Everyone's P4P List

[alexpaterson]

1st Mayweather
2nd Pacquiao
3rd Marquez
4th Hopkins
5th Cotto
6th Williams
7th Dawson
8th Mosely
9th Donaire
10th Calderon

I have Mayweather ahead of Pacquiao because i think hes achieved more than Pac but if Marquez beats PBF he goes top and if Pac beats Cotto he goes ahead of PBF

[garthy]

I'm really not sure on the list but wondered why everyone seems to put Mosely above Cotto
when Cotto has proven to be a better fighter when they met.

1. Pacman (Best boxer at the moment)
2. Hopkins (Best at Light-heavy made a fool of a one dimensional straight lined Pavlik)
3. Marquez (Best lightweight after overcoming Diaz in a all action fight)
4. Kessler (Best Super-middleweight by far would destroy Froch or Bute)
5. Cotto (Best Welterweight and Mosely knows it, winner fights Pacman)
6. Abrahams (Would destroy Pavlik, Pavlik dodging fight opting to fight a past KO'd oponent of Abrahams)

I've only picked 6 as after that I would either be naming some of the same weight divisions or naming fighters I havent seen enough of which would be wrong to go by mostly stats.

[hitman_hatton1]

1st Mayweather
2nd Pacquiao
3rd Marquez
4th Hopkins
5th Cotto
6th Williams
7th Dawson
8th Mosely
9th Donaire
10th Calderon

I have Mayweather ahead of Pacquiao because i think hes achieved more than Pac but if Marquez beats PBF he goes top and if Pac beats Cotto he goes ahead of PBF

for me these lists are a case of what have u done for me lately.

the janet jackson song in other words.

and pac has beaten marquez (close), diaz, oscar & hatton.

also he beat oscar and hatton more convincingly than floyd did.

pac is a 6 weight world champion (he won the feather title off barrera remember).

while mayweather has been off for nearly 18 months now.

[hitman_hatton1]

I'm really not sure on the list but wondered why everyone seems to put Mosely above Cotto
when Cotto has proven to be a better fighter when they met.

but mosley has just spanked margo.

margo beat cotto.

again another case of what have u done for me lately.

the mosley-cotto fight was closely contested as well don't forget.

[alexpaterson]

1st Mayweather
2nd Pacquiao
3rd Marquez
4th Hopkins
5th Cotto
6th Williams
7th Dawson
8th Mosely
9th Donaire
10th Calderon

I have Mayweather ahead of Pacquiao because i think hes achieved more than Pac but if Marquez beats PBF he goes top and if Pac beats Cotto he goes ahead of PBF

for me these lists are a case of what have u done for me lately.


the janet jackson song in other words.

and pac has beaten marquez (close), diaz, oscar & hatton.

also he beat oscar and hatton more convincingly than floyd did.

pac is a 6 weight world champion (he won the feather title off barrera remember).

while mayweather has been off for nearly 18 months now.

I see where your coming from but i feel Mayweather is the better fighter p4p

[hitman_hatton1]

I see where your coming from but i feel Mayweather is the better fighter p4p

when they fight i also think floyd will come out on top.

but before he does i think pac deserves the nod for now.

floyd's performance against marquez will likely change my mind.

it's very close at the moment.

one thing is for sure those 2 have to fight each other.

the perfect fight to end the decade.