Hmmm. Not sure I agree with you on this post Alp.Ambling Alp wrote:A few more that I don't believe anyone has mentioned that really have much of a case:
Edwin Rosario
Charley Mitchell
Laslo Papp
gime me your 3 weakest IBHOF'ers...
-
The Great John L
- Heavyweight
- Posts: 4351
- Joined: 26 Jul 2005, 19:37
Re: gime me your 3 weakest IBHOF'ers...
-
Ambling Alp
- Heavyweight
- Posts: 3627
- Joined: 15 Jul 2005, 22:31
Re: gime me your 3 weakest IBHOF'ers...
Well, I guess Rosario did have a few nice wins. I just don't know if it's enough to offset his losses. Mitchell is difficult because much of his record is probably incomplete. Would have been interesting had he fought "Nonpariel" Dempsey or Fitzsimmons.
Papp is one that really bugs me. (He never beat a contender as a professional.) This has to be based compeletely on his amateur career. Is a fighter's amatuer career even a factor when voting for others? If so the lack of an outstanding amateur career should prevent the induction of many Hall of Famers.
Besides Stevenson and other great amateurs aren't in.
Papp is one that really bugs me. (He never beat a contender as a professional.) This has to be based compeletely on his amateur career. Is a fighter's amatuer career even a factor when voting for others? If so the lack of an outstanding amateur career should prevent the induction of many Hall of Famers.
Besides Stevenson and other great amateurs aren't in.