 120.922072872988 | 
| Salud            | Jesus         |  119.61289622423 | 
| Garza            | Jaime         | 112.776374163727 | 
| Mendoza          | Luis Enrique  | 108.726849469466 | 
| Payakaroon       | Samart        | 104.460710409142 | 
| Meza             | Juan          | 102.637826983297 | 
| Espinoza         | Louie         | 101.927766698754 | 
| Ayala            | Mike          | 100.680543642372 | 
+------------------+---------------+------------------+

Super Flyweight

+---------------+------------+------------------+
| last_name     | first_name | rd               |
+---------------+------------+------------------+
| Watanabe      | Jiro       | 484.189747850599 | 
| Galaxy        | Khaosai    | 418.946246582181 | 
| Roman         | Gilberto   | 392.301832987667 | 
| Moon          | Sung-Kil   | 364.823906650653 | 
| Tapia         | Johnny     | 301.416295595671 | 
| Tokuyama      | Masamori   | 274.776152549407 | 
| Ballas        | Gustavo    | 231.402723986849 | 
| Rojas         | Jesus Kiki | 200.001861932062 | 
| Orono         | Rafael     | 157.977274643532 | 
| Dutch Boy Gym | Samson     | 157.351040298659 | 
| Rojas         | Sugar Baby | 150.377592543305 | 
| Kawashima     | Hiroshi    | 143.598558876025 | 
| Sithoar       | Yokthai    | 128.921106747529 | 
| Ruiz          | Jose       | 111.655489944883 | 
| Poontarat     | Payao      | 95.0808093561432 | 
| Goitia        | Alimi      | 89.2827526394644 | 
| Iida          | Satoshi    |  86.925112616776 | 
| Pical         | Ellyas     | 84.4989121536505 | 
| Sithbaobay    | Thanomsak  | 84.0826624904653 | 
| Romero        | Danny      | 83.5166918271778 | 
+---------------+------------+------------------+

Minimumweight

+------------+------------+------------------+
| last_name  | first_name | rd               |
+------------+------------+------------------+
| Lopez      | Ricardo    | 756.106960500108 | 
| Alvarez    | Rosendo    | 292.083545904823 | 
| Ohashi     | Hideyuki   | 129.485662722425 | 
| Sakkreerin | Fahlan     | 127.772876376421 | 
| Petelo     | Zolani     | 122.014982018823 | 
| Bustos     | Isaac      | 119.433445531141 | 
| Hoshino    | Keitaro    | 107.992346682756 | 
| Porpaoin   | Songkram   | 100.310918968581 | 
| Chavez     | Eric       | 82.4438349571454 | 
| Gamboa     | Joma       | 82.1568769468327 | 
| Lin        | Rocky      | 82.0897398890238 | 
| Melchor    | Manny      | 75.0932137899909 | 
| Magramo    | Ronnie     | 74.2530782816648 | 
| Choi       | Hi-Yong    | 70.1981080765772 | 
| Pongsawang | Fahsang    | 66.0250213779703 | 
| Tabanas    | Andy       | 56.6847916453342 | 
| Rubillar   | Ernesto    | 52.4504353744218 | 
+------------+------------+------------------+

[JCS]

Witherspoon/Arreola... I would've expected a great deal more movement from that result.

Is this a matter of the DQ not carrying enough weight? I think this should be seriously looked at, as most DQs are very legit wins.

[computerrank]

Witherspoon/Arreola... I would've expected a great deal more movement from that result.

Is this a matter of the DQ not carrying enough weight? I think this should be seriously looked at, as most DQs are very legit wins.

The rating for DQ is quite ok from my perspective.

The weight depends on the number of rounds boxed - here only 3 -> weight = 3/12 = 0.25. This is equivalent to wins on points - a short bout makes a lower weight.

The clearness of decision is 0.5 by default, which is equvalent to MD and SD by default. Otherwise the CD factor may be lower depending on close scores, but not higher, which is again equivalent to wins on points. In this bout we had CD = 0.5.

