Why does BOXREC mention incorrect data?????

Post Reply
bangkok_gurentai
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 39
Joined: 24 Aug 2009, 00:26

Why does BOXREC mention incorrect data?????

Post by bangkok_gurentai »

Regarding to fight of Kokiet Group in Thailand on February 23rd, 2010, i posted fight result in this folum but administrator issued another - incorrect result - on database!
I dont know why such matter happen????

http://boxrec.com/show_display.php?show_id=596690

The result of Paiparob Kokietgym (Pornobnom) is TKO in 9Round as PABA's official site mentioned and I already reported like that too.

But BOXREC issued that RTD in round 9. There was ring to start round 9 but challenger can't stand up and show will to give up, so referee stop the game.

Most of time i went to stadium and check judge paper directly. and confirm with the judge who joined the game too.
But ok, if BOXREC upload issue based on old reporter, not new reporter like me, even if reporting incorrect results.....


Bangkok Gurentai
Emaster
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 471
Joined: 18 May 2008, 15:01

Re: Why does BOXREC mention incorrect data?????

Post by Emaster »

bangkok_gurentai wrote:The result of Paiparob Kokietgym (Pornobnom) is TKO in 9Round as PABA's official site mentioned and I already reported like that too.

But BOXREC issued that RTD in round 9. There was ring to start round 9 but challenger can't stand up and show will to give up, so referee stop the game.
BoxRec shows RTD 8 as no fighting took place in the ninth round so that the fight is considered to have been stopped between rounds eight and nine regardless whether the bell to start the ninth round had rung. Here is a discussion on the TKO vs. RTD issue.
bangkok_gurentai
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 39
Joined: 24 Aug 2009, 00:26

Re: Why does BOXREC mention incorrect data?????

Post by bangkok_gurentai »

I understand about TKO and RTD issue. It should be discussion.
But then

1. why does BOXREC not mentioned name of counter part of Phupha Por Nobnom??? The name of counter part is Pompetch Sor Thiepkhun as i reported,

2. why does BOXREC mentioned result of Duangpetch as UD??? There was no announce about point. Only show the win of Duangpetch.

If the reporter went to stadium or ask judge about result of Duangpetch directly, he should know "1".

?????


Bangkok Gurentai
AntonS
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6406
Joined: 16 Sep 2003, 04:38

Re: Why does BOXREC mention incorrect data?????

Post by AntonS »

If the bell sounded for rd 9 it should be TKO 9 @ 0:01
It was inserted as such, but changed by another editor. I'll check his source.
Cheers
bangkok_gurentai
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 39
Joined: 24 Aug 2009, 00:26

Re: Why does BOXREC mention incorrect data?????

Post by bangkok_gurentai »

Thanx,

Next time, I will try to take photo of judge paper and insert link here.
if not do, no-one believe me.
Post Reply