where do people rate jack root?

[Adamj1987]

i dont know too much about him other than he was successor to jim jeffries and lost the title in the first defnce

[SaadOffTheDeck]

He just fought Hart for the vacant title, Jack never had any legitimate claim to it.. Root claimed himself Light heavyweight ruler and then he got whipped. I don't rate him at all to be blunt about it.

[granberry]

Jack Johnson said Root had the ideal left jab.

But what did he know.

Halfwits posting on the internet 100 years later who never saw Jack Root fight know more.

[Adamj1987]

Jack Johnson said Root had the ideal left jab.

But what did he know.

Halfwits posting on the internet 100 years later who never saw Jack Root fight know more.

that seems to be the way lately

[kikibalt]

Jack Root, Joe Stanley and Billy Peacock

[Collins2000]

Jack Johnson said Root had the ideal left jab.

But what did he know.

Halfwits posting on the internet 100 years later who never saw Jack Root fight know more.

that seems to be the way lately

Lately?

It's always been the way in here.

[SaadOffTheDeck]

The fact that granberry saw jack Root fight tells a lot. If he is between 115 and 140 years old, I'm impressed.

I've never fell in line with the opinion that everything older ruled. Root didn't get a whole lot done. I've never put together an extensive Light heavyweight list. But i can't imagine he would crack the top 75 or so. Maybe squeeze in a top 100.

[granberry]

The fact that granberry saw jack Root fight tells a lot. If he is between 115 and 140 years old, I'm impressed.

I've never fell in line with the opinion that everything older ruled. Root didn't get a whole lot done. I've never put together an extensive Light heavyweight list. But i can't imagine he would crack the top 75 or so. Maybe squeeze in a top 100.

Yes

I saw Jack Root fight George Gardner.

I have owned that film for years.

Obviously Saad hasn't seen Root fight

and doesn't even know that films of Root exist.

Par for the course on an internet boxing site like this.

[granberry]

The fact that granberry saw jack Root fight tells a lot. If he is between 115 and 140 years old, I'm impressed.

I've never fell in line with the opinion that everything older ruled. Root didn't get a whole lot done. I've never put together an extensive Light heavyweight list. But i can't imagine he would crack the top 75 or so. Maybe squeeze in a top 100.

I also have a film of Corbett fighting Fitzsimmons in 1897.

It is a pity that posters like Sadd are not aware of such films.

Saad's post is a very sad indicator of the level of posters on internet "boxing" sites.

[SaadOffTheDeck]

So you've seen Root knocked out once. Where do you rate him? Are you even capable of discussing a simple topic? You're a bitter individual.

[granberry]

So you've seen Root knocked out once. Where do you rate him? Are you even capable of discussing a simple topic? You're a bitter individual.

Saad exposes himself as being ignorant of the existence of any films of Root.

And all he can do is offer ad hominem attacks in reply.

[Controversial]

http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-fr ... 946497D6CF

[Knucklez]

Root beat a young Fireman. Big deal.

[dempseyfire]

To say he doesn't rank in the top 75 light heavyweights is absurd. The guy beat Kid McCoy, George Gardner, Jim Flynn, Marvin Hart, Frank Childs, George Byers and drew with Tommy Ryan.

He definitely makes my top 40 175lbers of all time and possibly top 25-30 . . haven't put a list together that high.

But ignore Granberry's attacks . . .I'm shocked he's still here when a third of the threads around here are locked b/c of his propensity for conflict.

[SaadOffTheDeck]

Light heavyweight is a stacked division, 25-30 would be absurd to me. I wouldn't rate Root over Marvin Johnson.

[granberry]

Light heavyweight is a stacked division, 25-30 would be absurd to me. I wouldn't rate Root over Marvin Johnson.

How can you "rate" Root when you know nothing about him?

[Collins2000]

Light heavyweight is a stacked division, 25-30 would be absurd to me. I wouldn't rate Root over Marvin Johnson.

How can you "rate" Root when you know nothing about him?

Why not post another picture of Ali - Frazier to show what a witty fellow you are.

[granberry]

Light heavyweight is a stacked division, 25-30 would be absurd to me. I wouldn't rate Root over Marvin Johnson.

How can you "rate" Root when you know nothing about him?

Why not post another picture of Ali - Frazier to show what a witty fellow you are.

collins follows me around boxrec, posting his sicko ad hominem attacks.

collins hasn't heard of Jack Root any more than he has heard of Kid Azteca or Juan Zurita.

[Collins2000]

How can you "rate" Root when you know nothing about him?

Why not post another picture of Ali - Frazier to show what a witty fellow you are.

collins follows me around boxrec, posting his sicko ad hominem attacks.

collins hasn't heard of Jack Root any more than he has heard of Kid Azteca or Juan Zurita.

Didn't I just see you post yet another picture of Ali - Frazier in the thread I started?



You seem to be obsessed with Ali. Or do you still call him Clay down at the meeting hall?

[SaadOffTheDeck]

Why not post another picture of Ali - Frazier to show what a witty fellow you are.

collins follows me around boxrec, posting his sicko ad hominem attacks.

collins hasn't heard of Jack Root any more than he has heard of Kid Azteca or Juan Zurita.

Didn't I just see you post yet another picture of Ali - Frazier in the thread I started?



You seem to be obsessed with Ali. Or do you still call him Clay down at the meeting hall?

he's obsessed with many things, unfortunately talking about Boxing isn't one of them. Pretty incredible he hasn't been banned. I'm not sure why I don't have him on ignore, he really is so off the wall that it isn't even irritating. So i have to rate Granberry behind broughton, Irene & Mr Untouchable for suck. But he is definitely in the top 5.

[granberry]

Why not post another picture of Ali - Frazier to show what a witty fellow you are.

collins follows me around boxrec, posting his sicko ad hominem attacks.

collins hasn't heard of Jack Root any more than he has heard of Kid Azteca or Juan Zurita.

Didn't I just see you post yet another picture of Ali - Frazier in the thread I started?



You seem to be obsessed with Ali. Or do you still call him Clay down at the meeting hall?

collins is trashing another thread with his sicko ad hominem attacks.

Not a word about Jack Root from collins, who only has disruption and trashing of the threads of others to offer.

[ThatOne]

collins follows me around boxrec, posting his sicko ad hominem attacks.

collins hasn't heard of Jack Root any more than he has heard of Kid Azteca or Juan Zurita.

Didn't I just see you post yet another picture of Ali - Frazier in the thread I started?



You seem to be obsessed with Ali. Or do you still call him Clay down at the meeting hall?

collins is trashing another thread with his sicko ad hominem attacks.

Not a word about Jack Root from collins, who only has disruption and trashing of the threads of others to offer.

The thread went down hill when you disrespected SaadOffTheDeck.

[granberry]

collins has his whole crew here now to trash this thread.

Not a word about Jack Root from any of them.

They never heard of Jack Root, but they are here to trash another boxrec thread.

[ThatOne]

collins has his whole crew here now to trash this thread.

Not a word about Jack Root from any of them.

They never heard of Jack Root, but they are here to trash another boxrec thread.

Maybe if you didn't disrespect your fellow posters you would not feel the sting of their ire.