[JCS]

Witherspoon/Arreola... I would've expected a great deal more movement from that result.

Is this a matter of the DQ not carrying enough weight? I think this should be seriously looked at, as most DQs are very legit wins.

The rating for DQ is quite ok from my perspective.

The weight depends on the number of rounds boxed - here only 3 -> weight = 3/12 = 0.25. This is equivalent to wins on points - a short bout makes a lower weight.

The clearness of decision is 0.5 by default, which is equvalent to MD and SD by default. Otherwise the CD factor may be lower depending on close scores, but not higher, which is again equivalent to wins on points. In this bout we had CD = 0.5.

Not sure if I agree with that... I'm sure if research was done, a vast majority of DQ losses would have been KO/TKO losses. I am not saying it should have full value, but I believe it should be close.

Also, why would the DQ round matter??

[computerrank]

Witherspoon/Arreola... I would've expected a great deal more movement from that result.

Is this a matter of the DQ not carrying enough weight? I think this should be seriously looked at, as most DQs are very legit wins.

The rating for DQ is quite ok from my perspective.

The weight depends on the number of rounds boxed - here only 3 -> weight = 3/12 = 0.25. This is equivalent to wins on points - a short bout makes a lower weight.

The clearness of decision is 0.5 by default, which is equvalent to MD and SD by default. Otherwise the CD factor may be lower depending on close scores, but not higher, which is again equivalent to wins on points. In this bout we had CD = 0.5.

Not sure if I agree with that... I'm sure if research was done, a vast majority of DQ losses would have been KO/TKO losses. I am not saying it should have full value, but I believe it should be close.

Also, why would the DQ round matter??

It is basically a decision on points - a big deciding point by the referee - there is no KO or TKO in place.

As in decisions on points - the shorter the bout - the less clear the decision base applicable. A DQ in the first round doesn't say much about the boxing achievements in the bout.

[JCS]

I guess we will have to agree to disagree... but I think a DQ should be worth more.

It should make no difference if the DQ happens in the 1st or 12th round, as there is no indication to tell us how close the fight was. I think this is a flaw.

[Smally Big Plums]

...why Kelly Pavlik is No1 in the boxrec p4p ratings?

[JCS]

...why Kelly Pavlik is No1 in the boxrec p4p ratings?

He has distanced himself the furthest away from the competition in his own division, more so than any other boxer.

In other words, you have a very strong boxer in a weak division.

[allworld80]

BR being accused of anti PR rankings

http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/sho ... hp?t=81539

[Asterix]

BR being accused of anti PR rankings

http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/sho ... hp?t=81539

I can't see myself ever becoming a regular poster there.

[metropol]

Im sure this may have been discussed , but why has cotto gone out of the p4p top 25 ? Is it just me or does this seem a bit wrong? Hatton is still there and he hasnt done anything convincing since mayweather.

[sockdolager]

Im sure this may have been discussed , but why has cotto gone out of the p4p top 25 ? Is it just me or does this seem a bit wrong? Hatton is still there and he hasnt done anything convincing since mayweather.

Mainly because when you lose to the #1 guy you wont be free falling. When you lose to someone not in the top 25-30, you free fall. I don't agree with it completely, I still have Cotto in the top 20 but that system is based on different criteria.

[JCS]

We really need a sticky or disclaimer for that list as these questions get very annoying.

Its about which fighters are the most dominant with regards to their current division.

[Asterix]

We really need a sticky or disclaimer for that list as these questions get very annoying.

Its about which fighters are the most dominant with regards to their current division.

I think there should be a disclaimer on the main website.

