Cannibal wrote:Floyd is one of the most carefully managed fighters of all time. If Hatton had won the Pac fight, he would have had no hesitations about jumping into a rematch and cashing in. I don't think Floyd gave as good as he got in that interview, I think he came up short when asked perfectly valid questions.
Floyd's record since moving up from lightweight shows a lot of signs of extremely carefully chosen opponents.
Corley - Corley was off the back of a loss to Judah and has lost every time he made the step up to the very top. Despite this he still managed to hurt Floyd.
Bruseles - B fighter
Gatti - The fight that launched him into PPV. Gatti was an over achiever even in his prime and this was at the very end of Gatti's career after many wars. His style was all wrong for Mayweather and he was nearly a stationary punching bag in front of Floyd.
Then he jumped up in weight without fighting ANY of the top men at 140.
Mitchell - Blitzed by Tszyu 2 fights previous and shot to pieces by the time Floyd got him.
Judah - Was coming off a shock loss to Carlos Baldomir of all people.
Baldomir - Then he fought Baldomir himself, in which he was a heavy favourite. Disappointing as well when you factor in the fights that could have been in its place.
DLH - Again jumps up without fighting any of the top at 147. Gets pushed by a DLH who has seen better days and gasses towards the end to give Floyd a SD win.
Hatton - Probably his best win since Castillo since Hatton on paper was a top, undefeated fighter in his prime. Was tailor made for Floyd though and Pac's demolition of him has put doubts on just how good a performance it was. Pac also beat Hatton at his stronger weight.
Floyd then "retired" rather than face Cotto who was also undefeated at the time and the list of great fighters that he didn't fight was longer than the ones he did.
Very very harsh mate.
Corley lost to Judah but he was seen as a solid enough fighter and Floyd was acclimating to 140. Corley had Cotto dancing in the ring, remember that. Corley would have beaten Hatton with his slickness if you ask me too. It was a good win where Floyd outboxed Corley all night.
Bruseles was a keep busy fight, they all have them.
The Gatti fight was talked about for years and it was a great fight for making getting Floyd known plus making a lot of money. That fight and the manner of victory gave him a lot of good publicity.
You say he jumped up from 140 without facing any of the top men there. I believe Hatton was saying he needed 3 warm up fights in order to fight Floyd at the time. Hatton took his hiding when the time came anyway so why criticise floyd for not fighting a man who is 100x inferior (as we have seen).
Mitchell was his first 147 fight and yes he was shot. You say Judah lost to Baldomir and floyd fought him but floyd went and fought and beat baldomir (the lineal champ at 147) by shutout.
He went up to 154 to fight DLH and weighed 150 for the fight (a harder fight than fighting Cotto/Margarito or Mosley imo) and he beat DLH on everyones scorecards in fairness. A great performance UP IN WEIGHT against a GOOD DLH who pushed him all the way.
Floyd deserves credit in my opinion. I see him beating JMM and Pacman in quick succession. From there, he has to fight a legit 147 pounder (Cotto, Mosley etc, whoever is the lineal champ) or even I will criticize Floyd. But for now, he is coming back from 1.5 years off against what I believe is the #1 pound for pound fighter in the world (he did beat pacquaio twice after all). That is good enough for me.