If Shane had beat Winky and fought Tito...?

[Counter-puncher]

Shane was supposed to be going on to fight Trinidad, had he got through the Winky test.

who wins?

i personally thought Tito was made to make Shane look good. yes Shane was troubled by jabbers/bigger men at times, but tito's jab wasn't as good as Forrest's or winky's (or Oscar's), IMO.

[Goodnight, Irene]

Around '03 or '04, Trinidad was a spent force. Mosley wins handily, even at Jr. Middleweight.

Now, around 1999-2000, at Welter, that could turn out to be a different story. Maybe.

[allworld80]

Mosley, brutally.

[I Feel Fine]

Is there really any doubt? I would also pick the Shane who beat Oscar the first time to beat the Trinidad who (bad decision or not) beat Oscar.

[danieljenkins]

tito and welter imo

[Goodnight, Irene]

No explanations forthcoming from the three who've inexplicably backed Trinidad

[dajuggernaut]

The Trinidad that beat Mayorga looked really good.

[Goodnight, Irene]

The Trinidad that beat Mayorga looked really good.

Good enough to beat Mosley, in your estimation?

[dajuggernaut]

The Trinidad that beat Mayorga looked really good.

Good enough to beat Mosley, in your estimation?

No.