[BlueRoomProject]

I go by this one anyway:

POUND-FOR-POUND

MANNY PACQUIAO Lightweight/Jr. Lightweight
JOE CALZAGHE Super Middle/Lt. Heavyweight
JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ Jr. Lightweight
BERNARD HOPKINS Lt. Heavyweight
ISRAEL VAZQUEZ Jr. Featherweight
ANTONIO MARGARITO Welterweight
KELLY PAVLIK Middleweight
CRISTIAN MIJARES Jr. Bantamweight
RAFAEL MARQUEZ Jr. Featherweight
MIGUEL COTTO Welterweight

[sockdolager]

Here is my top 15 list

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. Kelly Pavlik
5. Bernard Hopkins
6. Israel Vazquez
7. Wladimir Klitschko
8. Antonio Margarito
9. Rafael Marquez
10. Cristian Mijares
11. David Haye
12. Miguel Cotto
13. Shane Mosley
14. Arthur Abraham
15. Ricky Hatton

Go ahead, blast away...

[Asterix]

The BBC's: http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/boxing/4181323.stm

1. Floyd Mayweather - Welterweight
United States (39 wins, 0 losses, 0 draws, 24KOs)

2. Manny Pacquiao - Super-featherweight
Philippines (47-3-2, 35KOs)

3. Joe Calzaghe - Super-middleweight
Wales (45-0, 32KOs)

4. Antonio Margarito - Welterweight
Mexico (37-5, 27KOs)

5. Miguel Cotto - Welterweight
Puerto Rico (32-1, 26KOs)

6. Juan Manuel Marquez - Super-featherweight
Mexico (48-4-1, 35KOs)

7. Kelly Pavlik - Middleweight
United States (34-0, 30KOs)

8. Israel Vazquez - Super-bantamweight
Mexico (43-4, 31KOs)

9. Ricky Hatton - Light-welterweight
England (44-1, 31KOs)

10. Paul Williams - Welterweight
United States (34-1, 25KOs)

[metropol]

We really need a sticky or disclaimer for that list as these questions get very annoying.

Its about which fighters are the most dominant with regards to their current division.

Maybe a stickey would be a good idea. how are these lists judged? now if you dont think cotto is inside the top 25 in the world well god love you.

[JCS]

We really need a sticky or disclaimer for that list as these questions get very annoying.

Its about which fighters are the most dominant with regards to their current division.

Maybe a stickey would be a good idea. how are these lists judged? now if you dont think cotto is inside the top 25 in the world well god love you.

Its computerized. Nuff said.

[Axe]

The BBC's: http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/boxing/4181323.stm

1. Floyd Mayweather - Welterweight
United States (39 wins, 0 losses, 0 draws, 24KOs)

2. Manny Pacquiao - Super-featherweight
Philippines (47-3-2, 35KOs)

3. Joe Calzaghe - Super-middleweight
Wales (45-0, 32KOs)

4. Antonio Margarito - Welterweight
Mexico (37-5, 27KOs)

5. Miguel Cotto - Welterweight
Puerto Rico (32-1, 26KOs)

6. Juan Manuel Marquez - Super-featherweight
Mexico (48-4-1, 35KOs)

7. Kelly Pavlik - Middleweight
United States (34-0, 30KOs)

8. Israel Vazquez - Super-bantamweight
Mexico (43-4, 31KOs)

9. Ricky Hatton - Light-welterweight
England (44-1, 31KOs)

10. Paul Williams - Welterweight
United States (34-1, 25KOs)

So Williams, nowhere near the top 25 P4P a week ago, jumps into the top 10 after Margo's win.

I can see the logic there, but disagree on this particular case.

[ProboxerUK]

Can some one tell me how Pavlik got #1 without fighting?

Clear bias against UK fighters.

[Coco]

It's actually done on a points scoring system, u may not agree with the system but it has nothing to do with nationalities

[FightFan.com]

Pacquiao is the clear choice for #1 anyway, so it's not like it matters.

[pundit]

Can some one tell me how Pavlik got #1 without fighting?

Clear bias against UK fighters.

Damn. This is the proof that computers are racist.

Btw, #1 is of course PBF, #2 Pacman.